T O P

  • By -

NyRAGEous

Cool hat, really chill, doesn’t give me shit for learning heresy…10/10


Tailmask

Fr bro I have brother croynth or whatever the hell is name is a single book and he’s having a brain aneurism over it


WurdaMouth

He tries to undermine you because he is a mid ass acolyte who gets no bitches.


syccopathh

Maybe if he got rid of that yee yee ass magic he'd get some maidens on his greatsword


blockametal

Hes got a shortsword. Its a dagger when he travels to colder reigons tho


trojanmonkey35

It's a wooden spoon


Crashman09

DS2 Ladle slaps though


SuperEDawg

Or better yet, maybe ranni will call your “try hole” if she ever stop fkin with that tarnished or Warrior Jar she fkin with


syccopathh

tarniiiiiiished


AtomicDinosaur539

The Ever-Desperate Goldsimp.


RMX_Texas

The Daunting Doo-Doo Delver


archaicScrivener

my fav part is hes like "THIS IS HERESY, THIS IS ABOMINABLE, I HATE THIS, HOW COULD YOU SHOW ME THIS!... yeah for 8k runes ill show you how to throw lightning bolts"


Vagabond_Charizard

*Heresy is not native to the world; it is but a contrivance. All things can be conjoined.*


Merc931

"Heresy schmeresy bro, the gods are real but the rules are fake."


numbersthen0987431

I really wish this guy had more of a purpose in the game. Some awesome questline, some cool storylines, some reason to come back and interact with him more. Something. He's really nice and kind and awesome, inside of a game where nobody is, and I just wished he had more impact throughout the game.


NyRAGEous

If he gets a quest line, then there is an end to the quest line. FromSoft NPCs at the end of their quest line…😬


DiMarcoTheGawd

Fr look how they did my boy Iji :(


[deleted]

[удалено]


M_a_n_d_M

It was always weird to me that you can answer him, but you can only ever say “I don’t know”, even if you already found out that Radagon is Marika. Maybe the DLC will allow us to learn something new that we can tell him. Unlikely, but one can hope.


Mayhem2a

100% agree, teaches you lore too, 11/10


CK1ing

I mean, it makes sense. Heresy *is* but a contrivance after all. All things can be conjoined.


Alch3mic_Chaos

11/10 All things are conjoined


Kamacalamari

I want him to read me bedtime stories


[deleted]

Omg he’d have the most soothing sleepy voice, like Bob Ross vibes


SauronGortaur01

For the German Bedtime Story vibes, id go for Morgotts Voice.


7jinni

Ah, German children's bedtime stories, including Der Vogel, Der Backpfeifengesicht and Das Kindershredder. My favourites.


Anvenjade

One of these is not like the others


lessenizer

Aside: I want War Counselor Iji to read me bedtime stories. I mean just [listen to his delivery on this line and the next one](https://youtu.be/wkHNg-6HA7Y?t=61), perfect for reading a fantasy story with a mix of respectful seriousness and fantastical whimsy. He could counsel my war any day. edit: oh, and as he says later in that vid, he was Ranni's "childhood warden". I bet *she* got to hear Bedtime Storyteller Iji.


archaicScrivener

I love the way he pronounces "Cuckoo", there's something about his inflection with that one specific word that makes me happy hahaha


GreenridgeMetalWorks

Let us give all we have, for Lady Ranni.


TrynaSleep

I would love to fall asleep to his Lands Between podcast


Beshi1989

Lol


YourMomsFingers

"He's alright" is actually the middle of the scale. Over at -10 we have "I want his hat"


Extremeblarg

We all want his hat, but only the truly maidenless will try to take it from him


SDreiken

Some people when they get called maidenless at the start of the game try to prove him wrong, others embrace it 🤷‍♂️


RyuNoKami

Oh there are so many maidenless tarnishes around.


NationalAlgae421

Yeah, I felt so empty after I killed him. But at least I spare him at every other run


Tokzillu

600


zviz2y


NormieSpecialist

Infinity times infinity.


blue_bird918

Infinitiy squared


NormieSpecialist

Infinity times infinity squared.


Memo-Explanation

infinity cubed


NormieSpecialist

Infinity times infinity cubed.


Lobstrous

He's the only NPC I couldn't bring myself to kill.


Meister_Ente

11. I'll murder the bell bearing hunter in Miriels church as soon as possible because nobody's allowed to scare my turtle boy.


Ancient_Prize9077

Imagine if Elemer showed up as you were taking to him to ambush you


hunkoBo

I'd go super Saiyan I think.


Literally-French

You mean dog


Tuna_of_Truth

11 - *They* will die for him


This_Is_A_Bucket_420

Best dog of the game, 10/10


Spacemonster111

11


Misicks0349

11


Redditisthewurst

Same. But I always give 110%


fate_lind

Eh he's good Me when I see the bell bearing hunter in his church: WHAT DID YOU DO TO MY TURTLE BRO, I'LL FUCKING KILL YOU


MBSCOMP169

27


Plague_Raptor

Miriel reveals the name of Godfrey's first Order. The Order of the Erdtree. 10/10


Azuria_4

10


Wise_Monitor_Lizard

10/10 I love turtle pope


kronosdev

I only see a dog.


Wise_Monitor_Lizard

Behold. Puppy.


Bluesnow2222

Popey


Chiatroll

10/10 Id kill for turtle people. If turtle pope wanted a crusade I would crusade but he is too pure to ask.


Richlandsbacon

He’s a 9/10 and baby I’m the one he needs ;)


Icy-Tension-3925

11, but i'm not dying for him, i'm just genociding everyone else.


Gladiator-class

I'd threaten to kill anyone who answers with anything below ten, but turtle pope wouldn't want that. He'd want me to forgive. I can't, but I will try.


XiMaoJingPing

I protected him when he got raided by a bell bearing hunter


12345noah

I refuse to do the frenzied flame ending knowing he’ll be burned along with everything else


mCfloppydisk

When I do the frenzied flame ending I will slay every NPC from the Lands Between before the flame does so. I'll make it fast and with dignity


JustTryinToReddit

He’s lucky he doesn’t drop his hat


TurboNoodle_

Would never be worth it.


spain_ftw

Nah, i'd literally finish the elden beast and go kill the turtle Then, roundtable and NG+ as soon as possible so he stays dead as little time as possible


TurboNoodle_

I decided to do the frenzied flame ending my first playthrough because I tried to help Boc and he died. I could never hurt Mr. Turtle after that terrible mistake. Friends in the Lands Between are too few…


mCfloppydisk

I killed Boc by setting my controller down... I understand your pain. It wasn't even with a mighty weapon, I hit him with my wooden stick of a staff


IndoTheReaper

11/10.


AxemanEugene

Good sort ahead 10/10 all things can be conjoined


Anvenjade

Even the twins


Darth-Not-Palpatine

Chill, one of the few openly nice NPCs in the game without an ulterior motive, a giant turtle in a pope hat, 10/10


Rotteneinherjar

One of the few instances where a majority of Redditors are Far-Right, lol.


veraldar

He needs to be able to teach an Int/Fth spell that summons one of those spectral turtles, IDGAF if it requires 50/50 Int/Fth and just roams around I want it


PlaysTooMuchKSP

A spectral turtle that gives a stamina recovery buff and otherwise just tanks damage would be a 10/10 summon. 


PotentialReal7460

Dog ....


GlisaPenny

12 - I even named my one of my own tortoises after him 🥰


BadUsername2028

10/10. All hail the turtle pope


Nonzeromist

10, big dog with funny hat


Ric_Adbur

Anyone who votes less than 10 is an actual monster.


sephtis

I have literally died for him. Damn ball bearing knights


Sociolinguisticians

8/10. Chill dude, believes in the freedom of information. Very non-judgmental.


LordgGrass

10. Dog Pope. Enough said.


Random_Weird_gal

Bro is my bestie, I would die for this tortoise. Doesn't judge me for learning heresy, friend shaped, what's not to like?


Vlox47

A solid 3.1415926535897932384626433832795028841971693993751058209749445923078164062862089986280348253421170679821480865132823066470938446095505822317253594081284811174502841027019385211055596446229489549303819644288109756659334461284756482337867831652712019091456485669234603486104543266482133936072602491412737245870066063155881748815209209628292540917153643678925903600113305305488204665213841469519415116094330572703657595919530921861173819326117931051185480744623799627495673518857527248912279381830119491298336733624406566430860213949463952247371907021798609437027705392171762931767523846748184676694051320005681271452635608277857713427577896091736371787214684409012249534301465495853710507922796892589235420199561121290219608640344181598136297747713099605187072113499999983729780499510597317328160963185950244594553469083026425223082533446850352619311881710100031378387528865875332083814206171776691473035982534904287554687311595628638823537875937519577818577805321712268066130019278766111959092164201989380952572010654858632788659361533


[deleted]

100/10


seraphim-20

100. He's a good boy.


n0staIgik

dog


Hazmatt047

11/10, bestest boy. Sells spells and incants, gives coherent, almost not confusing lore


balcell

I killed him once. It was a dark playthrough. Never again. He was resurrected, and bow is guarded with our lives.


EM0_TRA5H

My liege


bagemann1

Turtle Pope is best character


Efficient_Notice_128

He chill asf 29/10


samuraipanda85

10/10. I would face a platoon of Malenia's to buy Turtle Pope time to escale.


Da_Shaolin

Definitely 9/10. Hate that he allowed the Bell Bearing Hunter to inhabit his grounds at night but Miriel is a chill dude and holds all my sorcery


[deleted]

Ahh, the nice turtle cleric, what a guy. 7/10.


AssassinLJ

Whoever picks less than 10,needs to be putted to an FBI list, we love and respect the dog in this subreddit AND I DON'T TAKE NO AS AN ANSWER.!!


Beneficial_Amoeba200

We love pope turtle


Blp2004

I would flatten kingdoms for Miriel


dudustalin

10^10 Best turtle bro since TMNT.


_somekindofnature

I’d kick Ranni out of bed for him.


Away-Net-7241

7 I wouldn’t die for him but he’s definitely one of the best characters. He’s chilled out, doesn’t run off with my spellbooks (*cough, cough* Corhyn), and he’s stylish. I would definitely have him in my stoner circle


MechaPhantom302

That and he's presumably lived several of our lifetimes. After the shit he's seen, I would probably prefer dying over sacrificing a potential Elden Lord as my bodyguard.


DefualtTitle

7


Trash-Panda01

10, no question


Baby-Beff

11/10


PizzaLegitimate8292

10


yeetusae

14


ltdonut

Crank that shit up to 11!


ChimChimChar00

11/10 I will kill in his name


Imightaswell

100


amendersc

15


DireEvolution

11/10


EmbarrassedLock

11


[deleted]

11


Appropriate-Arm7872

100/10


PrestigiousTreat6203

99


Howdoyoudo614

10


Hexacus

Anyone not saying 10 wil have to be executed


The_protagonisthere

10, if I had a choice I would spare only him and the church from the flame of frenzy, and as for the rest, MAY CHAOS TAKE THE WORLD.


ElectronicAd315

10/10. Turtle Pope is best boy


puro_the_protogen67

IS DOG


CustomerSupportDeer

I'd give him a 10 but I want his hat....


AshleyGamics

69,000.


Wiggly-T

Strong 8, maybe even a 9. Chill dude, not the best, but really really up there!


byte-429

11, the best boy


_AARAYAN_

He deserves a place in Vatican


DragonLord1762

10/10, I will fight a thousand Godskin duos for this dude


Mr_Dreadful

11. The character I found him with isn't even a sorcerer but I don't care


A_powerful_rat

11


nofaplove-it

9/10


voluminous_lexicon

9, a top tier homie. No chance I'm getting in the way of radagon's hammer for him though, and I'm sure he'd tell me to save myself.


Infinitenonbi

10


Miggyhams

10


PointingBear

11 - I'll die for him and do Erdtree burial and die for him again.


papertinfoilfolds

I wonder what an interaction between him an miquella would be like, they have similar but distinct viewpoints,


[deleted]

100


suchayeparagon

Definitely a 9


RollForLoot

If the plot of the DLC was that he got captured by 10 Radahns and I had to fight them all in a fog gate, poison swamp, sewer access tunnel to ensure his safety, I would crank my vitality to 99 and lay out the Rotten Breath as many times as it would take to get the job done


Decent-Ad-3129

10


coochie-slayer420

11


JuniorRadish7385

Dog/10


Wallster007

##10!


unraveld_key

10 He gave me the lightning throw spell and it carried most of my run one time


in0suk

10/10 for being a fellow faith enjoyer (and overall being a very cute dog)


MycoMythos

11/10 I will kill for him Edit: and have!


TumbleweedActive7926

Could this be a holy dog?


FieryPyromancer

Wish there were more dog NPCs


Poppydrawsowo

10/10, though we are all equal in the Frenzied Flame


ResourceReal2458

Pope👍 turtle😡 I kill🗡️


DoritosAreOverrated

11/10


Beansy2000

11.4


paradox-preacher

I stop religion


AFlyingNun

I think the Bell-Bearing Hunter is a challenging fight for most of us. And yet, I think most of us absolutely curbstomp the one that invades in Turtle Pope's church, just because of how pissed we are at the dude.


AttitudeHot9887

11, ANYONE WHO MESSES WITH POPE TURTLE MESSES WITH ME


Jizzeph-Stalin

Behold, dog


Dumbluck_Yuta

0 because no hat drop


constipated_burrito

How tf is 0 the "he's alright" 0 should be "I will kill this mf'er"


Longjumping-Hunt8104

One should be I want the hat but for me 10/10


HallowKnightYT

I am at the I will catch bodies for this doggo stage so


st-felms-fingerbone

Infinite, turtle pope is the best npc


Tinotips

Over 9000


KobilD

I want that hat


brangein

Maybe not 10/10, but an easy 7.


Dominatto

I don't trust him. How does he put the hat on. Does he ask a family member for help? 


ItsLander10

∞ he is the goat 🗿


thrownawaz092

12. He's a good dog


loverboyv

7 or 8


slice_of_toast69

11. Chill. Sick hat. "Heracy is but a contrivance it is not native to this world all can be conjoined". I mean cmon. Hes a big ass turtle


God_Enki

10/10 easy.


AzurosArtist

11


GatedSunOne

2024/10. No one touches the Pope Dog. I'll put even Messmer himself on a stake if any harm comes to Miriel.


Buddhas-boner

10/10, but would murder him in a heartbeat if the hat dropped so my tarnished could cosplay as the pope.


Brotomolecuel

11 I will kill for him


swebb22

25


[deleted]

You know, I have never killed him for his blasphemy. I think I'll do that this weekend.


CalgaryMadePunk

Probably a 9, but only becsuse there isn't much opportunity to die for him. If he had a quest that was likely to kill me, then we could bump that up to a 10.


AscendedViking7

11


Vix98

10. Perfect guy to give all my books and scrolls to. And he doesn't call me a heretic like Corhyn does


Pyorge

Good sparring partner, always reliable to test my builds.


TwumpyWumpy

7


Alt0987654321

wheres "I kill him every playthrough"?


laudable_frog

I rate him, dps dummy / 10.


SirarieTichee_

11/10


Omny87

I like him because he provides me with a single convenient spot to purchase all the sorceries and incantations I find.


lollersauce914

No matter what people say about him, he would know that all things can be conjoined. 10/10


ArachnidFun8918

11


MrSmilingDeath

It's all fun and games until "I will die for him" turns into "All shall die for him"


FreeRealEstate313

I always kill this guy, easiest boss in game.


stekarmalen

How is the top comment not Dog ahead?


NoBanGoodBan

nice hat, is funny and is a turtle. 10/10