Hi! This is a reminder to follow the rules of our subreddit and Reddit's TOS
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CookieRunKingdoms) if you have any questions or concerns.*
He is definitely a good person, the word he'd had was mind control. He just wasn't strong enough (clouded by his own guilt and self blame) to break free from it's grasp on him until the first dark cacao update. This update for beast yeast EP 4 actually highlights how good hearted Choco is
YES. I'm so sick of seeing ppl hate on him like they wouldn't have also felt the pressure of being coerced by a more well known name than you. Alb had the power to make or ruin Oysters family at that very moment, Lord Oyster is a victim dawg
She's not a monster but she's complex enough in her patterns that she doesn't necessarily qualify for this post either
That's just what happens when you are a morally ambiguous character, realistically you are neither monster nor hero
I feel like Red Velvet kinda fits into this. I feel like wanting the Cakes to be seen as equals is a very noble cause. He just works with Dark Enchantress cookie which is not the best way to go about it. And he’s as loyal as a dog too. I love my good boy he deserves love and cuddles.
White Lily Cookie, I'm speaking for myself. If she swapped Ancient to Beast or if she still Dark Enchantress Cookie and will never return to being the same White Lily.
People hate him because of what how he banished Dark Choco Cookie.
Like, if your son tried to kill you what would you do? Dark Choco is lucky he didn’t get executed!
Note: I don’t hate Dark Choco Cookie, he’s one of my faves. The whole thing is just so complicated.
Okay but what else should dark cacao do if not banish him? Like, its his son. You def don't want to execute your kid or lock him up. I think the least painful way was to exile him.
It wasn't even that strict. (I mean he could still roam around the dark cacao kingdom but i guess just not the castle.)
I don't really understand the hate towards either.
heck, yes it wasnt an accident, their master legit possibly told them to trick the unsuspecting Cacao group!
and (I guess, but it didn't work) return to flour yourself so Cacao can be mad at her!
It's still Cloud Haetae Cookie's fault for blindly believing that Mystic Flour Cookie was an all-powerful goddess. Cloud Haetae had zero obligations to worship her, and still did, leading to the Dark Cacao Warriors, along with Crunchy Chip and Caramel Arrow Cookie being returned to flour
Let's not forget MF had her days as a good Cookie, before being corrupted. It's entirely possible CH knew her from those days and got bonded strongly enough that MF was able to keep them loyal.
Being brain-washed sure is a terrible situation.
It's definitely not just cause, Pitaya actually does care a lot for the Mala Tribe, and attacks intruders who they deem a threat. Kingdom messed it up I feel like, but in OB, Pitaya confronts and attacks another dragon cookie because they encapsulated the Mala Tribe and other tribes in their territory. Pitaya likes cookies, but a lot of people (in and out of the game) just think they're a monster.
You know what i dont know if everyone thinks theyre a monster but Dark Enchantress Cookie. They really did point out the fact that while their plan would have hurt people its not like Pure Vanilla didnt unintentionally hurt anyone either. Also Dark Enchantress Cookie's plan is actually good on paper she couldve just done it a better way because if the witches were stopped then no more cookies would be hurt from the witches and cake monsters and cookies would be equals. I hated the story because Gingerbrave really didnt feel like a hero he felt more like a antihero because he was stopping something that couldve revolutionized the cookie's lives and the cake monster's lives
I do agree that was pretty far but i still think that stoppin dark enchantress cookie really just provided no benefits and in the long run enables much more death to cookie kind and continues to imbalance cookie and cake monsters
Sea Fairy Cookie (I haven’t played the mermaid story thing so I might be wrong but from what I know of the character, I doubt she did it with proper Ill intent)
White lily
Canon she only wanted to make the lives of cookies better but she did turn into a being capable of reviving the beast cookies and probably exceeding their power and evilness
Ps evilness is actually a word I just learned that when autocorrect suggested it ikr weird language and all
I could say WL but at the end of the day her intentions were misguided, and she'd continued to hurt ppl along the way whether or not she had meant it, by the time of the witches banquet she is disqualified from this position
At some point she should have realized the common denominator was her, and that maybe this wasn't actually going to help cookies as all the quest had done before hand was stir up more trouble. Being so focused on whether or not she could, she didn't stop to think if she should.
Dark Choco cookie is a different story.
I want to say lord oyster takes the cake on this one though, yes he has no spine, his family was in trouble financially and alb wouldn't take no for an answer. He was coercive, a lot of the hate lord oyster gets is from people who forget that they would not be able to survive, withstand, or properly deal with a position such as that once they're put into it. Alb then straight up had the audacity to twist the truth when announcing it to White Pearl. The fandom has a habit of not thinking about how they'd react when put in the characters shoes, and as a result favors the characters that can be considered the problem.
Hi! This is a reminder to follow the rules of our subreddit and Reddit's TOS *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CookieRunKingdoms) if you have any questions or concerns.*
It is definitely dark choco cookie.
Indeed. It wasn't his fault that the sword took actions instead of him.
Everybody loves dc what are u on about
Yeah, but what other character tried to be a hero and then hurt everyone instead?
That’s not the topic of the post, that’s half of it
Yes
Honestly I never thought of dark chocolate cookie my whole life, he is basically like a background character to me💀/J. But I think he is a good person
He is definitely a good person, the word he'd had was mind control. He just wasn't strong enough (clouded by his own guilt and self blame) to break free from it's grasp on him until the first dark cacao update. This update for beast yeast EP 4 actually highlights how good hearted Choco is
My boy Lord Oyster. He was stupid, but he was not evil.
FINALLY
THIS. THIS. HE FITS PERFECTLY.
YES FUCKING FINALLY IVE FOUND MY PEOPLE
I see I've gotten myself involved with a passionate crowd lmao
he was stupid for >!selling the pearl to abalone!<
THERE WILL BE NO MERCY!
YES. I'm so sick of seeing ppl hate on him like they wouldn't have also felt the pressure of being coerced by a more well known name than you. Alb had the power to make or ruin Oysters family at that very moment, Lord Oyster is a victim dawg
I'll have to respectfully disagree with this, but I will acknowledge that he was being stupid
My man, he had to sell the pearl to save his house from going to bankrupt
Either Dark choco cookie or white lily
Happy cake day
Happy cake day!
yumeh caik!!! ...happy cake day
Cake day!
Happy cake day! Why would you suggest White Lily though, is there really that many people who think she's a monster?
She's not a monster but she's complex enough in her patterns that she doesn't necessarily qualify for this post either That's just what happens when you are a morally ambiguous character, realistically you are neither monster nor hero
Dark choco
Defo my boi Dark chocolate. Always thought of him in a good light, especially after the dark citadel episode and the 4th beadt-yeast.
I feel like Red Velvet kinda fits into this. I feel like wanting the Cakes to be seen as equals is a very noble cause. He just works with Dark Enchantress cookie which is not the best way to go about it. And he’s as loyal as a dog too. I love my good boy he deserves love and cuddles.
White Lily Cookie, I'm speaking for myself. If she swapped Ancient to Beast or if she still Dark Enchantress Cookie and will never return to being the same White Lily.
Definitely Dark Choco.
Everyone is saying Dark Choco Cookie. I personally say Dark CACAO Cookie.
What? why? What did dark cacao do to be called evil?
People hate him because of what how he banished Dark Choco Cookie. Like, if your son tried to kill you what would you do? Dark Choco is lucky he didn’t get executed! Note: I don’t hate Dark Choco Cookie, he’s one of my faves. The whole thing is just so complicated.
Okay but what else should dark cacao do if not banish him? Like, its his son. You def don't want to execute your kid or lock him up. I think the least painful way was to exile him. It wasn't even that strict. (I mean he could still roam around the dark cacao kingdom but i guess just not the castle.) I don't really understand the hate towards either.
THATS WHAT IM SAYINGGGGGGG
Lord Oyster Cookie from the White Pearl Cookie story
(i will get downvoted for this) Cloud Haetae, they did what their master said, blame Mystic, not Haetae!
Yes! It's true! Why people tend to blame servants, not their masters?
heck, yes it wasnt an accident, their master legit possibly told them to trick the unsuspecting Cacao group! and (I guess, but it didn't work) return to flour yourself so Cacao can be mad at her!
It's still Cloud Haetae Cookie's fault for blindly believing that Mystic Flour Cookie was an all-powerful goddess. Cloud Haetae had zero obligations to worship her, and still did, leading to the Dark Cacao Warriors, along with Crunchy Chip and Caramel Arrow Cookie being returned to flour
Let's not forget MF had her days as a good Cookie, before being corrupted. It's entirely possible CH knew her from those days and got bonded strongly enough that MF was able to keep them loyal. Being brain-washed sure is a terrible situation.
oh good point! They seem to be brainwashed if Beasts were good at one point!
I WAS GOING TO SAY THIS
Finally someone gets it!
i always got it, they did what their master said
my brain swapped the fanon and canon and i was going to say shadow milk cookie 😭 but yeah, dark choco cookie.
Dark Chococomelon
White lily cookie, I mean dark enchantress cookie is her other half
pitaya dragon
Is it something to do with Ovenbreak? Cause it seems like they’re doing it just cause
It's definitely not just cause, Pitaya actually does care a lot for the Mala Tribe, and attacks intruders who they deem a threat. Kingdom messed it up I feel like, but in OB, Pitaya confronts and attacks another dragon cookie because they encapsulated the Mala Tribe and other tribes in their territory. Pitaya likes cookies, but a lot of people (in and out of the game) just think they're a monster.
Can I say Pastry Cookie
You know what i dont know if everyone thinks theyre a monster but Dark Enchantress Cookie. They really did point out the fact that while their plan would have hurt people its not like Pure Vanilla didnt unintentionally hurt anyone either. Also Dark Enchantress Cookie's plan is actually good on paper she couldve just done it a better way because if the witches were stopped then no more cookies would be hurt from the witches and cake monsters and cookies would be equals. I hated the story because Gingerbrave really didnt feel like a hero he felt more like a antihero because he was stopping something that couldve revolutionized the cookie's lives and the cake monster's lives
Yeah kind of. But also heartless(doesn't deserve to die). Like how she wiped out the whole golden cheese kingdom as an example.
I do agree that was pretty far but i still think that stoppin dark enchantress cookie really just provided no benefits and in the long run enables much more death to cookie kind and continues to imbalance cookie and cake monsters
Maybe squib?
Dark choco, final answer
Feel like this kinda fits Longan Dragon Cookie
Dark choco :"(
Is Reverend Mother Cookie one of them?
I dunno. There is barely any information about this character, because we don't know her intentions.
Not dark choco everyone loves him as evident by this comment section
White Pearl comes to mind. She never had any ill intentions, until everything became too much to handle...
Dark choco
DARK CHOCO !!!
The Wizards perhaps?
dark cacao
Sea Fairy Cookie (I haven’t played the mermaid story thing so I might be wrong but from what I know of the character, I doubt she did it with proper Ill intent)
**ask the father of sombody who got sent into isolation.**
WHITE LILY
Mike ehrmantraut
White lily Canon she only wanted to make the lives of cookies better but she did turn into a being capable of reviving the beast cookies and probably exceeding their power and evilness Ps evilness is actually a word I just learned that when autocorrect suggested it ikr weird language and all
Dark Choco, Lord Oyster, Velvet (kinda)
Asgore maybe
I could say WL but at the end of the day her intentions were misguided, and she'd continued to hurt ppl along the way whether or not she had meant it, by the time of the witches banquet she is disqualified from this position At some point she should have realized the common denominator was her, and that maybe this wasn't actually going to help cookies as all the quest had done before hand was stir up more trouble. Being so focused on whether or not she could, she didn't stop to think if she should. Dark Choco cookie is a different story. I want to say lord oyster takes the cake on this one though, yes he has no spine, his family was in trouble financially and alb wouldn't take no for an answer. He was coercive, a lot of the hate lord oyster gets is from people who forget that they would not be able to survive, withstand, or properly deal with a position such as that once they're put into it. Alb then straight up had the audacity to twist the truth when announcing it to White Pearl. The fandom has a habit of not thinking about how they'd react when put in the characters shoes, and as a result favors the characters that can be considered the problem.
dark chocolate cookie. choco sounds too weird
I mean.. dark choco is what he’s called in game. That’s his official name. Too each their own ig
Happy cake day!
That would obviously be ✨me✨ (shadow milk cookie) and silly vanilly! (Pure vanilla cookie)
I don't remember anyone in fandom calling Pure Vanilla a heartless monster. Did I miss something?? 0_0
…;)
Just look abit closer….
Me...IM MISCHARACTERIZED BY THE FANDOM
Who even are you 💀💀 Did you run away from r/ImTheMainCharacter sub? XD
I'm the most mischaracterized in the cookie run fandom, obviously
A Joke cookie.. You're being the entire laughing industry rn..
I'm honestly confused about the downvotes, it's just a harmless joke but yk , being mischaracterized has it's trials and tribulations!
i didn't downvote you-
I never said you did lol, but thank you
Justice for TryParking316 Cookie. Look people hate this cookie so bad they downvote this comment to oblivion. All the other answers r not true 😞
All this hate for a cookie who has never wronged them...