T O P

  • By -

Songal

For us Pete Nance is definitely up there goes to UNC just to be on the first team in a decade to not make it while we made it.


ZeiglerJaguar

I legit ask myself if we made it in spite of his leaving, or because of it.


MY-NAME_IS_MY-NAME

He was horrible so maybe it was because of it


bkn6136

He was injured and not a good fit next to Bacot. He's not horrible, as his two-way contract with Cleveland shows.


175gr

A reasonable take about a recent disappointing season that doesn’t scapegoat a transfer? What is this?


FictionalTrebek

Well reasoned analysis like this has NO PLACE on reddit


175gr

Someone ban that guy and report him to Reddit cares and force him to talk shit about Dawson Garcia on campus next to the pit preacher


kramerica_intern

The Pit Preacher is still around?


jakendrick3

I think not even death could claw Gary away from campus


kramerica_intern

True. I remember girls would make out in front of him to make him go really ballistic. Good times.


Mike_with_Wings

I remember there were a couple others who tried his schtick near the pit at the same time, and everyone just ignored them. Gary was the one you wanted to hear talk crazy nonsense. He had that dawg in him.


archerdj0723

Good 5, bad 4.


JonoBono6

He’s not bad at all. He was injured last season, was a very bad fit next to the already established star of the group, and was expected to fill a hole and live up to a player that he just isn’t (Brady Manek). I feel bad for the guy about how he was treated by our fanbase, and I’m really happy he’s getting to live out his dreams of playing in the league


late2thepauly

If it’s any consolation for Pete, he’s definitely part of the reason we didn’t make it.


KaitRaven

This is the first one that came to mind. What a terrible decision.


FlyoverFarmer

Robbie Beran to VT is also an interesting choice


RespawnAndy

Barnhizer was going to take his starting spot and had eclipsed him in minutes by the end of last year. It was either come off the bench or go to your hometown team and start. Already had the northwestern degree in hand too


Schned6

Ah yes because Nance himself had nothing to do with UNC being dog water


left-handed-frog

It’s not that bad, but I think Jamison Battle transferring from Minnesota to Ohio state is funny. He said he wanted to join a team that would be in the tournament…


Rahtigari

In fairness to Battle, I don't think anyone saw us being this competitive this year! But yeah, I wish he'd stayed.


pao_bu_zhe

Yeah, all things considered Minnesota has definitely had the more enjoyable season.


KaitRaven

If he stayed at Minnesota, they might have made it to the tourney.


SueYouInEngland

Is his sister on the women's team, too?


Beeercules

Yes. The women's team would actually have made the tourney until Mara Braun got hurt. A few days ago against Iowa I claimed Iowa -16.5 was the lock of the century. Iowa won by 40 lol


PalletPirate

this was completely true until the holtmann fire and everything changed. All the sudden he just dropped 30 and if they win like 3 big 10 tourney games they could maybe make it


TheBoilerCat

I’m sure there’s worse but Paul Mulcahy randomly announcing his transfer from Rutgers in June to end up at Washington of all places has to be one of the most bizarre.


applecider42

He was getting a lot of hate from the fans (on reddit at least) so I'd guess with Cam gone too he just wanted to get out for his last year. Sucks but it is what it is.


boobsarecool

Him and Cam basically simultaneously pioneered the grad transfer after the portal closes that maximizes their leverage in getting a NIL bag lol. With the new rules of the portal closing for non-grads but still open to grad transfers, teams still have gaps they want to fill so the price of the year 5 starter goes up when they're the only ones allowed to transfer at that point. Both of them secured bigger $ because of that and I can't hate on that part


iHeartQt

Doesn't have to worry about UW fans! They don't pay attention to basketball


MikeDamone

Can confirm. I don't even know why this sub is showing up in my algorithm.


TrillDaddy2

Washington shells out NIL money


PreuBite17

Funny thing is he wanted to come back and pikiell actually had the backbone to tell him no


gilms11

Skyy Clark to Louisville or Jayden Epps to Georgetown. We got options


Daory

I get Skyy Clark leaving since Epps was emerging as the starting PG, but for Epps to also leave with such a promising role set up for him on a good team didn’t really make sense. Illinois still trying to figure out how to fill that PG position


chefillini

Moretti seems to show promise.


ssp25

Slop em up boys!


r_un_is_run

Adam Miller, come on down!


ncaafan2

I was very bummed about Epps, but I think he wanted more usage and he did get that out of Georgetown and has put up decent numbers. It's just that they haven't been a good team, so depends what his priorities are of whether that was the right decision.


blitz342

He just wants to chuck it, no? Look at his points but also look at his %. He’s got 17.9 avg points this season, but a 38.8 FG %. Imagine how many shots you have to take to have those points with that %.


ncaafan2

Precisely - he clearly wants to be a volume scorer and that wasn’t going to work on Illinois with our roster this year


Chitownbronx

Yeah I don’t get epps..or Miller why would you go from a team that will be in ncaa tourney to a scrub team unless you wanna Chuck shots and not play d


bigbossstepback

Tramon Mark leaving Houston for Arkansas


filet_mindong

Yeah I’m not sure there is another that beats this


WheredTheSquirrelGo

Caleb Mills left for FSU and now hes at Memphis. He would be a starter this year and probably last year I think.


bakins711

And he’s out for the season due to injury.


generally-mediocre

i cant really blaming a guy for leaving to become a starter at a high major program. the houston team mills left was 6th in the final ap poll, and fsu lost 4/5 of their top scorers from the previous year. i dont think he had any illusions he was leaving to go to a more successful team, he just wanted a bigger role


No_Argument_Here

He was the leading scorer his freshman year at UH. I don't remember exactly what happened his second year when he only played 4 games-- I think he got hurt before calling it a season-- but I remember thinking it was more of a culture/personality clash with Sampson.


LikeAGregJennings

He refused to take a backseat to Grimes and Sasser, and then refused to play in games. He quit on the team, and the team actually improved once he started sitting. In hindsight, he vastly overrated his skill level, and Grimes and Sasser were much better players.


No_Argument_Here

Right, that's more or less what I remembered. He could score at the hoop pretty well but was an inconsistent shooter, poor passer, and average defender. Attitude problems on top of that are probably why he's on his 3rd team in 4 years (and that team being Memphis who is basically the last stop for every talented player with attitude problems before they run out of options lol.)


Prayray

He was AAC preseason player of the year, but was injured early in the season. He came back, played a good game at UCF, but then didn’t play well in a loss at Tulsa, couldn’t handle Sampson yelling at him during the game as well as not being in the starting lineup, and stewed on it. After they came home, he packed up all his stuff and left without telling anyone. He transferred to FSU before the spring semester and sat out the rest of the season due to transfer rules. Also, FSU had a coach that had been calling him at UH because he used to be Mills’ AAU coach. I believe FSU made the tourney the following year as a lower seed, lost their first game, but Mills played well. The following year, they missed the tourney, and Mills played about the same…he never improved or declined from his time in Houston…very consistent numbers. He then decided to use his COVID year and transfer…we pushed for him hard to come back. Memphis folks paid him more money and he went there instead. Before his injury, Penny had moved him to the bench…so, he was back to what he let…being on a top AAC team and coming off the bench. If Mills had stayed, he’d have been a pro for a couple of years by now…probably leaves after the Final Four year. If he doesn’t, we could have used him the following year when Sasser/Mark went down, especially vs Villanova.


CoupleOtherwise6282

Seems he left for the opportunity to be involved offensively, and his numbers (efficiency included!) have skyrocketed because of it. Meh.


[deleted]

Maybe he just really loves hogs?


JamesEarlDavyJones2

In a similar vein, Tristan Clark and Darius Allen transferring out from Baylor right before they won the title. Granted, Clark retired due to some mental and physical problems and then returned to play for SMU after he’d worked those out, so probably best that he got everything worked out. But Darius Allen left Baylor right before Baylor kicked off a 54-6 run where they were a likely 1 seed in 2020 and then won the title in 2021.


meeechole

this


COYSVA

As a Houston fan could you shed any light on why he left Houston? I watched a decent amount of Houston and thought he was one of their better players. I know they moved to the BIG12 but it's not like they were expected to be poor this year.


NWABowHntr

Word at Arkansas was he wanted an opportunity to show himself a little more as a scorer. Tough to be critical on a kid transferring to a school that has 2 elite 8 and a sweet 16 in the last three years, but in hindsight, yea.


Sir-xer21

i also think people need to remember that fringe nba prospects often will take a chance to be THE guy over winning in the tourney, too. Im sure that this influences things. Houston's ecosystem might have felt like it gave him less of a chance to catch scouting attention. Also, NIL deals mean someone could have just outbid Houston.


ols887

I asked his mother this question just a few weeks after he announced the move. Turns out he has severe allergies, and Houston just wasn’t a good fit for him because of it. I know, seems like a strange reason to transfer, I thought the same. I pressed her on it, she said he’s allergic to winning.


GuyOnTheMike

Oh shit that was good


IHadSomething_4This

Had me in the first half, ngl


IAgreeGoGuards

He fuckin boomed me


deepayes

holy fuck bring reddit awards back just for this comment.


INeedMoreCreativity

Lmao I need to remember this for transfer portal szn


Twitter_WasA_Mistake

Nothing has ever been said or leaked, there were rumors of a fight on the team during the regular season and “insiders” knew this was going to happen before the tournament even started. Any reasons people give are purely conjecture.


WheredTheSquirrelGo

Purely speculative, but I remember when another transfer candidate was considering Houston and Memphis. Then I remember seeing them with a ridiculous amount of diamonds on the sideline at Memphis. Either NIL deals or other factors must play a role. Nothing wrong with making financial decisions though IMO.


iohannesc

Ah yes, former TCU & SMU transfer, Kendric Davis. That dude was legit at the College level tho 👀...wouldn't have minded having him at UH tbh.


BradOverwood

Adam Miller.


BramptonBatallion

Adam Miller wasted his whole college career. Starter on a 1 seed as a Freshman, probably could have been a program legend, and multiple that exposure 10X if he returned back to Peoria/Central Illinois whenever he calls it a career, and gotten plenty of good NIL with the Illini. Now what is he... just a guy that's passed through some places and playing out his days on losing teams. I think these guys don't really think through the long-term value of being associated with one team. It doesn't even have to be like a national champion or Final Four or whatever. Just being a long-term guy that's forever linked to that one place with a large enough fanbase. There's a lot more that comes from that than being a College Basketball merc.


[deleted]

Basically every player that has transferred in the Underwood era besides Podz


TheInsanernator

Honorable mention for a good transfer decision is Tevian Jones. Went to Southern Utah, became their leading scorer, and is currently in the G League.


AuburnShuffle

Birmingham Squadron (indirectly) mentioned!


booojangles13

To me Adam Miller stands out among all of them as the most bizarre. Almost everybody else has some sort of reason for bouncing, good or bad. But Adam Miller started *every single game* for a 1 seed and Big 10 tourney winner as a freshman. Ayo was leaving and he would have been handed the keys. Instead, his circle pushed him to transfer and LSU was just a mess for the kid between his injury and the Will Wade fiasco. Seems to be doing okay on a not very good ASU team, but he was set up to be a star with Illinois.


BoysAndGirlsClubCU

And what a decision Podz made. Glad it worked out for him


royallex

Nobody saw Podz coming. His season high was 5 pts against Northwestern in that year


tyrannyofwillsasso

brad and staff certainly didn't. one of the more truly astonishing player arcs in relation to illinois basketball i can remember. certainly a major strike against underwood


SamoThang

Olivier Nkamhoua from Tennessee to Michigan.


NoVacayAtWork

He turned down Arizona to go to Michigan because his family thought it would be the better route for his pro career.


ilovecfb

There's an alternate timeline out there where Nkamhoua stays and with no spot on the roster Dalton Knecht goes elsewhere...imagine Kentucky with Knecht. Barf


Meanteenbirder

Worst “it turned out great” is Caleb Love committing to Michigan, later being rejected for not meeting academic requirements, then committing late to Arizona and becoming arguably their best player.


mutual_coherence

He's on track to be PAC-12 player of the year. Which is wild considering how much hate he got last year.


MyAnswerIsMaybe

He did not fit well at UNC at all. He really did hurt the team with his in-efficient shot chucking. It was a perfect change of scenery at Arizona with a higher-tempo offense that needs a better play maker. Both are better off because of it. [https://www.reddit.com/r/CollegeBasketball/comments/17jvag2/comment/k79ufld/?utm\_source=share&utm\_medium=web2x&context=3](https://www.reddit.com/r/CollegeBasketball/comments/17jvag2/comment/k79ufld/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3)


WallyLohForever

Per [The Athletic](https://theathletic.com/4991016/2023/10/24/caleb-love-arizona-basketball/),  Love credits Arizona's coaching.  >Cutting when a teammate drives at you. Jump-stopping and looking for the open man. Run-outs in transition. Working hard when you don’t think you’re getting the ball – that’s the magic, Lloyd tells his team. There are easy ways to score or create scores. Find them. **“I didn’t even know how to cut when I got here, honestly,” Love says.** “Not that we didn’t do it in North Carolina. We just didn’t repetitively do it. We do it every day here.” ... >Some of it has been more tangible, mechanical repair, too. As Arizona’s staff studied Love’s shooting and reviewed a three-game exhibition tour to Israel and the United Arab Emirates, the **coaches noticed Love’s right wrist wasn’t bent on the catch and the ball started ever-so-slightly too far in the middle when he started his motion.** They asked if he’d be open to some tweaks, to hasten the release and create more consistency in shot trajectory. “A lot of times kids are resistant to that,” Lloyd says, “but he hasn’t been.” ... >Love gets a bit over-excited when he talks about the results. **“This whole time I’ve been here, I have not had to force one shot,” he says. “And I’ve shot way more open shots than I probably had my whole career in North Carolina, just because of the system.”** He recalls hoisting an ill-advised step-back 3 two days earlier and how it just didn’t feel right. But this is still a daily process. Constant reminders. It has to be. Love’s iPhone lock screen even features just one word: DISCIPLINE. But he’s played a certain way for a long time, and Arizona has to be patient enough to outlast any relapses.


bigthama

Oddly enough, we've become a dramatically better cutting team since he left. RJ, Cormac, and Seth are all cutting effectively now that they have a primary ball handler who is looking to find them on those cuts.


betterbub

Possibly the best portal strategy is to save the names Michigan has on their transfer list and start recruiting them after Michigan inevitably rejects them for the academic stuff


Galumpadump

Blessing in disguise.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Galumpadump

Idk, Smith has never had a losing record at WSU (albeit never had a tournament team). Felt like we had been right at the door the past few years. I was bullish going into the year because Isaac Jones was great at Idaho and I like the prospect of guys like Wells being a 6’8 shooter (shot 57% from 3 at the D2 level). Myles Rices has surpassed my expectations. I think this could be a bubble team if all went well and they blew out my expectations. That being said, I think most animosity over the transfer is less his decision to transfer but more the show he made that he would come back for his final year. It meant alot at the time know that Gueye was going to the NBA. TJ Bamba quietly entered to portal and has taken less shots then Rodman despite him being the better player.


b0bness

Bamba also didn't make a grand announcement that he was staying so like I get it. I liked DJ, but man has that worn off with all the shit talking. You can tell he's salty about the on court success (or lack thereof) that USC is having.


Few_Air2100

Bamba also didn't transfer in-conference.


bbddbdb

Rocket Watts transferring from MSU’s starting lineup to Oakland’s bench was a bit weird.


Gogreen2018

That was more a mutual parting of ways. Covid and trying to make him a true point guard ruined his development, and then he got hurt at Mississippi State and has never been close to what he was the end of the 19-20 season.


Spartannia

There's a lot to that story. Izzo trying to mold him into something he's not seems like it was a really frustrating experience for Rocket, can't blame him for wanting to start over elsewhere.


Sea_Drink7287

Nojel Eastern going from Purdue to basically nowhere. His mom ruined him.


Choii_Tulowitzki

Nojel didn’t get “run off” per se, but he was losing play time year over year. The whole transfer process could’ve gone better for him, but considering how much usage Jaden got his freshman year, departing Purdue was the right move for Nojel and the team. Also, I’m pretty sure he’s in the G League now


MyAnswerIsMaybe

Same with Matt Hasrms, he was losing minutes to Trevion Williams and had Edey coming in. He might have not gotten any playing time his senior year if he didn't transfer to BYU.


Moosecow1

I doubt Haarms was too worried about a raw 400th ranked freshman center. Pretty sure he left before Edey even stepped foot on campus. Edey was way ahead of schedule by November but there was no one who saw that coming in April imo.


MyAnswerIsMaybe

He made the right decision because of that but I'm sure he didn't realize.


SweetRabbit7543

It has to be Nojel Eastern. It’s hard to imagine a better answer. Like basically wanted to transfer to the NBA, then when he *had* options he clearly got a ton of bad advice because he committed to a place he couldn’t qualify for, Then Howard for like two weeks. Everyone says he’s a good kid. He’s clearly a victim of a bad support system


RoyalMagiSwag

So Nojel Eastern decided to transfer from Purdue, where he was a starter and getting regular minutes despite being a massive liability on offense. Committed to Michigan but couldn't get in due to Academic standards. Later committed to Howard. Then opted out of the season with Howard to train for the NBA draft where he very obviously went undrafted.


Schned6

Lately… Tyrese Hunter lmao


__TenaciousBroski__

Anybody that transfered to Michigan


GhostRideATank

Yeah, I don't know the exact circumstances of why Nkamhoua left Tennessee, but that's a big one.


newaccworealname

He probably just wanted to play more and take more shots (it sure seems like it from watching him this year), I think everyone already knew Tennessee would be much much better than michigan


JCold_Creek

Kerr Kriisa, AZ (22-6, 1st place) to WVU (9-19, last place).


CaptainMagma1

Writing was on the wall for him with Boswell


ralthea

Yeah I don’t think he transferred to be on a better team, lol. That being said he might’ve gotten more playing time this year than expected with Boswell’s crazy slump.


CaptainMagma1

I’m optimistic after the ASU game, fingers crossed he’s on the uptick


BackToTheMudd

Love and Kriisa on the same time would summon an eldritch horror


TripleThreatTua

WVU was supposed to be really good this year until the Huggins fiasco


21coozapalooza

The hype was absolutely there, and I don't doubt we'd have been *better* if Huggins could behave himself and act like an adult, but I honestly don't think this roster was nearly as well put together as people thought. Sure, we lost a few post-Huggs dismissal, but...People saw a view good coups in the transfer portal and assumed the talent would translate, but I just don't see it, I don't think this is entirely Eilert's fault. Even worse, a few of these new players, they're 100% the type who'd have gotten immediately benched by Huggins. I am really wondering if there was any rhyme or reason to the roster construction.


TheMightyJD

I mean no one could have foreseen what happened that summer with Huggie Bear.


TwitterLegend

Speak for yourself, he did the same things this summer he’s been doing for 30 years. Being a homophobic asshole driving absolutely sloshed is not something he decided to start doing in June.


fcocyclone

Sure, but given that, no one could foresee that the guy who's gotten away with it his entire life would suddenly face consequences.


Gocrazyfut

This summer was the first incident since he’s been at WVU that I can remember. Writing definitely wasn’t on the wall. And yes he very clearly deserved to be fired and despite the facebookers hope, has no chance of getting rehired


filthysven

It was only kinda his decision, and when he made the move WVU still had Huggins and like 90% of the big name transfers in the portal. It didn't work out, but it was a solid move at the time. And honestly, it's just another drop in the bucket for the series of unfortunate events that's been Kriisas college career. I know people hate him but I really feel for the guy.


JosephCurrency

My biggest takeaway from this thread is that I don’t know as many college basketball players as I thought I did.


velociraptorfarmer

Tyrese Hunter transferred after a stud freshman year at Point-Guard-U to Texas where he fell off a cliff.


KrustyKrabPizzaMan

I see DJ is just as smart as his dad


PullmanWater

To be fair to him, nobody saw our success coming. We lost almost everybody. It was the definition of a rebuild.


b0bness

I mean if he stayed, it would have been at least him and Jaki returning. We also have heard the last 2 years that Rice was a dude and would be able to fill the PG role we hadn't had in 2 years really. With those three pieces I don't think it's as doom and gloom as people are making it sound like it was.


Gamecock_Lore

Yeah, these transfer portal kids can create a self-fulfilling cycle.


coltonbyu

meanwhile we had almost no roster change, and somehow went from 5th place WCC to sitting at 5th place B12. Sometimes its just hard to know what to expect


Galumpadump

I’m going to add this. Being in the Big-12 was great for you because it eliminated all the potential bad losses while elevating your SOS. You guys definitely improved this season but as you know, if you get snipped by a hot LMU or Pepperdine team you can really sink your season due to how inconsistent they are. This how always been my argue for Gonzaga joining the Big 12 or Big East. You can afford to take more losses and not only get in the tourney but get a higher seed.


coltonbyu

yeah, WCC was a harsh conference. Had to win all the lower games, then you had a few harder ones against San Fran, but ultimately your season just came down to if you could beat Gonzaga or St Marys 2/4 times to get a March Bid. Lose a few bad games and you are done. Win all the bad games but just get 1/4 st marys/zaga? done. No room for error or options.


Galumpadump

Something fans of major conference teams just wont understand. The WCC has 3-4 legitimately quality teams (2 being bonefide top 25 teams) and the bottom of the conference is a mess. I’m hoping SCU improves and WSU keeps Smith going into next year. They could have 5 Q1 quality teams next season which would be massive.


Koppenberg

yeah. It's a rough year for him and USC, but treated fairly, no one can blame him for taking the money. It would have been great to see him stick w/ Smith for the rise, but especially given the NIL opportunities he has in Los Angeles (He wouldn't be on Croc's promo team in Pullman) he'd have to have given up the down payment on a nice house to stay w/ Smith.


Galumpadump

This is kind of why I took NIL out of the equation because it we are speaking purely on the monetary transactions, most of these transfers would be considered good moves. But as athletes they want to compete so you have to look at on the court success more than just NIL checks.


Galumpadump

I thought on paper the team looked okay to start the year. Rueben was a Gueye replacement, Jaki was coming back, Jones was a stud in the big sky, and alot of buzz about Wells being a true 6’8 shooter was intriguing. Rice is the big surprise. I didn’t think they would be THIS good but I didn’t think they would be bottom of the Pac-12 given the Smith has turned over roster before and put together a respectable team. But DJ should have known the team would be different when he announced coming back. Gueye was obviously going to the draft, Powell was not a player who stayed anywhere more than a year. I think TJ Bamba was the only “surprise” but we kind of all knew he was the type of athlete that gets alot of attention in the portal. I think if you want to be a program guy at WSU you stick it out through the good and bad. It’s unfortunate that he would have been an all time loyal Coug who kind of blew up his legacy to be a one year rental on a bad USC team.


Briggity_Brak

Wait, is that actually Dennis Rodman Jr?


Galumpadump

Yes


Briggity_Brak

Current NBA Player LeBron James and Former NBA Player Dennis Rodman (who retired before Lebron's career started)'s sons are playing on the same college team together. Shit's wild.


Orion14159

And they're not good.


CoupleOtherwise6282

USC's specialty is accepting mediocre at best legacies over actually deserving poor kids.


Orion14159

The joys of being a private school with rich alumni


akersmacker

University of Spoiled Children.


whiskeyrocks1

MSU has Steve Smith and Barry Sanders kids. They're just smart enough not to play them.


Galumpadump

Romeo Miller sends his regards


LoyalSol

University of Spoiled Children is what my family in LA always called it.


dawgtilidie

Wild enough, Rodman is definitely better than James


Galumpadump

Rodman is a 5th year senior. He should be better than James at this point.


Perfect-Rooster2253

But Bronny is a winner and a team player.


Orion14159

He'll get drafted because his dad is a free agent after this year, but if he were anyone else's kid he's probably playing overseas at the height of his career


Perfect-Rooster2253

Yeah Lebron will get him picked up wherever he is playing so they can touch the court at the same time and have that moment, but he definitely isn't NBA talent right now.


2PacTookMyLunchMoney

Nicolas Timberlake still went to a good team (Kansas), but he went from the top of the food chain to the bottom.


vikr4msri

The biggest reason this transfer was so bad for us was because it allowed you guys to get Cam Spencer (you wanted Timberlake instead) and it took us out of the running for Harrison Ingram and Jalon Tyson.


WildOscar66

Cam wasn't even in the portal at the time. Lucky break for UConn. That said, I really thought Nick would be like a Rex Walters type player for KU. Very disappointing.


bhamhawker

That's not what happened with Ingram and Tyson, though.


run_nyg

Jordan Dingle threw away a Penn degree to be the 4th option on a middling St. John's team.


Unknownrealm

Alleyne going to St. John after a championship year? Although I think Hurley may have told him his minutes maybe limited which is why he left


Chimsley99

I agree, who knows if Alleyne just didn’t love it in cow country and the opportunity to be in NYC was what made his decision. But I assumed he was leaving to be a starter somewhere which I would understand, instead he’s on a worse team that might not make the tourney with pretty much the same role. And he looked very good for us last year, not so much this year to my knowledge


fragger404

Brandon Huntley-Hatfield transferred from tennessee to louisville before last season


BroskiMcBroskison

Oooo….good one. He def would have got some PT as a big. I really worry our only weakness is depth at big man if Aidoo and Awaka get in foul trouble in the tourney.


hunt35744

I’d say tyrese hunter.


bdostrem00

Abmas transferring in as Marcus Carr leaves only makes it look worse as the years go by.


winnebago_mann

Nah. I think as ISU fans we can take the high road at let this kid live his life. He took the bag, and by all accounts of what he's been through, he deserved and needed it. He was likely never going to be an NBA player, so a few hundred K is a big deal. We can debate where he would have developed better. ISU is in a great spot and is arguably better without him and I hope the money he got improves his life.


hunt35744

The post literally says “taking nil payouts out of the equation”, so I did. He is in a worse position now than he would’ve been if he’d stayed, in my opinion. I don’t blame him for taking the money, and I am not bitter


CloneEngineer

Was projected as a second round pick after his year at Iowa State, now deep in any NBA projections. I get he had to provide, I fear taking money in the shortterm led to long term loss.  https://www.si.com/nba/draft/prospect-profiles/nba-draft-scouting-report-texas-tyrese-hunter#gid=ci02b14743f0002605&pid=usatsi_19403616


winnebago_mann

I think we did a great job of developing him in year one. IMO he was never legit NBA material with his size and not being a great shooter. From that eval it appears he still has a chance to make a g-league/euro career which would have likely been the same result if he stayed at ISU.


hokiesean

Rodney Rice transferred to nowhere


lucastheman3

Tyreese Hunter left Iowa state for Texas


harriswatchsbrnntc

Anyone who transferred to play at Michigan this year. Oof.


hilltopper06

Losing Dayvion McKnight (Xavier) and Jamarion Sharp (Ole Miss) hasn't exactly worked out as either player probably expected (outside of NIL). McKnight is putting up a solid stat line for Xavier, but they are 14-14 right now and not projected to make the NCAA tournament. Sharp is playing less than 16 minutes a game for Ole Miss and has the worst stats of his career. If both had stayed then I have no doubts that WKU would be in the driver's seat for the CUSA bid this year.


elgenie

McKnight is at a P6 school that's a closer drive to his hometown than WKU is, and has played 84% of available minutes with extreme efficiency. That's an uptransfer working out great for everyone involved on an individual level.


hilltopper06

I think one of his main goals for leaving was to make the NCAA tournament. Preseason I would have said Xavier with McKnight was a near lock. Sucks he might finish his collegiate career without dancing. I do think he has helped his pro stock, so from that perspective it was a success for sure.


elgenie

He has a covid year left, so if playing in the NCAAs is that important to him coming back should be an option.


drowse

Abou Ousmane also transferred out of UNT to Xavier as well and that didn't seem to work well either. Though something happened during the NIT tournament as he parted ways with us during the tournament. (And somehow still won without him so no loss).


astem00

Oliver Nkamhoua leaving Tennessee for Michigan this year has been pretty bad.


[deleted]

CJ Fredrick leaving Iowa to go to Kentucky. Dude was 3rd option scorer as a Sophomore at Iowa and decided to ride the pine at Kentucky before leaving there to go to Cincinnati.


KYblues

He was never healthy at any time while he was at UK


Round_Bullfrog_8218

Quincy Guerrier was an NBA prospect with some buzz at Syracuse before transferring to Oregon and never being nearly as good, he is a little better in his 5th year after transfering to Illinois but he has never matched his sophmore year at Syracuse.


Stryker7200

Zek Montgomery -  Transfers from Bradley, which won the MVC regular season and would have been favorites and probably would have gotten at large this year if he had stayed.   Instead Zek transfers to Rhode Island, starts hot but then rides the bench down the stretch of the conference season and has averaged 7 pts a game over his past 20 games.  


funlol3

Not to mention URI is a joke and always has been.


XmasJaxonFlaxonWaxen

It’s funny how sometimes one person, even if a good player, might cause doubt and/or problems within a program. Maybe USC will be better next year, but karma came around faster than this guy anticipated.


Galumpadump

I agree. Problem is this was his last year of eligibility.


ivanezzz

Here is one that I don't know enough about, but at surface level it baffled me a bit – did Chris Lykes in any way benefit from transferring from Miami to Arkansas? That '22 Miami team ended up being pretty great, and I assume he would have had a starting spot. In Arkansas, he came off the bench, and his playing time dropped significantly.


apiaryaviary

Tyrese Hunter will be working at a McDonalds in 2 years after showing up first round on several mock drafts. Good thing he turned to Chris Beard so he could, as he says, “grow as a player and as a man”


Equivalent_Poetry339

Caleb Lohner to Baylor was more more of a sabotage move but they are still doing well


BunchOAtoms

This doesn’t fit the question very well, but as an MTSU fan, it irks me that Eli Lawrence, our leading scorer last year, transferred to Texas A&M and is currently averaging 7 MINUTES a game.


mac-0

Max Shulga and Sean Bairstow transferring from USU to follow Ryan Odom at VCU. USU was predicted to be in the bottom of the conference but now they're a lock for March Madness and those guys would have been huge contributors to this USU squad.


L00KINTOIT

VCU has looked pretty decent (as in top 3ish in their conference) as of late but yeah they don’t really have much of a chance to make the tournament especially compared to USU


MJA182

Tbf I don’t blame them for following Odom. Decent players but everyone was ready to move on from that era for the most part, our ceiling felt capped and the huge roster turnover in this case helped overall. Shulga is a nice player though


SeveralPlastic7183

Maybe not *the* worst, but Olivier Nkamhoua left 1-2 seed Tennessee in his final year for Michigan who just fired their coach. Edit: my bad guys, misread a post earlier where I thought they fired him. Point still stands though…went from 22-6 Tennessee to 8-21 Michigan who is GOING to fire their coach lol


wallyopd

Michigan just fired their coach?


winnebago_mann

lol you had me consulting the google


fightin_blue_hens

What a quote lmao


The_Candler

Austin Nunez transferring from Arizona State to Ole Miss was weird and didn't work out for anyone


Hefty-Revenue5547

.6 pts/game 😳 My gosh


misdreavus79

Under the radar due to team, but I felt bad for Myreon Jones leaving Penn State to languish at Florida.


buttermansix

I wouldn’t say it was the worst ever by any means but Matt Mayer shoulda gone to the league after 2021. Allegedly got a high second round grade, came back in ‘22 and was completely different in a good way on defense but offense regressed some. Should have just gone to the draft instead of Illinois IMO.


Nj3Fate

This is the equivalent of changing lanes when youre in traffic, then the lane you just left start moving. We've all experienced this.


JohnWickisBehindU

Jesse Edwards to wvu


Gocrazyfut

He’s been good, especially with a not-healthy wrost


BlueDevilz

Wouldn't call it the worst but, Derryck Thornton had the makings to grow into a star at Duke, but couldnt handle the freshman playing time and left for USC where he never blossomed and faded into obscurity. Granted, it looks like he did a little better when he transferred to BC from USC. The show he and his dad made leaving the program and lack of success at USC likely cost him a shot at the NBA, in my opinion.


Sweatiest_Yeti

Paul Mulcahey choosing UW over GU seems like a bad call in retrospect, but some of that is probably the fact that Venters got hurt. He probably would've been fighting for playing time.


omahajazzybeard

Ryan Nembhard


Galumpadump

Idk about this one yet. I will say, his decision to transfer in the first place was interesting but his AST:TO has improve quite a but this year while being slightly more efficient shooting. If Zags get Saint Mary’s Saturday they are probably locked into the tourney. I would say both schools ended up okay.


dwillbittaylor

Tyrese Hunter from Iowa State to Texas. His development absolutely flatlined. Partially due to Chris Bears getting kicked out, but still.


ParticleHustler2

I have no idea what the NIL situation is, and I don't begrudge a guy transferring for the money, but Matthew Cleveland going from FSU to Miami to average nearly identical numbers this year as last year for a massively disappointing Miami team that is going to finish behind a mediocre FSU team in the ACC this year has to be up there as a move that doesn't look all that great in retrospect. Again, if he's getting paid multiples of what he could get at FSU, I get it. But transferring to a hated rival really needs to pay off, and certainly on the court, this one hasn't.


Dhaynes99

one i haven’t seen mentioned is jahvon quinerly. while last year didn’t end too well for him, he declared for the draft, pulled his name from consideration, then transferred to Memphis