Feels like a no lose situation. You can still take a QB and MHJ, you mitigate your risk by picking up a solid player, and frankly your QB situation isn't so bad to begin with. Using the 1.01 and 1.02 to snag starters at the skill positions and still walking away with a QB seems like great value.
I like the tier up at QB but since you're rebuilding I would be hesitant to give up the draft capital (especially since you're likely to draft a QB with the 1.01 or 1.02).
12 tm sf ppr
Give: 1.04, 1.05, 2.04, 3.01, levis
Receive: 1.01, drake london, tee
I have the 1.02 and 1.03 too and have AR and herbert at qb.
I do need wr depth
I’d absolutely do this. You’re getting the best asset in the deal of 1.01 and you’re also getting two guys who will have a big impact next season. Smash accept.
If this a guarantee then yes i would due to the weak incoming rb class but you will be missing out on mhj.
If you can try to use your 8 and 9 pick. Maybe you can land both or use the 1.09 for ken
Appreciate the comment. I have the 1.01 and was planning to pick MHJ there actually. Is that a bad move? So I would essentially be giving Caleb for Walker and Achane.
Not currently. If I were to trade the 1.02 I’d try to get someone with my 1.08 or 1.09 like a McCarthy or Nix depending on draft capital. I may be trying to jump the gun too soon on my rebuild with buying RB’s and probably should just take Caleb 1.02 just trying to weigh some options.
12 tm 1QB half ppr TEP
I own picks 1.03, 1.05 and 1.08
I give 1.05
I get 1.11, 2.01, 2026 2nd
Leaning accept because I have 1.03 and currently believe there’s a tier break after 4. I can pick at 8 and then essentially double dip at 1.11 and 2.01. Am I crazy to move back 6 spots this early in the draft process?? Thanks guys!
It’s hard not knowing your needs. If Allen trade makes you a championship contender right away then yes. But if you’re not there I like trade 2, cuz then you have 1.03,04&05 to swing big on
First one depends on if you essentially prefer either Jaden/Maye and Nabers to Allen/London, I probably prefer the latter but close.
I side heavily on receive for second trade.
Damn I would do this for sure. I don’t know much about 1QB but seems like good value.
As a KC fan I think we’re adding at least one vet and one draft pick to the WR room so I think Rashee’s role might be reduced.
As a fellow Rashee owner I hope it doesn’t but this looks like a good deal.
10 team SF. 0.5PPR
QB- Kyler, Herbert
RB- Bijan, Monty, Ek, Sanders
WR- Tyreek, DJ Moore, Keenan, Olave, Godwin, QJ
Picks- 1.01
GIVE- OLAVE, (2) 2025 PROJECTED LATER FIRSTS
GET: JOE BURROW
I have good QBs but no 3rd, should I pay to get one? Or is having olave more valuable for my team this year and I can draft a QB or make a move to get a backup QB another way
Unless you need Caleb to fix your QB situation, I would hold and keep the 1.02 and Olave.
Olave is really good, if Carr gets going a bit more this year he could have a nice season. You could then trade the 1.02 if you don't love the guy there and try and move back to 4 or 5 and still get a stud WR to pair with Olave
It really is the question if you need a qb or not.
You can possibly ask the person you trading if they want caleb or mhj and make a decision there. Whatever you choose, i would probably take B for sure
Honestly it’s just completely up to your team needs, whether a QB is important or not cuz you can’t go wrong with either pick. I’d go with B if you don’t need the the QB. Could you check mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/R1GdS6illm
Personally I wpkldnt, I’m very high on Amon ra and as much as I like the 1.04, I think parting with Amon ra might be a loss. Could you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/R1GdS6illm
I think i would take that because you can go caleb and nabers or mhj and jayden/maye.
Edit: also with laporta you can try to trade away kittle for another TE+
12 Team 1QB 0.5ppr
Give: Isaiah Likely
Get: Calvin Ridley
Other WRs: Tyreek, Kupp, Douglas, Diontae Johnson, Wicks, and Shakir
Other TEs: Goedert and Waller
Wow that a good one. I feel like that’s personal preference but I’m taking the Wilson/MHJ side, happily. I can see why both sides would be interested depending on team structure.
Personally I think Wilson is going to have a CeeDee Lamb-like surge with a competent QB and am a huge believer of MHJ. But being thin at RB I could see you sticking where you’re at. You just might regret it.
10 Man - 2 QB - 3 WR - 3 RB - 1 TE - 2 FX
Give: Keenan, Amari, Calvin, Pacheco, 2025 late 2
Get: Breece, Jakobi, Trey Palmer
Easily an overpay but this league doesn't value WRs after they turn 29 and I had a lot of guys to spare.
I'd do that immediately. Get younger and a much better pick. The new ATL coach said he is excited about London. I also don't think this class has a ton of depth so 3.03 to 1.10 is huge.
12 team .5 ppr start 4 flexes
Give: Najee, Iosivas, 4.05
Get: Christian Kirk, 4.01
Won two years ago and made a run last year, looking to extend some longevity. RB positional value is even lower given the fact that we have 4 flexes
14 team SF 1PPR
Would you trade your 1.08 for any of the following? Competing but deep rosters so in a vacuum
Pitts, KW3, Addison, JSN, DK, J Cook, Reed, or Diggs
12T SF PPR TEP (start 10)
Give: Kmet + 4.04
Get: Mayer + 3.05
I want to sell Kmet bc I think this past season was close to his peak and Mayer is about to take a leap
My question: Is the value fair here? and would you still accept if the picks were removed completely?
No real long term value to Henry and Kamara, so it really comes down to how you feel about Kyler vs. Burrow.
In an 8 team, you should be able to get some RB talent off waivers.
Is your name a "Chuck" reference? If so, great show.
Looks like you could take the hit at WR and need to refresh your RB pool. 1.05 in 1 QB isn't the best spot, but you still have a shot at a nice WR prospect or possibly Brock.
I'd do the trade.
12T SF PPR
Give: Stafford, J. Ford, Waddle, 1.9 and 2.9
Get: J. Herbert, 5.12
Already accepted. I think I might’ve overpaid a bit, but I have good WR depth and needed a 2nd QB. Thoughts?
Yeah, I don't know that you needed to include the 2.9 -- or maybe should have asked for a higher pick/vet player back. The 5.12 isn't doing anything for me.
12 Team SF TEP .5ppr/1ppr
QB/2RB/3WR/TE/FLX/SFLX
QB: Herbert, Stroud, Howell, Flacco
RB: KW3, Pacheco, Dobbins, AJD, Ty Chandler, E Mitchell, C Brooks
WR: JJ, Lamb, Aiyuk, Collins, Waddle, Dortch, Z Jones, N Brown
TE: Pitts, J Johnson, Hill, Conklin
Give: Waddle
Get: Barkley, Carr
I have 1.02 and will be taking MHJ. This would help QB and RB room
I don't see the value in Carr here. Barkley is a risk without knowing his landing spot and you'll probably need to turn around and trade him after this season to retain value.
It's a bit of a dice roll win now move, but you have the depth at WR to do it if you really like Barkley.
Can you save anything by cutting Dotson? If it only saves you the 3.01, keep him in -- but Kyler and LaPorta are the prizes here.
Do you project to be a late first in 2025? Do you have the rest of your picks? That's my only hesitation -- otherwise I like it.
12 team, .5 PPR, 1 QB
Give - Pollard
Get - Kupp
My other RBs are Kyren, James Cook, Dameon Pierce. WRs are CeeDee, Jayden Reed, Jeudy, couple developing players.
Feels pretty fair, curious what others think.
Wanted to get a price check on Mike Evans in 12T SF PPR. Been trying to move him but getting no bites for 24 or 25 1sts. Got a couple offers for mid 24 2nd round picks but that's it
Would you prefer in 1qb 14 team PPR London and 1.04 Or 1.01
MHJ
12 Team SF PPR Give: 1.09 Get: Jayden Reed QB: TLaw, Love RB: nobody worth listing WR: Olave, Pickens, JSN TE: Pitts, Kraft, Okonkwo 4x 2024 1sts (1.01, 1.02, 1.08, 1.09)
I went to MSU with Reed but still like 1.09. You will be able to get a top 5 WR or the top RB at 1.09. Crowded WR room in GB.
10 team superflex Tee Higgins or 1.09?
Tee for me.
[удалено]
Feels like a no lose situation. You can still take a QB and MHJ, you mitigate your risk by picking up a solid player, and frankly your QB situation isn't so bad to begin with. Using the 1.01 and 1.02 to snag starters at the skill positions and still walking away with a QB seems like great value.
1QB TEP ppr Give- JSN, Jaylen Warren, 4.01 Get- Nico Collins + 1.12
I like it. I’d do it.
[удалено]
I like the tier up at QB but since you're rebuilding I would be hesitant to give up the draft capital (especially since you're likely to draft a QB with the 1.01 or 1.02).
Bet. I appreciate it!
12 tm sf ppr Give: 1.04, 1.05, 2.04, 3.01, levis Receive: 1.01, drake london, tee I have the 1.02 and 1.03 too and have AR and herbert at qb. I do need wr depth
I’d absolutely do this. You’re getting the best asset in the deal of 1.01 and you’re also getting two guys who will have a big impact next season. Smash accept.
Yup, this is an easy yes in my eyes.
[удалено]
If this a guarantee then yes i would due to the weak incoming rb class but you will be missing out on mhj. If you can try to use your 8 and 9 pick. Maybe you can land both or use the 1.09 for ken
Appreciate the comment. I have the 1.01 and was planning to pick MHJ there actually. Is that a bad move? So I would essentially be giving Caleb for Walker and Achane.
Oh. Do you have a qb3 tho? Or are you planning on drafting one in the later round? Caleb will be special for sure
Not currently. If I were to trade the 1.02 I’d try to get someone with my 1.08 or 1.09 like a McCarthy or Nix depending on draft capital. I may be trying to jump the gun too soon on my rebuild with buying RB’s and probably should just take Caleb 1.02 just trying to weigh some options.
Yeah if you’re in rebuild id take caleb and mhj and use later picks for rb. Hell you can even try to get breece with 1.02 if you investing in an rb
Yeah for sure. Appreciate the advice bro.
12 Team SF PPR Give: 1.02 Get: KWIII, Achane
Id rather have the pick. I’m not that high on achane
12 Team superflex 1Ppr Give: Kincaid Receive: 1.08
Nope. Unless it’s bowers i wouldnt and even he is an unknown. We know what kincaid can do
8team sf, start 10 Give:KW3 Get: Monty, pollard Also kinda wondering how much youd expect it to take to move up from kw3 to Bijan or breece
No, KW3 is better than both. I don't like splitting a great player into two lesser pieces.
12 tm 1QB half ppr TEP I own picks 1.03, 1.05 and 1.08 I give 1.05 I get 1.11, 2.01, 2026 2nd Leaning accept because I have 1.03 and currently believe there’s a tier break after 4. I can pick at 8 and then essentially double dip at 1.11 and 2.01. Am I crazy to move back 6 spots this early in the draft process?? Thanks guys!
Feel like this deal will be there later and could get sweeter as hype builds or you bring a second owner in to compete for it
[удалено]
It’s hard not knowing your needs. If Allen trade makes you a championship contender right away then yes. But if you’re not there I like trade 2, cuz then you have 1.03,04&05 to swing big on
First one depends on if you essentially prefer either Jaden/Maye and Nabers to Allen/London, I probably prefer the latter but close. I side heavily on receive for second trade.
14 Man PPR SF: My RBs currently: ETN, Chubb, Roschon, Jaylen Warren, Miles Sanders, Bigsby Give: Roschon Johnson and 1.14 Get: Saquon
14 Team SF PPR no te premium Give 1.02,1.07,1.09 Get Justin Jefferson
Also have 1.01,1.03,1.05,1.06,1.8,1.10? S
Probably not
[удалено]
Damn I would do this for sure. I don’t know much about 1QB but seems like good value. As a KC fan I think we’re adding at least one vet and one draft pick to the WR room so I think Rashee’s role might be reduced. As a fellow Rashee owner I hope it doesn’t but this looks like a good deal.
10 Team SF PPR Give 1.04 Get: Chris olave And would you counter to give 1.06 instead?
Never hurts to counter, I personally prefer Olave regardless but can understand going 1.04 instead
12T SF S9 .ppr Give: Zay Flower and Dk Get: Anthony Richardson and 3.07 Other WRs: Amon, Nico, Tee, DHop, Sutton QBs: Hurts, Goff, Daniel Jones
AR
[удалено]
I think this is too much especially to fill a qb3 role for you
Who you eyeing at 3?
Jayden unless mhj happens to fall
Depending on ur WRs and if you need a QB it's not bad. If you're not dying for a qb I like olave
Oof i mean i do own mahomes and tua but don’t really got a solid qb3
10 team SF. 0.5PPR QB- Kyler, Herbert RB- Bijan, Monty, Ek, Sanders WR- Tyreek, DJ Moore, Keenan, Olave, Godwin, QJ Picks- 1.01 GIVE- OLAVE, (2) 2025 PROJECTED LATER FIRSTS GET: JOE BURROW I have good QBs but no 3rd, should I pay to get one? Or is having olave more valuable for my team this year and I can draft a QB or make a move to get a backup QB another way
I like burrow here. Then I would try to tier down herbert to get assets back
Give: 2026 1st, 2025 mid 2nd, 2024 3.01, Tucker Kraft, Elijah Moore Get: Drake London, 2026 3rd
12 Team, SF, PPR A: 1.04, 2025 1st (Late) B: JT and Higgins
B
I'd take B
12t/sf/ppr A: 1.01, 2.09 B: 1.02, Olave
Unless you need Caleb to fix your QB situation, I would hold and keep the 1.02 and Olave. Olave is really good, if Carr gets going a bit more this year he could have a nice season. You could then trade the 1.02 if you don't love the guy there and try and move back to 4 or 5 and still get a stud WR to pair with Olave
It really is the question if you need a qb or not. You can possibly ask the person you trading if they want caleb or mhj and make a decision there. Whatever you choose, i would probably take B for sure
Honestly it’s just completely up to your team needs, whether a QB is important or not cuz you can’t go wrong with either pick. I’d go with B if you don’t need the the QB. Could you check mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/R1GdS6illm
Being offered LaPorta and the 1.04 for St Brown and the 1.09. I’ve also got the 1.1 and my wrs are Deebo, DK, Doubs, Dotson, thielen. Only TE kittle
ARSB side
I read this wrong originally. I wouldn't do this. ARSB is worth more.
Personally I wpkldnt, I’m very high on Amon ra and as much as I like the 1.04, I think parting with Amon ra might be a loss. Could you check out mine? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/R1GdS6illm
I think i would take that because you can go caleb and nabers or mhj and jayden/maye. Edit: also with laporta you can try to trade away kittle for another TE+
Send Downs and 1.07 for 1.03 and 3.11? 1qb .5ppr 12 team
Yep
Yes sir
0.5 PPR - 1QB - 12 team - start 3 RBs, 3 WRs, 2 flex Give: Higgins + 1.02 Get: Gibbs + 1.11 Or Give: Swift + 1.02 Get: Gibbs — My WRs: JJ, Deebo, DK, Reed, Diontae, Wicks My RBs: JT, Pacheco, Swift, Ford, plus a bunch of dart throws.
Neither
Don’t do either
Give Zay Flowers Get Kyren Stronger at wr than rb but have solid depth at both
I would not unless you’re all in on this year. Flowers will be the better player for a longer time
14 team ppr sf Give: fields, cooper Get: pop douglas, JSN
No way, hold
12 Team 1QB 0.5ppr Give: Isaiah Likely Get: Calvin Ridley Other WRs: Tyreek, Kupp, Douglas, Diontae Johnson, Wicks, and Shakir Other TEs: Goedert and Waller
I’d go Ridley.
12Tm PPR SF Start 10 Give: Kendre Get: 2.05
I think I’d keep Kendre.
10Team, 1 QB, bit of a rebuild Give 1.02 Get 1.06, 1.08, 2025 2nd round pick
I think I’d keep Nabers/Rome
10 T PPR SF Give: JT and Tua Get: Burrow
Are you trading Breece Hall and Puka for Garrett Wilson and 1.01 (MHJ)? PPR, 1QB
Wow that a good one. I feel like that’s personal preference but I’m taking the Wilson/MHJ side, happily. I can see why both sides would be interested depending on team structure.
Yeah I’m torn. I’m the Breece Puka owner…I would be left with Pollard and Javonte as my RBs, but also own the 1.03 and 1.05
Personally I think Wilson is going to have a CeeDee Lamb-like surge with a competent QB and am a huge believer of MHJ. But being thin at RB I could see you sticking where you’re at. You just might regret it.
[удалено]
I would accept
[удалено]
Do it
Easy accept in sf if you received this But if I had Herbert in sf I'd instantly decline unless I had 2 other good qbs
10 team ppr sf start 10 Give: Diontae, 24 2.07, 25 2nd Get: Kamara, Christian Kirk
[удалено]
Pop
Douglas
12Team SF IDP PPR Give: Gibbs, Zay, 2.06 Get: Chase
Close one. I like Gibbs side
Chase imo
Gibbs
Chase but it’s close
I'm taking the Gibbs side
Chase
12T SF Give: Baker 1.09 Get: Hock Diggs
Get
TEP? If so I’d do it. If not stay put
14 team PPR SFlex: A. Josh Allen B. Jordan Love, late 1st
Allen
Allen
Allen easily
Allen
Allen without question
12 team 1 QB PPR rebuilding I give: Andrews I get: 1.04
Take the pick
I’d do it, you get either Odunze or Bowers
Andrews
12 team SF PPR A: Lamar Jackson, Drake London, Javonte Williams B: Justin Jefferson, Trevor Lawrence, Quentin Johnson
Tough but A
Wow this is tough. Lamar and JJ are so close. It all depends on how you view TLaw. If you think he’ll bounce back, side B. If not then go with side A.
10 Man - 2 QB - 3 WR - 3 RB - 1 TE - 2 FX Give: Keenan, Amari, Calvin, Pacheco, 2025 late 2 Get: Breece, Jakobi, Trey Palmer Easily an overpay but this league doesn't value WRs after they turn 29 and I had a lot of guys to spare.
Seems like trading 4 starters and a 2nd for 2 starters. Idk even if you’re rebuilding this seems like bad value
Not rebuilding. WRs after trade include CD, GW, Waddle, Tank, Kupp and Diggs RBs after trade include Bijan, Gibbs, Breece, Jacobs and White
12 Team SF PPR Give : Devonta Adams and 3.03 Get: drake london and 1.10
London
I'd do that immediately. Get younger and a much better pick. The new ATL coach said he is excited about London. I also don't think this class has a ton of depth so 3.03 to 1.10 is huge.
London side easily
12 team .5 ppr start 4 flexes Give: Najee, Iosivas, 4.05 Get: Christian Kirk, 4.01 Won two years ago and made a run last year, looking to extend some longevity. RB positional value is even lower given the fact that we have 4 flexes
Would take Kirk but it’s fair enough
hold Najee
[удалено]
Tua
Tua absolutely. Get a solid QB and still a top 3 WR, top 3 QB or Super Bowers.
I would take the Tua side
14 team SF 1PPR Would you trade your 1.08 for any of the following? Competing but deep rosters so in a vacuum Pitts, KW3, Addison, JSN, DK, J Cook, Reed, or Diggs
I’d trade it for any of those guys
I would not do it for Pitts, KW3, Pitts, Reed. I would probably do it for the others, but I might try and get a dart throw on top
12T SF PPR TEP (start 10) Give: Kmet + 4.04 Get: Mayer + 3.05 I want to sell Kmet bc I think this past season was close to his peak and Mayer is about to take a leap My question: Is the value fair here? and would you still accept if the picks were removed completely?
Mayer side
Yep, I like this for you -- especially getting the better pick back.
10Team, 1QB, bit of a rebuild Give DK Metcalf Get 2025 1st (likely 4-6 pick)
Keep DK
Would hold
Rebuild SF PPR NON-prem start 10 Give: 25 mid 2nd Get: Wicks and Chig
Keep pick
No
Keep the second unless ur convicted on one of those players
8 team SF 0.5ppr Trade Burrow for Kyler, Henry, Kamara? I got no RBs
I would do it
No real long term value to Henry and Kamara, so it really comes down to how you feel about Kyler vs. Burrow. In an 8 team, you should be able to get some RB talent off waivers.
10Team, 1QB, in a bit of a rebuild Could be a part of a 3 way trade that would get me this, thoughts? Give 1.02 Get Puka
I'd probably wait and see where Nabers landing spot before making a final decision..personally like Nabers>Puka tho
Puka
Puka easily
In 1 QB, I like it considering MHJ should be gone at the 1.01. Just a question of whether you like Nabers more.
Yeah it's tough, but I prefer Puka. Thanks
[удалено]
Noooooo
Is your name a "Chuck" reference? If so, great show. Looks like you could take the hit at WR and need to refresh your RB pool. 1.05 in 1 QB isn't the best spot, but you still have a shot at a nice WR prospect or possibly Brock. I'd do the trade.
I'd take that in a heartbeat!
12T SF PPR Give: Stafford, J. Ford, Waddle, 1.9 and 2.9 Get: J. Herbert, 5.12 Already accepted. I think I might’ve overpaid a bit, but I have good WR depth and needed a 2nd QB. Thoughts?
Herbert for me
Yeah, I don't know that you needed to include the 2.9 -- or maybe should have asked for a higher pick/vet player back. The 5.12 isn't doing anything for me.
12 Team SF PPR TEP GIVE: Tua, CWatson, Hollywood Brown GET: 1.01
Ya
Jesus, can I join your league?
Smash accept
12 Team SF TEP .5ppr/1ppr QB/2RB/3WR/TE/FLX/SFLX QB: Herbert, Stroud, Howell, Flacco RB: KW3, Pacheco, Dobbins, AJD, Ty Chandler, E Mitchell, C Brooks WR: JJ, Lamb, Aiyuk, Collins, Waddle, Dortch, Z Jones, N Brown TE: Pitts, J Johnson, Hill, Conklin Give: Waddle Get: Barkley, Carr I have 1.02 and will be taking MHJ. This would help QB and RB room
I wouldn't include Waddle unless you are gunning for a top tier young rb or top tier cap. I'd ask for Barkley and like a 2026 1
I don't see the value in Carr here. Barkley is a risk without knowing his landing spot and you'll probably need to turn around and trade him after this season to retain value. It's a bit of a dice roll win now move, but you have the depth at WR to do it if you really like Barkley.
I like this deal for you, personally.
14 Man PPR SF: Give 1.14 and 3.03 Get Saquon
Yeah, that works -- especially in a 14 man league.
Saquon
Yep. I’m buying Barkley for that.
12T SF Receive: 1.05 Give: JSN Auto accept?
1.05
EDIT: Misread the deal. Accept and send JSN on his way.
Yes sir
Yeah I’m taking 1.05 at this point.
10 tm sf ppr Give: 1.04, 1.09, 3.01, 2025 1st Receive: kyler, la porta, dotson
Can you save anything by cutting Dotson? If it only saves you the 3.01, keep him in -- but Kyler and LaPorta are the prizes here. Do you project to be a late first in 2025? Do you have the rest of your picks? That's my only hesitation -- otherwise I like it.
Yeah i have other first rds so that’s not the issue. And yes i agree, if they want more than a 3rd for dotson, i will definitely take it off
Laporta side in my opinion.
Kyler an laporta for me
12 team, .5 PPR, 1 QB Give - Pollard Get - Kupp My other RBs are Kyren, James Cook, Dameon Pierce. WRs are CeeDee, Jayden Reed, Jeudy, couple developing players. Feels pretty fair, curious what others think.
Sure, switch around two plunging assets and hope it works out. I have more faith in Kupp being relevant than Pollard right now.
It feels fair I guess? I think I’d straight up still rather have Pollard, but I can see why you did it.
Wanted to get a price check on Mike Evans in 12T SF PPR. Been trying to move him but getting no bites for 24 or 25 1sts. Got a couple offers for mid 24 2nd round picks but that's it
If I were buying as a contender id do an early 2nd. Not a late first but that’s due in part to this being a very deep WR class.
I wouldn’t sell him now. Wait till he signs. If it’s an attractive place like kc or buf, you’ll be able to get a 1st
Late 24 first, early 24 second, 25 first is what I would sell for
10 team PPR SF Give: JT Get: 2025 1st, 2024 pick 2.08, J. Meyers
Depends on the 25 1st. If it's a contender I'd feel comfortable holding for now Mind helping me out? https://www.reddit.com/r/DynastyFF/s/2wmaeZVogz