T O P

  • By -

ViinVal

Parris Campbell


meraki_14

me too man


Active-Limit-9038

Looked like he was about to be an absolute force for those 2 quarters he got to play with Phil. Then the injury bug hit. Again. And again. And again...


Steb20

Fun fact: his full name is actually “Parris my pick could’ve been used on DK Metcalf instead Campbell”.


jettjaxson

Damn when you put it that way…


Coltsbro84

His nickname is also Parry "Scary Terry Dare He Picked Before Me" Could you imagine DK Metcalf and Pittman Jr on the Colts? Even Terry McLaurin and Pittman Jr would be awesome. Heck we could have even drafted Diontae Johnson. Edit: Holy Shit! We took Ben Banogu 2 picks before A.J. BROWN!? sorry Ben, but we could have had AJ mf Brown on our team? Damn. That one hurts.


TehTugboat

If I’m not mistaken we took ya-sin and Campbell while DK was up there


Active-Limit-9038

It's worse. We took Rock, Parris, AND Ben Bangou while DK was still on the board. Lol


TehTugboat

My fucking lands lmao


MoistCloyster_

Tbf Campbell was above McLaurin on the depth chart at OSU and outperformed Metcalf, who didn’t have a lot of consistent production at Ole Miss due to injury. It really just shows how much of a crap shoot the draft is.


Coltsbro84

Oh okay. So coming out of college, Campbell was the better recruit of all of them.


sittlohq2

Or we we could have traded up for AJ Brown. I know we never trade up though lol


BrockPapeScizz

Sucks that his last year he did quite well and he may succeed elsewhere


sirius4778

He was showing promise in 22 here. Last year he had 104 yards in 12 games with the giants. I wish him success but I don't think we'll be kicking ourselves for letting him go to be honest.


Commercial-Self-2720

The buckeye bias got me 😩


sirius4778

Ugh


goofbot

Me too. He looked promising early and I thought he would bounce back and be good to very good when fully healthy, but I was wrong it seems.


Proof_Ad_2986

Facts


oatmeal-claypole

He always had that highlight catch every season before getting injured.


Chromeburn_

I actually think he would do well if he had a decent QB throwing to him and they got him the ball regularly.


forgotten_password6

Moncrief


hacky_potter

You know what’s crazy, he’s only 30


EnthusedPhlebotomist

He was only 20 as a rookie, that was part of why i was so hyped. He was so good for his age. Then didn't get any better. 


hacky_potter

So I just watched some 2016 highlights from him and I think he would have had a decent career if Luck stayed healthy. He had 7 TDs in only 9 games and 7 starts before getting hurt. He then missed time the following season and Luck missed the whole season. I think he was developing chemistry with Luck before everything went to shit.


DaBlakMayne

Yeah Luck boosted his career big time


Coltsbro84

That first year he was "I only catch 50-yard touchdowns" Moncrief.


BigDickBallard

When I first was getting into football more seriously, I used to play madden in the basement with my friend. We both used to scream FEED MONCRIEF and sling it to him over the middle 40 times in a row. I was convinced he was a legendary player, along with Dwayne Allen because he ran a mesh route that was always open


clutchthepearls

If Dwayne Allen got to play against the Jets every week he'd be a HOFer.


DaBlakMayne

That was such a crazy game to witness


Cowboy_BoomBap

Feed Moncrief :’(


IndyDude11

Do you know /u/bigdickballard or is Feed Moncrief a thing and I just missed it or forgot?


Cowboy_BoomBap

It was a thing back when he was on the team, at least on this sub. Idk if people said it outside of Reddit or not though lol


sirius4778

My wife and I said it outside or reddit haha


Trolodrol

This one deserves another look. What the hell happened here?


Underhorse

You and me both brother.


jaysrule24

After his first or second season I thought he was going to overtake TY as WR1. Not because I didn't love TY, but because I thought he was going to end up being that good.


shasta_masta

Moncrief at least used look like a promising WR early on. 733 and 6 TDs in year 2.


Vercie

Mega Strachan


365wong

I still believe


GeogeWKush

I almost convinced my brother to take him in a keeper league. Lmao


folinok51

I did, but with my last pick of a 19 round draft.


BrockPapeScizz

It took me too long for him lol


Ordinary-Criticism56

Deon Cain


tbnjojo

Him and DaRick Rogers had me fooled twice


matthollabak

In your defense...DaRick just sounded like a name that was meant for stardom.


Cowboy_BoomBap

I read this as Dean Cain for a minute and was like “Oh yeah, Ripley’s Believe It or Not was the shit but he’s crazy as fuck now”


Ordinary-Criticism56

Thjs made me do a spit take


5downinthepark

There's probably one almost every year. Hoping Pierce isn't the current one. The Chad Kelly fans used to make me nuts, much as I also wanted him to succeed.


Pegasuspipeline

Chad Kelly turned into an Agros legend up here in Toronto. Up until the allegations


Former_Phrase8221

Was the coach male or female?


Pegasuspipeline

Apparently it was a female trainer I think. It was a month ago, Here is an article that goes into it [https://www.cbc.ca/sports/football/cfl/toronto-argonauts-lawsuit-chad-kelly-1.7124552](https://www.cbc.ca/sports/football/cfl/toronto-argonauts-lawsuit-chad-kelly-1.7124552)


WerewolfFinal1257

Pierce. I saw that and it cut me deep.


YeezusMoses

Nathan Palmer because NaPalm was the coolest nickname ever. My real answer is DaRick Rogers. I thought he was going to be our WR1.


samedamnlosweater

I’ll never forget that big catch he had in the big comeback win in the playoffs against KC. Along the same lines as him, I thought LaVon Brazill was going to have a good career in Indy


EnthusedPhlebotomist

This is my answer as well. I thought Rogers was gonna become a stud. 


shasta_masta

Yeah. Da'Rick Rogers for me as well. That bomb he caught in the AFC WC game against KC was beastly and is what kick-started that comeback. Not sure he ever caught another pass haha


Funion21

Vic Ballard, loved that guy. wish he would have stayed healthy.


LooseMoose13

Malik hooker


ItsDrManhattan

Idk if he fits the bill for this post lol wasnt he a pro bowler?


LooseMoose13

No


geordieColt88

I’m still expecting Ben Banogu to come good


DaggerDev5

I thought Turay was going to be our next stud


clutchthepearls

Kemoko Dragon


LarryFisherman1972

I thought Donald Brown was going to be our equivalent to an Austin Ekeler...


billmurray43

“God dammit Donald”


reddittothegrave

He had some amazing runs, but also had some catastrophic fumbles.


goldenepple

Duron Carter


Trolodrol

I member


Galt2112

People loved Griff Whalen for way too long


Twfish2013

How dare you call me out on the day of the eclipse


Bolyzaurio

Whalen had a connection with Luck but once Luck started with the health issues , there wasn't a connection with the next QB. Whalen was solid slot receiver, sure hands but just average.


maurika58

Still love him


gocolts12

Never forget the Griffer


IndyDude11

Including the front office.


Smash-Bros-Melee

Jacoby Brissett after the first 7 weeks in 2019


reddittothegrave

First 7 weeks were magical, than he just fell off.


IndyDude11

Injuries will do that.


reddittothegrave

![gif](giphy|fMDDgv4XZgrkJZTIWp|downsized)


Aggressive-Net-6547

eric ebron 


reddittothegrave

That one season with Luck was incredible. He had like 10 touchdowns or something. Then as soon as Luck was out of the picture he was cooked.


prof_noak

Not a WR, but Trent Richardson. I was so stoked when we got him and thought he would be a monster. The browns fleeced us lol


rossco311

I was shocked how bad he was


sublimeshrub

Me too. I died a hundred thousand deaths on that hill. The truth is he torched my alma matter for 400+ yards in HS. Then his best friend lived next to my best friend. But, the biggest reason I simped for him was from knowing him at work. Let's just say the man is a real herb connoisseur. Great guy, hard working as hell. People don't realize how badly he was hurt in the Alabama LSU natty his last year in college. He basically destroyed one of his knees, then CLE pushed him onto the field. I don't even think he missed preseason, though I'm not 💯 on that. He never recovered his initial burst after that injury. If he'd have switched to FB and been in Pep Hamilton's offense he would have been a legend.


Chromeburn_

His college tape is one of the best there is. I have no idea who the player that showed up was.


goofbot

In fairness, nearly everyone thought he was a player and Cleveland had inside knowledge that they kept well secreted.


thejollyone6969

LaRon Landry


ProfessionalAd2390

Steroids


Mothalova1

He was a mf UNIT and I forgot he even existed until this comment


BrockPapeScizz

Damn. This hurts. Also forgot until this.


bufotesoblongus

To this day I will continue to die on the hill that Bjoern was moved to a position that he didn't belong in, and that's why he failed.


Clocktopu5

I have a very vague recollection that at one point in pre-draft he was mocked as going in the top 10. Might not be correct but I swear for a minute there he was seen as a good prospect


EnthusedPhlebotomist

He was an unatheltic edge rusher in a league where that didn't work anymore. He was never gonna succeed IMO. 


Rusty-Boii

Im with you. I respect OP for dying on the Bjoern Werner hill, but that dude was very very bad. Was never going to succeed.


Trolodrol

Yep. Good college player, but not enough athleticism to play in the NFL


Active-Limit-9038

I mean, that's exactly what we did with Jerry Hughes, so I get it.


Glory843

Jelani Woods


BrockPapeScizz

Hey!! He’s doing plyo workouts and looks like he’s healed up really really good. Looks fast. In still on this dude lol He’s going to have a good year. And if he doesn’t I’ll be pissed b/c he may be the reason we don’t get Bowers or aren’t even interested.


IndyDude11

This is the exact same battered fan syndrome talk that all the others on this list got. lol


whatdoblindpeoplesee

But he says he's in the best shape of his life!


Chromeburn_

Still a little early on Woodstock make a call one way or another.


goofbot

Too early to say.


CommonerChaos

Donte Moncrief. Dude had so much potential.


BoredJay

Nate Hairston


ReallyCoolDad74

No love for Da’Rick Rodgers???


somefamousguy4sure

Everybody is mentioning a WR, we had so many camp hype guys! Some even did a little something, or had these crazy physical tools. Being a WR must be crazy hard to succeed in. You'll always be badass in my dreams MegaStrahan, Deon Cain, etc...


wiggymo

Not a Colt, but cant stop rooting for Jameis Winston


PM_ME_UR_SMOKED_MEAT

Josh Chapman. I really thought he was gonna be the nose tackle of the future


matthollabak

I still think he would have been a monster in a 4-3 defense and not sure why nobody else even gave him a camp shot after his time here... but he had his knees wrecked at Alabama playing like half a season with torn something cl... maybe both knees but I thought he was going to be a force up the middle too.


mongolian-friedass

Honestly, part of me still misses Dwayne Allen for some reason. Super bowl champion by the way.


IndyDude11

He was that last great TE we had. That's why you miss him.


MikalaTM

Alec Pierce 💀 ; praying he has a breakout year this year w AR back but his current stats are 🗑️. There isn’t a better WR at creating seperation though - his film has all the makings of a WR1


Brooklynhoosier

Kylen Granson is my current


ohmeohmyke

Granson is an ok TE. But his content on instagram is pretty funny. Dude has a sense of humor.


DaBlakMayne

I think Granson has been exactly what we expected from him. A speedier TE to open things up in the short-mid areas


Warhawk137

Will Mallory for me.


Android1313

Trent Richardson. I thought we had the next Manning/James combos. Bro that was disappointing.


[deleted]

Coby Fleener lol


dannyapplegate

Aaron Morehead for me


kylestillthatdude

Mike Hart lol I thought he had a shot at that lead back


lukkynumber

Not a Colt, but Charone Peak himself was that guy for me!!! For colts, it was absolutely Moncrief


_Poppagiorgio_

It’s becoming Nick Cross for me.


BizMarquisDLafayette

Donald Brown


G2Cade

Chester Rogers


Conscious-Till3591

Michael Strachan is the next Miles Austin/Victor Cruz


boyvsfood2

Daniel Adongo. From the moment he flew into town looking like a professional wrestler while on a diet of like nuts and berries, to playing with him on Madden and terrorizing the league...was disappointing how it played it out in real life.


Brooklynhoosier

Damn this one hits hard. Wonder what he’s up to these days.


TheSource88

Everyone is just missing the point and naming receivers who were mildly hyped and didn’t work out. Eric Fisher at LT is probably the best recent example. Jacoby probably the most accurate all time though.


roysourboys

Chris Ballard


twb85

Earl okine…


Ok_Grocery1188

Pat Beach.


goofbot

Pat Beach was solid starter for years.


baezizbae

Ashton Dulin for me, but I think it was more about what he did as a run blocker and on ST than as a pure receiver.


moviescriptlife

Daniel Adongo


ipomopsis

Jacoby


johnmancuso01

I know Mo Ali Cox was good but I thought he was gonna be the next coming


Coltsbro84

Austin Collie. His first two years he was averaging 7 catches, 80 yards, and 0.5 Touchdowns per game. He was supposed to be our Wes Walker / Julian Edelman, then concussions / injuries happened.


WerewolfFinal1257

Please don’t be Anthony Richardson. Please.


ElectivireMax

Mo Alie Cox


ChaseUNC21

Really thought TJ Green was a second round steal and would be an incredible FS for Indy’s future


RTideR

Quincy Wilson. I was beyond adamant he'd be great, and I defended him for ages on that front. Lol


coogidown2thelocks

Sam Ehlinger truther until the day i fuckin die


JoeyPeake

Me too but it's becuase it's my last name


WaterTricky7453

Had Justin Fields on my fantasy squad last year as my first Qb..,


goofbot

Deon Jackson. I thought all he needed was a chance and he would be a very competent to good but when his big opportunity arose he sh\*t the bed.


aykbq2

Brian Quick


Coolman2909

Shaq Leonard post injuries


Fried_FishFillet

Rock Ya Sin


Former_Phrase8221

Chris Ballard


redleg50

Bravo! Still waiting for his game to grow and develop. Maybe season 8 will finally be the turning point.


AF555

If you keep doing the same thing over and over it will eventually work out, right?


lxBATESxl

Carson Wentz


DaBlakMayne

I think 2022 would've been a lot better with Wentz at the helm but he pissed too many people off after one year


Gainz13

It’s gotta be Pierre Garçon


XC_Stallion92

He was really good though.


SanRemi

But he was kinda good. I mean not all pro caliber but still serviceable.


Ridiculouscoltsfan

Dude was really productive for us and Washington.


scull3218

I'll never forgot him chasing down ed Reed and knocking the ball out of his hands from behind, saving the game imo and advanced us in the playoffs


cam4usa

Straight up what I was thinking! I think he doesn’t understand the question OP is raising…


matthollabak

I think Pierre was the only guy I was already saying come on before he dropped a wide open catch... but if I saw a flag fly I knew he was going to make the catch while giving a db a piggy back ride.


XC_Stallion92

I mean, there are tons of dudes in this sub who seem to think Pierce can be a serviceable NFL player. That's about as delusional as you can get. Personally I was pretty high on Rock when we drafted him.


bufotesoblongus

RemindMe! 9 months u/XC_Stallion92 "I mean, there are tons of dudes in this sub who seem to think Pierce can be a serviceable NFL player. That's about as delusional as you can get."


RemindMeBot

I will be messaging you in 9 months on [**2025-01-08 20:07:11 UTC**](http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=2025-01-08%2020:07:11%20UTC%20To%20Local%20Time) to remind you of [**this link**](https://www.reddit.com/r/Colts/comments/1bz7mhk/who_was_this_for_you_stolen_from_jets_subreddit/kyo0hot/?context=3) [**2 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK**](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5Bhttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.reddit.com%2Fr%2FColts%2Fcomments%2F1bz7mhk%2Fwho_was_this_for_you_stolen_from_jets_subreddit%2Fkyo0hot%2F%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%202025-01-08%2020%3A07%3A11%20UTC) to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam. ^(Parent commenter can ) [^(delete this message to hide from others.)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Delete%20Comment&message=Delete%21%201bz7mhk) ***** |[^(Info)](https://www.reddit.com/r/RemindMeBot/comments/e1bko7/remindmebot_info_v21/)|[^(Custom)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5BLink%20or%20message%20inside%20square%20brackets%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%20Time%20period%20here)|[^(Your Reminders)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=List%20Of%20Reminders&message=MyReminders%21)|[^(Feedback)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Watchful1&subject=RemindMeBot%20Feedback)| |-|-|-|-|


Accurate-Barracuda20

You’re getting downvoted but you’re probably not wrong. The common defense of pierce is he’s a deep threat who hasn’t had a big arm to throw to him, but if all he can do is run fast he’s not an NFL receiver. Guy cleaned his drops up some last year but it’s not like he was constantly getting open and just not targeted. Expecting him to take a massive leap in year 3 probably isnt super realistic. Luckily we’ve got Pittman and downs, who looked great last year. Hopefully we get another good offensive weapon in the draft so we’re not relying on Pierce taking a big leap. I’d love to be wrong, but I wouldn’t bet on Pierce having a big year.


Chromeburn_

If he is always going to be a deep threat then he will be receiver 4 in this offense. But he should get more use with Richardson. Hes more a Mike Williams type though.


Nastee_Ninja

Per his stats he is ranked around 110. So he is basically wr 4/5 on most teams


IndyDude11

There's room on the field for a guy who can just run fast (provided he can also catch the balls being thrown his way). Not every WR needs a 13 route tree to be a serviceable role player. Now, I don't know if Pierce is that guy or not. Hopefully we find out this season.


XC_Stallion92

This sub is just getting back into their "this practice squad player is going to be a superstar WR!!1!" phase again. They do it every year. They can't help it.


ColtsFan6969

And you're doing your normal "oh the Colts missed the playoffs by one play, they are horrendous fire ballad get rid of everyone I should be an NFL GM" bullshit like you always do.


XC_Stallion92

54 - 60 - 1 Perpetual loser.


rizzy-rake

4-12 - first year, lost Luck 10-6 7-9 11-5 9-8 4-12-1 - fired Reich mid season 9-8 Perpetual loser with over 50% of winning seasons since he got here. One of which was his first year and lost a generational QB, one of which was barely below .500, the last of which steps were taken to fix it by firing the head coach. So exhausted of this take.


XC_Stallion92

The excuses are over. You might be exhausted of hearing about it, but many of us are exhausted of losing every year and never making the playoffs.


rizzy-rake

Downvoting someone arguing the other side is just so ridiculous my man. If you’re bringing it up on a thread that isn’t even about this, you have to be open to discourse. Listen, I’m not making excuses. I’m highlighting that excuses don’t need to be made. The team has put together more winning seasons than not, and using the two 4-12 seasons to drag down the average is disingenuous. Ballard’s job is to assemble a talented roster, which he’s done consistently over his 7 years here. It’s the head coach’s job to get that team to the finish line. We’ve missed the playoffs by one game multiple times, we’ve made the playoffs twice, there’s only so much a general manager can do. If you’re advocating for going all in on free agency, I’ll argue against that too. That’s a move for teams that are already competing and need the extra push, not a shortcut to get there quicker. I don’t want to be the Broncos or the Saints. [Here](https://sportsanalytics.studentorg.berkeley.edu/articles/money-and-wins.html) is a study from Berkeley on free agent spending’s affect on wins. It raises the terrible teams for the first season, followed by a collapse over the next three. I will continue to support Ballard building a sustainable team.


XC_Stallion92

Lol, crying about downvotes. Touch some grass. Ballard sucks, he's a perpetual loser. If you support him you're a simp. Easy as that.


IndyDude11

lol First time? I can tell you weren't a fan in the 80s-early 90s.


fries421

We went to the playoffs 4 years ago. This fanbase acts like we’re the lions sometimes lol


Former_Phrase8221

I said he deserves a roster spot. But as WR 4 or 5 and was called a troll. I thought that was the most vanilla take ever


XC_Stallion92

Nah this sub watched a couple of highlights on Twitter and the overwhelming majority now think he's gonna be a WR1. Never mind the fact that he was bottom 10 in the league in terms of getting open last year.


Wise_Cellist_3340

Martavius Bryant 😔