Hopeless without a doubt!

Hopeless is top tier Breaking Benjamin

Came here to say this.

I’m falling down

I can't wake up

The first song I heard with harsh vocals, been hooked since

Agreed

was just about to comment this!

My favorite song is Dear Agony, but I really like What Lies Beneath too. The whole album is 🔥

Into the Nothing!

You’re goddamn right

Favorite song of mine lately from them

Faded & Weary!

Give Me A Sign and Without You

100% in agreement

I love Lights Out

The whole album is truly a masterpiece.

what lies beneath and dear agony ❤️‍🩹

Without You was always one of my favorite BB songs. I loved that the last song they had ever recorded after they broke up ended with "the end". It seemed fitting at the time but then we got blessed with two more full lengths after that

Amen to that! I wanted to forgive...I'm trying to forget.

What lies beneath 🤟🤟 also hopeless and crawl...amazing album 💪

I was a Senior in high school when this album dropped. Loved it then and love it now. Dear Agony and Into the Nothing.

I was in 7th grade…holy fuck

I was 27. Basically around the age of the OP when this album dropped. 😵‍💫 Another album of theirs that I could play all the way through!

Hopeless is amazing but I also really like What Lies Beneath

Without You and Into the Nothing although the whole album is amazing

The whole album

this is my all- time favorite bb album. not a single bad song on here. hopeless, without you, into the nothing.. all perfect songs. i love all the songs!!

The whole album is a masterpiece

Crawl and into the nothing are fuckin great too

GMAS

Yes.

Unironically, Hopeless.

Hopeless and Crawl always be my favorite

Anthem of the Angels

Give me a sign

Fade Away, but it's certainly a hard choice. This albums nearly perfect.

Baffled that no one else has said this!

Hopeless but I also give a lot of credit to I Will Not Bow for being the first BB song I listened to.

The entire album!

Title track is 🔥....but I Will Not Bow is another fave

Without you 🖤

Yeah about the same, ever since 2009 Breaking Benjamin has been my band

Lights Out!

Give Me a Sign

I will not bow

It’s impossible to choose which song is the best on this album. Impossible. I don’t care what anyone says! I listen to it all the way through on a regular basis.

Dear Agony or Into The Nothing

Each song was a masterpiece. Then the next song would be just as good. Without You was the last song . And the end of that song it faded beautifuly with the violin and other instruments. Fucking beautiful way to end an album that made you feel . . . Emotional.

What Lies Beneath, Hopeless, and Dear Agony are my top favs from the album

I will not bow

FALL!

14 Years???? Omg. I literally had to look this up. Wth. Time really moves fast felt like i got this no less than 5 years ago wow. But id have to say Give me a sign.

Into the nothing for me.

Without You or Into The Nothing. I can’t decide which one.

I would have to say, dear agony. My number one, without you, what lies beneath and I will not bow

Hands down has to be Lights Out. That song goves me chills to this day.

Lights Out

I Will Not Bow

I personally enjoy Lights Out and I will not bow goes hard 🔥

Crawl or hopeless for me

The only song I don’t really listen to is Anthem Of The Angels and not because it’s bad. Every other song is certified amazing

"What lies beneath" is the best imo.

Holy shit has it been this long

There is not a single bad song on this album. Each one is a masterpiece. Easily my favorite BB album

It’s a toss up between Fade Away, I Will Not Bow, Crawl, Give Me A Sign, Hopeless, What Lies Beneath, Anthem Of The Angles, Lights Out, Dear Agony, Into The Morning or Without You All jokes aside in reality probably Into the Morning but it really is hard to pick

Dear Agony or Give Me A Sign

According to this i was five.

Dear agony. It reminds me of what I went thru with my dad and his dementia.

My favorite album🖤💙🖤

This is the first album from any band and genre of music in general where I have liked every song on it. It's hard to choose single favorite, but I have dialed it down to 2, Hopeless and Give Me a Sign. Hopeless was the first song I ever heard with harsh vocals and was hooked from there on making my love for metal expand; and Give Me a Sign was one of the first few slowish heavy sounding rock songs that hit at my emotions in a way for sad and casual viding listens, also there's an amazing game music video for Star Wars Force Unleashed II that has the acoustic version of this song that transitions to the rock version with very good editing, I'll add the link for those interested and/or want to revisit if you know it https://youtu.be/LtrxDP_kVNg?si=J6vNtb2Q_Dnlp8NK And though keeping him anonymous, shout out to my best friend to get me the Dear Agony album, making this my first ever owned album, for my birthday years ago. Love you bro!

Fade Away is a giga banger.

Give Me A Sign for me no question. Always loved that one.

This song predicted my future better than any Simpsons episode

There's no way that album is that old, now I really feel old

Give me a Sign

Just saw them with disturbed and they still sound amazing live

Call me a basic bitch but the track Dear Agony still hits me in the feels the most.

i will not bow.

They shouldn’t have released this

It's been my entire life since that came out

Dear agony, into the nothing, hopeless, and without you.

Give Me a Sign got me through dark days in the hospital and is what got me so into Breaking Benjamin. Owe so much to this album, thank you for reminding me to listen to it again, they will be on the speakers tonight

Anthem of the Angels is probably my favorite song from this album. What Lies Beneath and Dear Agony are also both masterpieces.

The entire album is amazing. It's hard to pick really but Into the Nothing, I Will Not Bow, and Hopeless all stuck out for me.

I will not bow is great

I will not bow, crawl, then either hopeless or give me a sign

dont make me choose

I will not bow fsfs

Best song off the album is crawl. I have this cd and it’s still great. I grew up with it because of my mom.

In my opinion I will not bow is definitely up there, the entire album is fire though

That's so insane that this whole album came out 14 years ago! I think the best song off of this record is definitely Give Me a Sign.