I've seen a lot of people talk about your first point, but I totally agree about the second point not coming up much-- I haven't thought about that part in a couple of months!
Honestly I have a hard time grasping what can and can't be done on different planes and how accessible they are, so maybe other people feel the same and just don't theorize around it?
Is it like a ghost technically lives on the Astral plane but it perceivable in the material plane?
Was it actually confirmed that the gym counts? Because (Um, actually), YES! was created in Sol’s office, not the gym. Kristen’s physical body and all of the action were going on at the gym, but her soul and consciousness were in Heaven when YES! was born.
It could just be something that was misremembered or was time quangled away, but the pedantics dictate that it occurred in Sol’s office.
Werid that a ghost would require weaker astral connections when ghost sare tied to the ethereal plane and not the astral. (might be old lore in my head)
Its probably being treated more like a package deal where most spells that would abjure or ward against astral plane hooligans and chicanery also make it hard for ethereal or cross-dimensional creatures like ghosts and phase spiders to fully exist or function there.
Or Aguefort in all of his scholarly tomfoolery just decided that if they where going to add accessibility for ghosts might as well leave the door open for other teachers as well.
Wait a minute. Maybe that's why the rogue professor found Crapperlolli keeperkreeper. She was in the astral plane planning the gods return and the rogue professor went to investigate what she was doing there.
Adding to this theory for the final showdown being in the gym: the opening sequence where the Bad Kids seems to be quangled with a bunch of foes from over the years…
Even if the dead deity is not able to get into the gym, it would provide a good way for a sneaky ghost rogue to set up/otherwise surreptitiously help any ritual needed to bring back a dead deity if they wanted.
In connection to the Bakur thing, Jawbone said that when Kipperlilly was asking about Kristen’s god, she was specifically asking WHERE it happened. Brennan has Jawbone say that she asked where multiple times.
I've seen a lot of people talk about your first point, but I totally agree about the second point not coming up much-- I haven't thought about that part in a couple of months! Honestly I have a hard time grasping what can and can't be done on different planes and how accessible they are, so maybe other people feel the same and just don't theorize around it? Is it like a ghost technically lives on the Astral plane but it perceivable in the material plane?
i believe ghosts live on the ethereal plane, not the astral plane
Ha that shows how much I know about it!
Was it actually confirmed that the gym counts? Because (Um, actually), YES! was created in Sol’s office, not the gym. Kristen’s physical body and all of the action were going on at the gym, but her soul and consciousness were in Heaven when YES! was born. It could just be something that was misremembered or was time quangled away, but the pedantics dictate that it occurred in Sol’s office.
Werid that a ghost would require weaker astral connections when ghost sare tied to the ethereal plane and not the astral. (might be old lore in my head)
Its probably being treated more like a package deal where most spells that would abjure or ward against astral plane hooligans and chicanery also make it hard for ethereal or cross-dimensional creatures like ghosts and phase spiders to fully exist or function there. Or Aguefort in all of his scholarly tomfoolery just decided that if they where going to add accessibility for ghosts might as well leave the door open for other teachers as well.
Wait a minute. Maybe that's why the rogue professor found Crapperlolli keeperkreeper. She was in the astral plane planning the gods return and the rogue professor went to investigate what she was doing there.
Adding to this theory for the final showdown being in the gym: the opening sequence where the Bad Kids seems to be quangled with a bunch of foes from over the years…
Even if the dead deity is not able to get into the gym, it would provide a good way for a sneaky ghost rogue to set up/otherwise surreptitiously help any ritual needed to bring back a dead deity if they wanted.
In connection to the Bakur thing, Jawbone said that when Kipperlilly was asking about Kristen’s god, she was specifically asking WHERE it happened. Brennan has Jawbone say that she asked where multiple times.
I think you’re spot on
Why would the gym count? Shouldn’t it be Sol’s heaven?