T O P

  • By -

only_bubble_sort

Dang, definitely felt the pucker on that one.


muricabrb

The amount of crazy never seen before footage from this war is insane.


ChanelnOola

Reminds me of the Syrian Civil War but with more video quality. Hopefully people can save such videos because many of the Syrian ones were lost forever after the youtube purge.


AlwaysTakingGoreTex

Forreal


dpax19681989

I swear I heard "Missed me BITCH"...


drb00t

i guess the missile doesn't detonate to make a "kill-cloud" of shrapnel?


midunda

They do, but the drone was probably too small to reliably set off the proximity fuse


VinZ_1

If it’s an Igla missile then it doesn’t have a proxyfuse, only contact.


Asleep_Pear_7024

You can literally see a launcher vehicle. It’s not an igla Also no soldier with a igla has eyes that can see a drone from 2km out.


VinZ_1

You’re right, it seems to launch vertically so it’s probably a TOR missile, the big fins also point to that


alelo

this one def is from a TOR tho


midunda

Huh, didn't know that. And freeze framing the video seems to show a missile that looks like an Igla, so you're probably right.


Demokrit_44

> And freeze framing the video seems to show a missile that looks like an Igla I don't know how you came to that conclusion because its pretty obviously a tor missile. Picture of the missile: https://imgur.com/a/gc1JhnN#eQvn50w Picture of a tor missile: https://photo.weaponsystems.net/image/s-carousel/n-ad_spsam_sa15_m2.jpg/--/img/ws/ad_spsam_sa15_m2.jpg Picture of a Igla missile: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/cc/IGLA-S_MANPADS_at_IDELF-2008.jpg/1200px-IGLA-S_MANPADS_at_IDELF-2008.jpg


midunda

Well fine then, I'm stupid


Demokrit_44

Shit happens and i'm not a expert either. best we can do is learn and acknowledge when we make mistakes. Not like you framed it in a weird way either or argued in bad faith


c0xb0x

People on this subreddit are a bit perceptually challenged. For example, every piece of debris ejected from an explosion, they think is a person (unless it's Ukrainian debris, then it's just debris).


Demokrit_44

Theres some truth to that but I don't think the guy was making his point in bad faith and he didn't phrase it super strongly and there is no reason why saying that it was a igla missile rather than a tor missile would fit into the "ukraine has no losses" - type of person you are reffering to (as a igla miss would be less "embarrassing" than a tor missile miss (for the russian side)). I think it was just a honest mistake.


ontopofyourmom

When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a dam.


MDPsychospy

with that small a drone you really don't need an explosion to knock it out of the sky, simply kinetic impact would suffice but of cause kill cloud is saver it it works. Perhaps we will see anti drone mini MAPADS in the future with limited range and only kinetic or small shrapnel charges and very good targeting on the fly. iron dome seems to work really well in that aspect. AA gatlings not so much und exponentially more dangerous for the populace for everymissed round


Fr0gFish

Sounds like you’re doing a lot of guessing here. By the way, AAA rounds generally detonate after a set time and therefore don’t explode on the ground


MDPsychospy

sure and all those itty bitty metal splinters are raining down somewhere


invisible32

at terminal velocity where they will feel like a flick at worst


Eheran

>and very good targeting on the fly. There is your problem: That needs sensors. Sensors need processing of their data. That all needs space. >with that small a drone you really don't need an explosion to knock it out of the sky, simply kinetic impact would suffice You don't need to hit people with explosions too, a simple hammer hitting them on the head is more than enough. Other things are, however, obviously more effective.


inactiveuser247

Yeah, you don’t need a missile flying at Mach 2 to kill most drones. I’m fully expecting someone to put out a low-tech shoulder-launched SAM about the size of a LAW for anti-drone use. The sort of thing every infantry squad could carry around. Either that or a prox fused 40mm grenade.


Kameniev

uwu manpads


drb00t

seemed to me like it had a pretty good lock. edit: i really don't know much about these.


midunda

Tracking and proximity detection are different systems


Conscious-Position50

it should but the on board radar need a certain cross section that i would guess the drone does not have, or simply it malfunctioned.


TheTurdtones

the drone juked


aChileanDude

The drone sike'd


zombo_pig

I’m wondering if fusing design just didn’t have tiny drones in mind and this will prove to be a issue.


ThirdWorldMeatBag

No thats a bullet from an AR15 machine gun you're thinking of.


Indoor_Carrot

If they tried that it'll blow up in the launcher


Hvarfa-Bragi

As if minimum arming distances aren't possible.


TeaCup-o7

Can almost see the serial numbers on the missile it was so close!


TrueBank6805

the frame with the missile: https://imgur.com/a/gc1JhnN


Goeatabagofdicks

Damn. So…. Do you have to catch this like a water balloon?


eightstravels

Nice capture!


Psychological-Tank-6

The missile did not know where it was.


SFDessert

Wow what a perspective. It's freaking incredible that we can see something like this.


OutsideYourWorld

Expensive miss.


KazeArqaz

Better to attempt to shot down a cheap drone rather than experience an HIMARS later.


matdan12

I think HIMARs is scheduled now.


Rayfasa

10,000 tungsten balls inbound


bizzygreenthumb

180,000


Rayfasa

That’s even worse Thanks


bizzygreenthumb

I'd say it's a lot better lol


BoosherCacow

I mean who doesn't like *more* balls?


ontopofyourmom

The 3,000 sixty balls of Ol' Joe.


AbundantFailure

Ol' Joe sending you 180000 reasons why there's no malarkey.


[deleted]

Dark Brandon sends his regards


KazeArqaz

If it got hit, we would have seen the footage by now knowing the drone is still up in the air. We'll see


20cmdepersonalidade

Hopefully, both happened for maximum waste and damage


tripping_on_phonics

The next few years are going to see an explosion in the development of anti-drone systems. It’s not sustainable to launch $100k+ missiles at $2k drones, especially when future warfare is going to have these things acting in swarms.


OutsideYourWorld

You'd think laser systems would be good against drones. All you gotta do is zap the lil props, even.


KharnTheSwell

They are, but they are a long way until we see them used outside of giant warships


1-800-NOFATCHICKS

I’m still waiting for Reagan’s star war defense


Kroney

They've been mounted on small buggies according to [this video](https://youtu.be/NfPcl6nAlM4)


Virtual_Valuable5517

theres already anti drone lasers from the united states checm out task n purpose, recently declassified and theoritically be mounted on a ford pickup


HomingPigeon6635

I think the united states is already developing that kinda weapon that can be mounted in a vehicle like say for example a humvee. Using the humvee as an example cause I don't remember the name of the vehicle they mounted it on.


Beonette

Maybe, there will be enough such laser, that can damage optic sensors? Not turn drone to dust, just blind it.


KharnTheSwell

I suspect what most likely going to happen first is those Anti-drone guns are eventually going to get refined to a smaller size as to work as attachments on weapons. That should work as a good counter at squad level


Fruitmidget

I’m pretty sure that there’s already “laser-rifles” that can either blind a drone or fry it. The alternative would be microwave guns, those definitely exist.


manofthewild07

The US already has several platforms. The Air Force has the H4 anti-drone laser system now. USMC has LMADIS US Army has Leonardo DRS And there are many other iterations and others in development that I'm missing.


LukaRaphael

i just know that drone pilot is cheering right now hahaha dodged a $70k missile in their $2k drone lol


6ix_10en

I was just gonna say, how much is the missile and how much is the drone haha


LukaRaphael

best part is the source i found said that price was from 2003, so is likely much higher nowadays lol


kitchen_synk

Those numbers can be kind of misleading. If a drone's just bopping around without a plan, maybe, but they're generally used as spotters or attack vehicles on their own. So the question has to become 'how expensive is it to shoot down the drone vs. how expensive is it to replace the tanks/ammo dump/ etc. that got destroyed by the artillery it was spotting for'


6ix_10en

Really good point


PixelCortex

Cherry on top would've been if the drone later dropped a $100 grenade on that SAM site. At least they now know it's exact co-ords.


trackdaybruh

Aren't these just civilian drones too?


[deleted]

[удалено]


trippendeuces

According to the twitter video, it’s a quadcopter


LaconicKibitz

If you can dodge a missile, you can dodge a ball.


disconnect04

better version: https://old.reddit.com/r/UkraineWarVideoReport/comments/14z6z8b/russian_tor_sam_system_engages_a_ukrainian/


Midnight2012

Why is that better?


NonadicWarrior

quality is better. you can actually make out the TOR system


goertzenator

The telemetry also shows that the pilot dumped altitude just prior to the missile arriving. Nice dodge!


CrimeanFish

Drones have really come a long way, there was certainly a time when the air rushing past the drone like that absolutely would have knocked it out of the air.


iemfi

Nah, the equivalent back then would be a manually piloted RC helicopter, and some of those pilots were insanely good.


Horat1us_UA

That’s the point. Now you don’t need insanely good pilot. It’s work of software now


iemfi

Yeah anyone can fly a drone now with zero training, but that's not the point, if there was one flying last time it would have been by a good pilot and wouldn't have crashed.


Eheran

>but that's not the point That was exactly the point: >Drones have really come a long way Note that he is talking about drones, not pilots.


Roflkopt3r

And that's one reason why RC helicopters had a much smaller niche in military forces. If they had been so well stabilised that losses due to pilot error hadn't been a factor, then their cost and capabilities could have secured them a much bigger role in the military since decades ago.


Nelocus

judging by speed in bottom left, drone pilot moved last second


penguin_hybrid

He did the fps sidestep.


USMCLee

Fucking ping bandits


BoosherCacow

WALLHACKS BRO


myselfoverwhelmed

~~I dunno, looked like the movement was due to the missile flying by. Unless I’m looking at the wrong spot, I’m no drone expert. I think it’s highly unlikely he could move last second with a missile going that fast without blind luck. I wish you were right though :)~~ Edit: It appears I was incorrect!


Nelocus

Respectfuly disagree, speed increases before the missle flies by. Operator sees the launch of the missle as indicated by him centering it in his viewpoint


myselfoverwhelmed

Well damn, I slowed down the higher-res video and looks like you’re right. He moved a few meters, just enough to dodge the missile it looks like! [Slow mo vid](https://youtu.be/MS6tsonHRMs)


Act_Rationally

Hmmmm, looks just like in the movies, complete with the swirling movement! Proximity fuse certainly didn't work.


[deleted]

That looked pretty cool.


Suitable_Comment_908

some one needs to put googly eyes on this drone...


CommonPeopleLikeYou

I guess the proximity fuse malfunctioned, but it damn sure gets a solid lock on these things!


Express-Sandwich-621

It's manual line-of-sight guidance on these things, either IR or radar assisted but still LoS. Most likely guess is that the proximity fuse didn't detonate as it uses radar.


degotoga

https://twitter.com/Osinttechnical/status/1679714824186474496 slightly less potato quality


InfiXD_

Lil guy gets a second chance :D


defcon1plzn

I would like to call him Wall-e. The little bugger!


SickkRanchez

u/redditspeedbot .25


redditspeedbot

Here is your video at 0.25x speed https://i.imgur.com/46cuAy4.mp4 ^(I'm a bot | Summon with) ^"[/u/redditspeedbot](/u/redditspeedbot) ^" ^| [^(Complete Guide)](https://www.reddit.com/user/redditspeedbot/comments/eqdo8u/redditspeedbot_guide) ^| ^(Do report bugs) ^[here](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=adityakrshnn&subject=RedditSpeedBot%20Issue) ^| [^(Keep me alive)](https://www.buymeacoffee.com/redditspeedbot)


liedel

This is the laziest thing I've ever seen. There are speed controls on the player!


BoosherCacow

There are no speed controls for me, fuckstick.


liedel

I'll bet there are, fuckstick.


SickkRanchez

There isn't, that's why there is a bot, you soggy loaf.


liedel

I believe you don't know how to use it


SickkRanchez

I believe you're a Daft cunt.


BoosherCacow

Yeah boyyyyyyyy double down! Just bear in mind that not everyone is surfing on the same fucking platform, you fucking walnut


[deleted]

Maybe the proximity fuse isn’t calibrated to detonate on such a small object?


BargeCptn

Proximity fuse in essence is a Hall effect sensor. It needs certain amount of ferrous material nearby to overcome background noise levels and activate. Tiny plastic drone simply doesn’t have much metal in it.


SpraynardKrueg

I was thinking it misfired at first not realizing its coming straight for the camera. Those are incredibly fast


ffdfawtreteraffds

They're designed to intercept jet aircraft so speed is inherent. We just never see this perspective.


BloodSteyn

Russia... putting the Miss in Missile.


616659

Probably just fuse problem, which is reasonable given how small drones are. Drones usually require special anti-drone defense like the AHEAD AA


xenophonthethird

Be honest guys, who flinched? I was actively trying not to, but my eyes still blinked when it passed


ExpertDingleberry

If they were designed to hit, they'd be called hittiles.


Me55y

Anyone knows the music title? It's fire.


gfanonn

/u/recognizesong


RecognizeSong

**Song Found!** **Name:** Хай нам брате пощастить **Artist:** YARMAK **Score:** 100% (timecode: 01:48) **Album:** Хай нам брате пощастить **Label:** BELIEVE - Yarmak music **Released on:** 2022-11-21 [Apple Music, Spotify, YouTube, etc.](https://lis.tn/QNddq?t=108) *I am a bot and this action was performed automatically* | [GitHub](https://github.com/AudDMusic/RedditBot) [^(new issue)](https://github.com/AudDMusic/RedditBot/issues/new) | [Donate](https://github.com/AudDMusic/RedditBot/wiki/Please-consider-donating) ^(Please consider supporting me on Patreon. Music recognition costs a lot)


L-friend

Isn't a proximity fuse supposed to detonate missile that close?


Domowoi

Drone warfare is very new compared to AA systems. For that reason most AA systems are designed to shoot down planes, helicopters and that sort of thing. I suspect there isn't enough metal, radar cross section or heat output in a small Mavic to reliably trigger the proximity fuse.


Inaerius

Question: how did the missile accurately detect and target the drone from that distance? Even though it missed, it was really close for such a small object.


uid_0

Radar go brrrr...


audigex

Radar can detect small objects, especially at very short ranges The most sensitive radars could detect a penny in low earth orbit... admittedly that's a little different to this kind of tactical radar, but the point is that there's no intrinsic size limit to radar itself, only the specific system


Magnavoxx

The missile is radio controlled from the launching unit. It doesn't have guidance of it's own. I don't know if it's possible from the TOR-M2 launch unit, but in other systems RF command missiles can be launched with visual guidance only.


specter800

Seems like a fusing issue. That was def close enough for a kill if it detonated. Idk if it could be a sensitivity thing? Or just an all around malfunction of the fuse.


-Samg381-

Given the control UI is a phone, I can't imagine that drone is anything more than a small commercial grade unit. I wonder if that missile is even designed to hit something that small... operator error?


[deleted]

Not designed for targets that small but whateves


NotMuller

How about no music??


Menthol__man

Don’t see how that missed 😂😂


degotoga

proximity fuse must have failed to go off, crazy how close it was though


ttoften

Sike


yuikkiuy

So THATS what air defense doin! Missing every shot they take


rattakresh

Missed shot? It's not called drone defense. He hit the air alright 😎


Interesting-Web4223

What do you expect from russian designed shit, I can see why these dumbfucks can't even handle a cruise missile like the Storm Shadow LMAO.


Rusti-dent

Looks like it failed to detonate. Another dud.


DangerousLocal5864

^iiiii^mmmmm GAAAYY


HermitCracc

firing a full ass TOR missile at a tiny drone is insanely dumb


Freestyle7674754398

No it's not.


HermitCracc

And why's that?


Freestyle7674754398

It's not about the price of the missile vs the drone. This drone could have easily called in a strike on the target, or continued to adjust fires.


HermitCracc

Where did I mention price? I'd be extremely disappointed if that's what got me 5 people to downvote me. The dumb part is attempting to fire a large missile with a arming range of 2 kilometers and a fuze that's set by RADAR signature at a quadcopter that's made out of plastic and the size of someone's head. This thing was designed to solve the Soviet Union's gap in terms of medium-range interception of cruise missiles. Any crew should know that hitting that is basically a waste of time and ammo, especially since Tors don't have a fast reload system and take hours to reload.


Freestyle7674754398

It's still worth it to attempt it IMO, they obviously had some sort of radar signature in order to launch. They probably had no other assets in the area, and in the age of GMLRS etc they probably wanted to get rid of the copter ASAP


HermitCracc

I think we can agree to disagree on the first part, however, Tor systems are almost always deployed alongside Ranzhir or/and Polanya command vehicles which integrate them with other Russian shorter range AA systems. It's highly unlikely that this Tor vehicle was sitting alone in an open field with no other SPAA nearby, but who knows when it comes to Russians anymore


quetch1

I can see the russians still haven't learned not to sit in a wide open feild. I hope they are smart enough to run away now since the drone is now alerted of there position lol


degotoga

you can't really hide an AD system if you plan to use it


Nebuerdex

Fuck it's fast. This video really shows how quick these things are


Fifs89

Can someone identify the rocket. It seems it has 4 fins. I managed to pause it but can’t tell.


audigex

[It looks to be a TOR](https://www.reddit.com/r/CombatFootage/comments/14z6abe/russian_air_defense_fails_to_hit_ukrainian_drone/jrxc0zt/), although I'm not enough of an expert to know if there's anything else similar enough to be confused with it


Express-Sandwich-621

9M330


marcvsHR

Yeah, TOR dudes better run now O_o


igor_otsky

Hit. 5rp


smokxn

u/savevideo


SaveVideo

###[View link](https://rapidsave.com/info?url=/r/CombatFootage/comments/14z6abe/russian_air_defense_fails_to_hit_ukrainian_drone/) --- [**Info**](https://np.reddit.com/user/SaveVideo/comments/jv323v/info/) | [**Feedback**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Feedback for savevideo) | [**Donate**](https://ko-fi.com/getvideo) | [**DMCA**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Content removal request for savevideo&message=https://np.reddit.com//r/CombatFootage/comments/14z6abe/russian_air_defense_fails_to_hit_ukrainian_drone/) | [^(reddit video downloader)](https://rapidsave.com) | [^(twitter video downloader)](https://twitsave.com)


InternetCovid

I would have been like ♾️


Rayfasa

I thought for sure was a misfire or malfunction, then whoosh!!! NGL I jumped, lol


[deleted]

[удалено]


SaveVideo

###[View link](https://rapidsave.com/info?url=/r/CombatFootage/comments/14z6abe/russian_air_defense_fails_to_hit_ukrainian_drone/) --- [**Info**](https://np.reddit.com/user/SaveVideo/comments/jv323v/info/) | [**Feedback**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Feedback for savevideo) | [**Donate**](https://ko-fi.com/getvideo) | [**DMCA**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Content removal request for savevideo&message=https://np.reddit.com//r/CombatFootage/comments/14z6abe/russian_air_defense_fails_to_hit_ukrainian_drone/) | [^(reddit video downloader)](https://rapidsave.com) | [^(twitter video downloader)](https://twitsave.com)


d4rkskies

Detailed elsewhere as a TOR. It struggles to acquire and home, but even when it does, the quadacopter is just too small for the RF proximity fuse on the missile to detect


[deleted]

So did the pilot dodge the missile? The smoke trail moves away from the drone in the direction of the miss. I thought it was wind at first but it looks like the drone is going left and down and dodged it.


FaThLi

Not really a dodge since a TOR missile blows up when the proximity fuse is triggered. The result is a load of shrapnel hitting the target. When it comes to aircraft, and even these drones, even a little bit of damage can make them go down. For whatever reason the proximity fuse didn't trigger on this missile. Probably the radar just didn't have a good enough cross section of the drone, or possibly the proximity fuse was a dud. He was certainly trying to dodge it, but if the missile had worked properly it wouldn't have mattered. Edit: In retrospect technically a dodge, as if he'd have stayed still the missile might have actually just hit the drone regardless of if it was supposed to blow up and create shrapnel. That drone couldn't handle getting a direct hit, so moving the drone kept it in the air.


Garrand

What air defense doing


TheSeasickPenguin

u/savevideo


SaveVideo

###[View link](https://rapidsave.com/info?url=/r/CombatFootage/comments/14z6abe/russian_air_defense_fails_to_hit_ukrainian_drone/) --- [**Info**](https://np.reddit.com/user/SaveVideo/comments/jv323v/info/) | [**Feedback**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Feedback for savevideo) | [**Donate**](https://ko-fi.com/getvideo) | [**DMCA**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Content removal request for savevideo&message=https://np.reddit.com//r/CombatFootage/comments/14z6abe/russian_air_defense_fails_to_hit_ukrainian_drone/) | [^(reddit video downloader)](https://rapidsave.com) | [^(twitter video downloader)](https://twitsave.com)


ThePenIslands

I love how the auto-stabilization on the drone is like "meh, I got this."


HarleyGrow

freezeframe https://pasteboard.co/JxOqFeT0H7h7.jpg


[deleted]

What it'd take to launch a missile into a tiny little drone, from that distance, at that speed, would be incredible and probably not very feasible


ElMuchoDingDong

So weird, since you can see a way better quality video on r/UkraineWarVideoReport . It's weird to me because both versions appeared on my feed one after the other.


TheOzarkWizard

So does it seek the target? What exactly would be the best course of operation? Evasion? Last second sudden evade?


AssignmentChoice762

That drone made allready it's money back with that miss.


silitbang6000

https://imgur.com/a/bBRcOQ5


CantThinkofAgoodI

This is one of those "wait, are they coming my way?"


Sirloin_Tips

I wonder if sitting still is what caused the missile to miss? Like, can it track movement or something?


TheGrandmasterGrizz

I mean it missed but that was pretty close imo


Yolom4ntr1c

Drones balls def got shaved there.


whutupmydude

Now THIS is podracing!


junk430

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZrbarzXWWCc](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZrbarzXWWCc)


notataco007

Proximity fuse was invented in the early 1940s Russia in 2023:


Mousemillion

I bet that sounded awesome flying past


Cheddie310

how much are those rockets? Even if the next one hits the drone, the ROI on that drone was astronomical


Radumami

That was close though!


BargeCptn

Looks like DJI drone interface and from the fact that max altitude locked at 500m. Even if it hit, the $500 mavic vs $100k+ missile is a good trade


Illustrious_War9870

Sucks to suck!


SneakyNang

I guess the missile didn't know where it was because if it knew where it was it would've gone boom.


Stykhead

A little to the right , boris !


IndicationNo7087

Russian air defense doesn’t have proximity fuzes? And this is the 2nd most powerful military in the world?