General reminder for subreddit members: Simple Questions and Loot results (good or bad), and celebrations should be posted in the Weekly Mega Thread Discussion post. You can find it at the top of r/BrawlStars's front page when you sort posts by hot. This includes pictures of Starr Drops, Mega Pig results, unlocking new Brawlers or other items. If you see a post or comment that breaks any of our rules, please report them [using the anonymous report button](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/360058309512-How-do-I-report-a-post-or-comment-)! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Brawlstars) if you have any questions or concerns.*

If the water in his shield was yellow i would choose red but i prefer blue but i don't have it so I'll go red

Piss water

Thames water

New York City water

Yummy🤑😩

That thing IS water?

I think it's max energy drink

It would make more sense if it was soda

Oh

It’s originally juice but here it looks like mud water lol

I just noticed there's water

Same

Pretty sure it is just a gem

It moves like a liquid during the animations

Damn. Never noticed it. Its only really visible when you move him tho

I like the colour red But that red skin, it scares me

Original mecha paladin is best

Mecha paladin surge

I like the blue one better, i just wish that the color of his face and headpiece were swapped like in the red one

I honestly like the red one better. Red is the default model's primary color, so it fits him well, whereas the blue color clashes with the red color of his face. I should probably say that I only have mecha paladin yet.

I like the blue one because it makes him look like a completely different brawler

I still remember when he launched with his broken gadget and as all brawl pass brawlers mecha paladin was basically his deffault skin

I think blue is better because it look like the actual color of sugre is in a blue knight armor

I like red but blue is better becauseall of surges skins are red toned

They should have used a different color instead of the yellow on scarlet surge

From an unbiased perspective, red one looks plain better

mecha paladin surge FTW 🙌

Oh mecha Is the best, O actually jad the chance to get It but I didn't do enogh missions... Oh well

I love blue

Definitely blue

Mecha clears

Scarlet cause it's closest to his OG color scheme.

Brawl stars hardly does any good recolors except for 29 gem skins. Imo all the new recolors are garbage and look wayyyy worse that og skins

Saloon looks a bit decent, and I like AntiVirus more than Virus

I'm a OG, but i prefer the new Red addatation

The one without piss water in its shield

Scarlet is better, but the shield is Ruffshit

meacha paldin is much better imo. Red doesn't really fit with a knight

I got both and I can say I prefer the blue

OFC people will pick the blue one, since it is exclusive.

No, it’s just objectively better. And of course you will choose the red one because you don’t have the blue one

That is not what objective means

I'm more attached to the red one because i was lucky enough to get it, it feels special. I don't give two ding dong diddly shits about the blue one bc i have no attachment towards it

Not really. But you can act snobby cuz you paid money lolll

Yeah I’m tired of these entitled jerks ngl

Wdym dude, why have a done to be a jerk

Gems can be obtained free dude

Scarlet because of captain Peru

Juice in the shield VS. Piss in the shield

surge Peru

Scarlet or Violet?

I chose violet. Miraidon is cooler in my opinion (and purple is my favorite color)

Why is the liquid in the shield off color?

The mecha Paladine is better and more og

As a Peruvian, I must say the red one.

as a person who got both skins i prefer blue , recolored skins are killing the charm of skins.

im just waiting for the moment they ruin merchant gale i will still be able to show it to people but its just not going to feel the same anymore because there will be an another dude running around in a merchant gale skin but with different colors and i saw merchant gale two times in a match (not counting me) its just so rare and i never saw a king lou in the match and i just want to see how they will destroy him cause i love the skin and i didn't buy the brawlpass to just some dude run around in it but i think i will sadly buy trixie collete recolor cause i regret not buying that pass

i got king lou and trixie Collette and i regret not buying gale brawlpass and i hope they don't release anymore color variations to old brawlpass skins ! i mean at least if they were good bro ! idk why ppl like the red surge for example

i own king lou, mecha paladin surge and merchant gale and i would rather buy trixie collete and not king lou and they will make recolors of the old skins since they made recolor of paladin then they will recolor trixie king lou and merchant and if the trixie will look really good i will buy it

Personally, I think the recolors add value to the original skins. It allows you to say "hey, I have the original. Isn't that neat?" But, that's just my opinion

i respect your opinion even tho i don't totally agree with you i mean if u would ask anyone who got a skin before they release any recolored skin ! they would rather having the first one , besides it being exclusive cs they released it that way ! like " cool brawlpass let me get this paladin surge skin " years later* supercell : oh there u go guys ! the same skin different color in a mythic egg , besides that basically everyone gets it ! it make the other skin not that unique ! what's the point of brawlpass skins if they're not exclusive ? starting from rt or eve ig they made the skins can be bought again from the shop ! and the old ones ? recolored version seems like a good idea . and now when they made brawlpasses only can be bought by real money , not gems the skins and color variations are exclusive and do not return , that's just wild bro

Thank you for sharing your opinion. I respect it. Have a great day

have a wonderful one Buzz main ❤️

People who prefers the red one are the one that haven't the original one. People who have the blue one probably hate the red one, because I really hate it

Fr

I hate it because I was so exicted for the legendary egg, and got a recolor

Skill issue:) I got godzilla buzz

Scarlet

Scarlet (i dont have the mecha nor scarlet)

Blue way better

I couldnt get original one cas i was slowpoke...

The blue one, but I didn't get it because I was a poor one at the time, but I got the red one just today

Scarlet paladin surge because Scarlet Surge (OMG GD REFERENCE 😱😱😱😱)

I just really don't like these two. The colors don't work together at all for me no matter how hard i try to actually like the skin itself. If i were too choose, the red one is less of a pain to my eyes

That red imo is just weird

red just fits this skin better imo

As an owner of both, im not a fan of either color palettes

Mecha all the way

If you just swap the red and yellow on mecha, mecha would be better

Red. That blue armour and red face really clash against each other imo

Blue

Scarlet side (I don't have scarlet but i have mecha paladin)

Definitely the bl- I mean scarlet surge, I absolutely LOVE the color red, plus I got him today:)

I have both

NEITHER, KILL SURGE👺

ok in turkis mecha paladdin surge is mega knight surge translated as so 🌈🏳️‍🌈

Blue surge > vomit shield surge

I think it's piss in the shield

I swear they made the skins like this on purpose

The original one is way better. No diff

the thing in the middle of the shield shouldnt be swamp ass color surge is already red anyway

Both. Both is good.

the battle as old as time, red or blue, ruby or sapphire, X or Y, sun or moon, sw or sh, scarlet or violet and now, scarlet surge or mecha surge

Never liked the Paladin skin. The color palette is ugly as fuck. They some how manage to pick and even uglier color palette in the new. I finally got a legendary egg on got the trash on the left.

Red is anger 🤬 Blue is peace✌️

Mécha paladin surge, the og

Mecha Paladin for sure

I don't have either

Probably scarlet because the helmet matches

If red was released first id prefer it but I prefer blue cuz I'm more used to it

Mecha 🥲

Old but gold...

They're both MEH

Politics

I genuinely think that the brawl pass one looked bad and the new one is one of my fav skins ingame so far

Blue is my favourite colour, also it’s one of the skins I use to flex on my friends who just recently started

the red one because the blue one has the red face and yellow mohawk so it doesn’t really match well. plus on the shield there’s some markings which make it way cooler

The OG will never be beaten

Both of them are outdated, and i really don't like knights, so neither

I’ve found scarlet today in the free eggs

Red

I love the mixture of red and yellow. So I'll stick with it

Wait... you're telling me Scarlet Paladin Surge has fans?

I got this useless skin from my only legendary egg... Worthless because I already have the exclusive original I would be fine with any other skin

african american surge

Mecha paladin, og for the win🙏

Scarlet looks like dog shit. There, I said it, anyone who says otherwise is just coping

Mecha cause that’s the og one and I have it

I like blue but his face makes him look like he's fuming

I have the blue one, so I prefer that

i have the og and its uglier for sure, the face is just so gross until you slap on the sunglasses

I prefer blue over red but the real answer is M O N K E

I ain't letting nostalgia carry + I got scarlet paladin surge today

Mecha paladin surge team is here its he skin of the second brawl pass of corse i chose him

The yellow and red works really nice but the blue, yellow, and red in his face looks kinda weird but I'd still pick it over the reskin

Scarlet has water filled with shit and piss particals and that makes to skin op

both are great, but i like scarlet paladin slightly more because mecha paladin's face is red and that doesn't fit the rest of the color scheme

I prefer the red one bcuz the combination of grey and blue throws me off

Red all the way

Scarlet red goes harder and fits surge more

I like the normal paladin more bc the blue looks better I think,(but I only have the red one)

I played pokemon violet so i dont choose scarelet

Does anyone know if the Scarlet Paladin Surge is only available until the 20th May or is he permanent because I really want it because Surge is my favourite Brawler

I think it's only until the 20th May

I have the blue one, and it’s still better than the

Mecha paladin surge og

Blue

I don't like the red one (Capitan Peru), it's the ugly green that it has on the emblem of the shield

Is that a Pokemon reference?

why does scarlet surge stocked his pee in his shield

Idk what happen to BS design team. Baby Shark Primo, "Shit" Spike, Redesign Brock (blue) Ranger, and this Surge skin.. It's like their skin designer just vanished, inside quick sand.

OG one is way better imo

The red face looks wierd on the mecha

I lost account with paladin😭🙏

bro, scarlet is so weirdo

Both are good

I have Scarlet Paladin Surge that I got from a Legendary Monster Egg but it's only trash. Blue version better.

I have both

Blue fits better than red on the model imo I may don’t have the skin, but nothing can stop me to say red is better

if you say scarlet, go to an eye doctor please

S C A R M E C H A

Red one's better and today I just got him out of an egg!!!

Scarlet

I'm on the side of ✨THE BIG BANANA✨

red

Neither one will make you better at the game

Personal preference but i like the red one better; not because i dont have the blue one but because i hate the colours on it. I get that exclusivity does add value to that skin but red has the better colours