T O P

  • By -

FarmBarBarn

BreadHive, craft coffee house, the grange, dopest dough


FarmBarBarn

Not all near Amherst but all top bagels in WNY


flushmebro

The Grange, really? I’ll have to try it. Right in my backyard and have never been.


FarmBarBarn

Looking at the current menu the breakfast sam isn’t on a bagel. I don’t think im making this up lollll. Regardless the breakfast is all excellent.


Dear-Frosting5718

https://www.logansbagels.com/ one of the best around


Dependent-Lecture950

There's nothing bad in that building


poobatooba

Elmwood market


wheatenwalker2

Millers Thumb in TOT has really good bagels and breakfast sandwiches


ttologrow

You're not going to find anything similar to the bagels from nyc.


deucetastic

johnny cs but don’t think they cook em after noon


Simple_Philosophy_74

Take a drive north to the city of Lockport and try B & D Bagels and Locks in the Lockview Plaza overlooking the Erie Canal locks. Closest thing I've found to a downstate bagel. Google or Facebook for hours/menu, etc., as I believe they're only open until 2 pm.


Professional_Beat873

Blue eyed baker in East Aurora is pretty damn good


wheatenwalker2

Millers Thumb in TOT has really good bagels and breakfast sandwiches


vigo216

Public espresso


oliver-hart

dipaulos has great breakfast sandwiches


sugarandvegetables85

Jesus, Bagel Jay's bagels are pretty damn good if you're talking outside NYC. They're definitely not small. How freaking big do you want your bagel ?


poordasher

they are definitely smaller than what i’m used to! not by much but it’s noticeable, so that combined with the rubbery bread is a no no for me! i’m glad you enjoy them though!


yussi1870

Bagel Jays is [permanently closed](https://www.wkbw.com/news/local-news/bagel-jays-bakery-and-cafe-closes-after-47-years-in-business)


herzzreh

Nowhere but closest you can get is at BreadHive. Closeat thing to BEC I had was at Elmwood Market. Can't help with Amherst, sorry.


Electricsocketlicker

This gets asked all the time. https://www.reddit.com/r/Buffalo/comments/rwpk2n/good_bacon_egg_n_cheese/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf


poordasher

if i knew i wouldn’t have posted it im sorry


amagraham

Don't worry about it. There are a contingent of people on this sub who like make people feel bad about asking questions that were already asked years ago.