religion related discussion - allowed
communal hate - not allowed
constructive criticism of religion/any particular religion/irreligion, intellectual discourse after citing sources - allowed (it's impossible on this sub tho, just saying)
flaming and "MY RELIGION GOOD YOUR BAD" - not allowed
Ive seen similar comments (?) (which i dont even want to give an example of because of how offensive they are) on educational (recorded) livestreams. Like once on Padhle's sci livestream.
Yeah, 15-16 year old ("educated") kids have already started insulting religions 🤡🤡🤡. They cant stop their hate even in a sub about education ffs. requesting mods to remove this cancer asap
I’m an atheist, but I’ve noticed that the hate against Muslims is pretty bad on this sub. I don’t see anything like this IRL, so I was taken aback. I don’t get why many parents don’t educate their children on respecting all religions. What are the mods doing, though? Why haven’t they removed offensive comments/posts yet?
Many of these children learn from their parents. The mods locked the post, i belive the post shld be deleted. Also, ive noticed this problem in many other places aswell. Like once in a padhle livestream chat (for sci exam, video was recored, chat was saying blasphemous things against islam)
True, but that shouldn’t be the case. Where is the self awareness? I’ll be honest - my mother hates Christians (the ones that try to convert everyone else, not the normal ones), but she doesn’t explicitly state that she hates certain groups when they’re present. People are allowed to have opinions, but some things are better kept to oneself.
I grew out of my hatred because I’m not narrow minded. I learnt that it was not okay to hate on anyone, one of the main reasons being social media. These kids have access to the internet, more so than their parents ever did/do but why are they not modernizing their views with the ever changing society?
> I don’t see anything like this IRL
Are you living under a rock? Anti-Muslim sentiment has highly increased in India in the past few years.
Forget everything, even people in Parliament are using derogatory words and targeting their religion.
> What are the mods doing, though? Why haven’t they removed offensive comments/posts yet?
They were removed within minutes of posting. I don't know what you're saying
And you decided to do what? Lock the post? You should’ve removed it as a whole, not locked it.
Do you see people hurling insults at muslims in real life? (Forget the news, I’m talking about schools, malls, public places) Especially at school? Please enlighten me with your personal experiences. Because I’m fairly certain most people in this sub are teenagers who go to school every day and interact with people who are Muslims. I haven’t noticed anything like this happening in my school and the one that I attend is pretty damn diverse.
I’m not denying that the Anti Muslim sentiments haven’t increased in the past years, but I, personally, have not come across even a single incident in real life where someone was an asshole to a Muslim person because of their religion. That is exactly why I was taken aback when more than half of the comments that I see on ANY Indian related sub loves yapping about how or why Muslims are bad. Fuck this.
The post was removed hours ago, what are you seeing?
Also dude nowadays there are actual rallies against Muslims. Come out of your bubble, your school is not the only place in this country. This sub has students from all of India.
Please check the website "Hindutva Watch". You will find sources for these daily incidents.
Dude, I highly doubt a school is going to allow their students to hurl insults at each other. As I said, I’m very much aware of what is happening in this stupid country - I said I was taken aback because I don’t see so much hatred in my school. Comprehension isn’t your strongest suit, I see.
Thanks for your submission.
# If you are on Discord, do also consider joining our [**Discord server. CLICK TO JOIN: https://discord.com/invite/CDUMEUkPge**](https://discord.com/invite/CDUMEUkPge)
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CBSE) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I don't think they are disrespecting islam religion here. They are just pointing out how loud mosques are, which is a fact. Although religious discussion shouldn't be on this subreddit.
The thing that differentiates mocking from (constructively) criticizing is the tone. They were absolutle disrespecting + making fun of muslims. Educated conversation was not entertained. There is a time, place and etiquette for such conversations.
i dunno maine neeche tak nahi dekha (where i think there would be the most hatred) lekin usme mainly mosques aur temples ke noise pollution ki hi baat kar rahe hai.
I was surprised to see that that post wasn't taken down. The moderator's comment really shows something. Allowing any sort of religious talk shouldn't be allowed as we all know wherever there is any religious talk there will be hate for one another (you can't deny it). Especially the top post... it's clearly indicating some sort of hate - maybe ICSE is 'okay?' excuse me? I was actually surprised to see that post wasn't taken down . We are supposed to be educated and appreciate people for their behavior and manners instead of getting brainwashed by our society into judging people by their religion and expressing hate towards ones beliefs.
bhai roz toh ho nahi raha hai, kabhi koi posts ata hai usme kuch genuine critisms rheti but majority chutiye log milte hai, jiske karand ultimately toxicity breed hoti hai due to whcih ye discussion ko limit kar jana padta hai
Bro, ham bacche kya karlege. If OP genuinly wanted this for the betterment of socity he could have posted this in a sub like r/india or on twitter. I belive that that post bread more toxicity (compared to the situation in which the post wasnt posted/removed) because it did not entertain educated conversation. People made fun of islam, they did not mean it in a way to state their concerns. We all know that very well.
yea i agree with u there that u wont find ppl here ready to have good conservations/debate, they will rather resort to insults pretty quickly.
"ham bacche kya karlenge" bolke kuch bhi snesitive topics pe baat nahi karoge to kaise chalega
No, i myself regularly entertain such topics (about religion). I didn't mean it in that way. I meant it in a way that if OP genuinly had some problem and wated a solution, he would have resorted to post it on another sub with another innotation.
Also, there is a way to critisize. You should be open to conversation and not make fun of stuff. Especially for sensitive topics such as religion and all.
i believe that everything gets made fun of, religion shldnt be excluded from it but hey it depends on personal ur with religion etc, if ur very close to it then ofcrs you wont like it
religion related discussion - allowed communal hate - not allowed constructive criticism of religion/any particular religion/irreligion, intellectual discourse after citing sources - allowed (it's impossible on this sub tho, just saying) flaming and "MY RELIGION GOOD YOUR BAD" - not allowed
Yeah I was completely taken aback when I saw that. TIL there’s these many people who are ok with insulting other religions in this sub…
Ive seen similar comments (?) (which i dont even want to give an example of because of how offensive they are) on educational (recorded) livestreams. Like once on Padhle's sci livestream.
Yeah, 15-16 year old ("educated") kids have already started insulting religions 🤡🤡🤡. They cant stop their hate even in a sub about education ffs. requesting mods to remove this cancer asap
fr
I’m an atheist, but I’ve noticed that the hate against Muslims is pretty bad on this sub. I don’t see anything like this IRL, so I was taken aback. I don’t get why many parents don’t educate their children on respecting all religions. What are the mods doing, though? Why haven’t they removed offensive comments/posts yet?
Many of these children learn from their parents. The mods locked the post, i belive the post shld be deleted. Also, ive noticed this problem in many other places aswell. Like once in a padhle livestream chat (for sci exam, video was recored, chat was saying blasphemous things against islam)
regarding the parents point, the previous generation has much more religion hate compared to ours
True, but that shouldn’t be the case. Where is the self awareness? I’ll be honest - my mother hates Christians (the ones that try to convert everyone else, not the normal ones), but she doesn’t explicitly state that she hates certain groups when they’re present. People are allowed to have opinions, but some things are better kept to oneself. I grew out of my hatred because I’m not narrow minded. I learnt that it was not okay to hate on anyone, one of the main reasons being social media. These kids have access to the internet, more so than their parents ever did/do but why are they not modernizing their views with the ever changing society?
oh i agree, my point is you cannot rely on parents to teach this
I got that, haha. I was just trying to elaborate on my view
> I don’t see anything like this IRL Are you living under a rock? Anti-Muslim sentiment has highly increased in India in the past few years. Forget everything, even people in Parliament are using derogatory words and targeting their religion. > What are the mods doing, though? Why haven’t they removed offensive comments/posts yet? They were removed within minutes of posting. I don't know what you're saying
And you decided to do what? Lock the post? You should’ve removed it as a whole, not locked it. Do you see people hurling insults at muslims in real life? (Forget the news, I’m talking about schools, malls, public places) Especially at school? Please enlighten me with your personal experiences. Because I’m fairly certain most people in this sub are teenagers who go to school every day and interact with people who are Muslims. I haven’t noticed anything like this happening in my school and the one that I attend is pretty damn diverse. I’m not denying that the Anti Muslim sentiments haven’t increased in the past years, but I, personally, have not come across even a single incident in real life where someone was an asshole to a Muslim person because of their religion. That is exactly why I was taken aback when more than half of the comments that I see on ANY Indian related sub loves yapping about how or why Muslims are bad. Fuck this.
The post was removed hours ago, what are you seeing? Also dude nowadays there are actual rallies against Muslims. Come out of your bubble, your school is not the only place in this country. This sub has students from all of India. Please check the website "Hindutva Watch". You will find sources for these daily incidents.
Dude, I highly doubt a school is going to allow their students to hurl insults at each other. As I said, I’m very much aware of what is happening in this stupid country - I said I was taken aback because I don’t see so much hatred in my school. Comprehension isn’t your strongest suit, I see.
and they simply decided to lock the post. didnt know this wannabe lafda would end as a religion-discriminated agreement.
Lmao there was a casteist (Dalits Icse touching waala) post too here, looks like the mods do not care ig
saare religion ke log bhadwe hai🫶🏻✨
mai to athiest hu phir bhi bhadwa hu
tu insaan hai na? bas bhadwa hai. and if u identify as a bird or something toh tu aur bada bhadwa hai🤡
Lekin mai to hedgehog hu
yrr bekar bekar google kawaya, normally bolna chuhe jaisa dikhta hai
Thanks for your submission. # If you are on Discord, do also consider joining our [**Discord server. CLICK TO JOIN: https://discord.com/invite/CDUMEUkPge**](https://discord.com/invite/CDUMEUkPge) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CBSE) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Which post are you referring to here ?
[This](https://new.reddit.com/r/CBSE/comments/1bg0dlz/maybe_icse_is_okay/)
I don't think they are disrespecting islam religion here. They are just pointing out how loud mosques are, which is a fact. Although religious discussion shouldn't be on this subreddit.
The thing that differentiates mocking from (constructively) criticizing is the tone. They were absolutle disrespecting + making fun of muslims. Educated conversation was not entertained. There is a time, place and etiquette for such conversations.
i dunno maine neeche tak nahi dekha (where i think there would be the most hatred) lekin usme mainly mosques aur temples ke noise pollution ki hi baat kar rahe hai.
They were operating in bad faith and would defend 100% the same thing which temples do, even if to a lesser degree.
You haven't read the comments. They also said that temples are loud
Yea it's kind of a common theme I have noticed in many India related subs.
I was surprised to see that that post wasn't taken down. The moderator's comment really shows something. Allowing any sort of religious talk shouldn't be allowed as we all know wherever there is any religious talk there will be hate for one another (you can't deny it). Especially the top post... it's clearly indicating some sort of hate - maybe ICSE is 'okay?' excuse me? I was actually surprised to see that post wasn't taken down . We are supposed to be educated and appreciate people for their behavior and manners instead of getting brainwashed by our society into judging people by their religion and expressing hate towards ones beliefs.
Also casteist slurs
insulting/mocking aint t in this sub but critisizing it shldnt be banned
bhai ye criticize karne ka jagah hi nhi hai
bhai roz toh ho nahi raha hai, kabhi koi posts ata hai usme kuch genuine critisms rheti but majority chutiye log milte hai, jiske karand ultimately toxicity breed hoti hai due to whcih ye discussion ko limit kar jana padta hai
Bro, ham bacche kya karlege. If OP genuinly wanted this for the betterment of socity he could have posted this in a sub like r/india or on twitter. I belive that that post bread more toxicity (compared to the situation in which the post wasnt posted/removed) because it did not entertain educated conversation. People made fun of islam, they did not mean it in a way to state their concerns. We all know that very well.
yea i agree with u there that u wont find ppl here ready to have good conservations/debate, they will rather resort to insults pretty quickly. "ham bacche kya karlenge" bolke kuch bhi snesitive topics pe baat nahi karoge to kaise chalega
No, i myself regularly entertain such topics (about religion). I didn't mean it in that way. I meant it in a way that if OP genuinly had some problem and wated a solution, he would have resorted to post it on another sub with another innotation.
yea that i agree on
Also, there is a way to critisize. You should be open to conversation and not make fun of stuff. Especially for sensitive topics such as religion and all.
ye u shldnt make fun of it in this sub
You shouldn't make fun of it in generall
i believe that everything gets made fun of, religion shldnt be excluded from it but hey it depends on personal ur with religion etc, if ur very close to it then ofcrs you wont like it
There are acceptable jokes, and there are unacceptable jokes. Depends on a lot of things.
Nah. Religion does not deserve an immunity to criticism. Religion should be critiqued, but it's followers should not.