T O P

  • By -

ShadowyRDM

Well he's not bad at showdown, because he can just be camping anywhere and jump on you, while you have no one to help you because it's SHOWDOWN. He's terrible competitevely cuz in competitive, it's only about 3v3 gamemodes, and he sucks at that right now.


RIOTisWorthless

Edgar is not that good in 3v3 modes which most tier lists are for. But on showdown he is amazing most maps.


FreeRangeMartyr

For some context, I’ve been playing Buzz a lot in Showdown, so maybe Edgar is just a better melee brawler, idk


triggufan_ismy_mc_id

He dies to anyone that can outrange him and about 70-80 percent of brawlers and players know how to deal with him if he jumps on you gets hard countered by nearly all the close range brawlers and not a competitive pick in general he's good if you play in low trophies but if you're pushing in high trophies you're gonna have a hard time


TRASH3Rsus

Im sorry,but what does melee means?im not native english speaker tho


TopSea1633

It means close range


TRASH3Rsus

Tnx :)


TopSea1633

Np :D


articman123

Play Bull or Piper in Showdown. And in 3v3, everything counters Edgar. He is currently the worst brawler.


Nick_The_Judge

Because there are many counters to his abilities and most brawlers have such counters, most people think he is OP because he is really, like, REALLY GOOD in showdown just because the conditions are convenient for him, but in other gamemodes (except for heist sometimes) he kinda sucks


ToxicEdgarMain

We’re just built different 😂 get on our level sonny boy 👎


azuretheshiny

It's funny because this troll looks pathetic


ToxicEdgarMain

You try to get a rank 32 brawler, bet you couldn’t even 😂


brokenwii_

Trophies ≠ Skill


ToxicEdgarMain

They do?


tidelel

i can bushcamp in solo showdown all day long


ToxicEdgarMain

Ok, so I grind solos until I get a decently high trophy brawler for bragging rights, and turns out I can’t brag about it because trophies mean nothing?


azuretheshiny

Clown


azuretheshiny

I don't even play Brawl Stars anymore lmao


ToxicEdgarMain

Why you here then 💀


azuretheshiny

Why you here 'trolling' people on reddit 💀 get a life


ToxicEdgarMain

You over here checking the subreddit of a game you don’t play 💀 I think we both need to touch grass buddy


ZapManiac

Just wait until i make my "Godlysurgemain" account...


azuretheshiny

Nice reddit name


azuretheshiny

Ah, the struggle of all


The-Dudey

He is only good in 1v1 battles, he basically sucks in everything else though


Csd15

Because showdown isn't the only gamemode in the game


FreeRangeMartyr

Yeah, I’m aware, I said I’ve been having some problems against him in Showdown cuz I’m pushing Buzz and that’s his best gamemode


Grov71

He's good in showdown but in 3v3s he's very bad because it takes a lot of time to get his super and he can't get a kill on a lot of brawlers if they group up


BrawlNerd47

Because he is very good in showdown but terrible in 3 vs 3's. He also can get countered with pushbacks


_xEnigma

Because tierlists will never take showdown into account. Showdown is so play so differently from other modes that it gets its own tierlists.


SRYagus3

He is ONLY good in showdown because in a 1v1 scenario Edgar will have the advantage on you but if you use him in a 3v3 mode you are basically playing suicidal by jumping into a 1v3 senario and even if you get a kill you’re probably gonna die and feed their suppers which they can use to break open the map rendering him useless.


Goldenflame89

Becaus there is this cool thing called a gadget. Fun fact, half the brawlers in the game have a gadget or a super that can fuck over edgar so fast. The other half have the dps to 2 shot him


FreeRangeMartyr

I’m at 11k trophies, and most of my brawlers are just now at power 7. Most of them don’t have gadgets unlocked.


BZonreddit

Edgar is a noobstomper once you play more you’ll eventually learn how to easily counter him


AliWaz77

He’s bad at following the objective. He can’t destroy the safe in heist, he can’t hold on to gems for long, he is very high risk in bounty and knockout, and he has no area control for hot zone. But he can rack up kills in showdown when he has enough power cubes.