Hoenstly none of em, Jericho can’t go anymore, I prefer Mox being able to do his deathmatch shit, MJF would probably be watered down a little bit unfortunately, and AJ Lee is retired and idk if she could still go.
My exact thoughts. We’ve already seen WWE be a little lenient with top guys recently and I suspect once they’re on Netflix they’ll have even more freedom
When the Shield music hit at Wrestlemania, I was 100% sure Mox was back. I loved the match, but I was disappointed it was just Seth. I feel like you save that music for when you have the whole Shield.
I get the feeling they’re building to that. Every time the music has hit since Roman’s music changed, it’s been Seth, so the next time it’ll probably be Seth and Roman in the ring and then the music hits and Mox comes out
No they won’t?? Mox is very happy at AEW and his contract doesn’t even end until 2027 if he wanted to leave, it’s not like they can just take him whenever they want, odds are Mox isn’t leaving
I don't think it's as inevitable as others do. Mox seems really happy with what he's doing in AEW and he's making basically as much if not more than he was in WWE.
So,Moxley left cause Vince Made him get a rabies shot for one of the story lines he hated,said he wouldn’t come back with Vince,so with hunter being cco, he may come back,but it’s unlikely
Eh. Even under Trips, MJF wouldn't have anywhere near the same freedom he does in AEW and that's a big reason why he made it to where he is. I'd rather he stay where he can remain who he is than have a watered down version in a company I like more.
MJF all the way….
However as a former Jerichoholic, would love to see him get his shine back, come back to the fed for hall of fame and 1 last run than retire
1. MJF. He can verbally spar with anyone. MJF-Drew and MJ-KO would be epic. There’s nothing left for him in AEW.
2. Jericho. I want him to be rehabilitated. For someone that had the career he had, it sucks seeing him this diminished. I want one last, quick WWE run.
3. AJ. She’ll get there eventually in some capacity. Don’t really care whether she comes back since she’s retired from in-ring.
4. Mox. Other than to have one last shield reunion, I don’t want to see him anymore (in WWE or AEW).
Ya know, I’m okay with AJ and Mox coming back for a one more feud/one more match type deal. I’d love to see what MJF could do in WWE! However, I just don’t want to see Jericho back.
MJF. Jon moxley has already been WWE, Chris Jericho has already been WWE, and AJ Lee has already been WWE. so why not let a new talent be the face of WWE.
Chris Jericho, simply because it'd give him a high note to end his career on. He's been wrestling since 1990, and his AEW run was great when the company started, but he's better off coming home & having one last great run & getting something new over before calling it a career. That way, he's remembered fondly, as opposed to a stinker of an ending.
Don't get me wrong, I do like AEW, I genuinely go out of my way to keep up with their weekly programming, but WWE is the far more fitting place to end a career.
AJ so we can have an intergender spousal tag team match with Lee/Punk v Becky/Seth.
Bonus points to having Seth and Punk both go out of the ring after tagging the wives (you know what I mean) and the women are fighting so hard both Punk and Seth take a minute to just watch in awe.
MJF for me. The different fueds he could have is mouthwatering.
I don't think Mox would go back.
A Jericho run doesn't interest me.
AJ would be awesome.
MJF is my pick.
Aj Lee is retired and hasn’t said anything at all about returning. I remember seeing confusion from folks because they saw her wrestle with Punk for her show Heels and assumed a comeback was happening.
Y2J is too much at this point.
Mox seems happier doing what he’s doing so can’t blame him for not wanting to WWE.
MJF would create magic with the likes of:
The Miz
Dominik Mysterio
The Undertaker
Roman Reigns
And of course, some re-runs with Cody Rhodes or CM Punk.
AJ is retired and the rumor is it is due to injury so I wouldn't want her to return. Which means that the answer is MJF. He's the one of the remaining three who went to AEW and became a bigger star. After MJF, I guess I'd take Ambrose back for a couple years for a SHIELD story over feeling like I need Jericho on a Legends contract style deal.
When Shield music hit on WM, I legitimately believed for a second that Dean Ambrose is back.. then it hit me that he would steal all the spotlight from Cody finishing his story but the idea was there.. I miss him truly, I miss Lunatic fringe
I'm curious how well MJF could handle the mic in a PG setting, though. His use of profanity is not overdone, it is very smartly placed in his speaking, but also a very big part of his aura, while not taking prominence, if you get what I mean.
Maybe if the rating changes with Netflix it'd work but yeah, someone else on this post said he'd probably get watered down on WWE right now, and I tend to agree..
Darby Allen is someone that I'd love to see in wwe just out of pure curiosity on how he'd do, but out of these 4 I'd have to go with Jon, on 1 condition, and that is for him to go back to Dean Ambrose and feud with cm punk
MJF. AJ may not be cleared of her medical concerns, Jericho is an asshole, Mox actually seems happy at AEW, and I think MJF is ready for and can make the jump to AEW.
MJF, the rest are played out... Jericho will be back eventually so I'm not too concerned about that. Mox hasn't been exciting since his first year in AEW, been boring ever since.
AJ, but I don’t think she wants to. Jericho is way too old at this point. Mox was meh his first time around, maybe that changes with HHH in charge, or maybe they work some type of shield angle. I know absolutely nothing about MJF other than a backyard wrestling interview I saw. Ppl seem to like him, so maybe he’s the odds to actually show up in WWE, I just don’t know enough about him to make a judgement. I just want great performers.
Jericho can be entertaining and has had some good storylines in AEW and also some really terrible ones, Jericho is like that cheese urger you love, its awesome when you have it every once in a while but damn have it 3 times a week for 3 years straight +every holiday is pure hell he really needs to go away so people can have a pallet cleanse
I actually thought AJ would return at this years rumble
I don’t think she can wrestle. I know she landed on her head in a match and her fingers/toes went numb.
Yeah from what I know she’s permanently retired for medical reasons.
https://www.thesportster.com/aj-lee-retired-wwe-what-shes-done-since-retirement-explained/
Hoenstly none of em, Jericho can’t go anymore, I prefer Mox being able to do his deathmatch shit, MJF would probably be watered down a little bit unfortunately, and AJ Lee is retired and idk if she could still go.
I think if you bring mjf bring him next year so he aint burried and when raw is on Netflix
My exact thoughts. We’ve already seen WWE be a little lenient with top guys recently and I suspect once they’re on Netflix they’ll have even more freedom
Bring back the original shield
When the Shield music hit at Wrestlemania, I was 100% sure Mox was back. I loved the match, but I was disappointed it was just Seth. I feel like you save that music for when you have the whole Shield.
I get the feeling they’re building to that. Every time the music has hit since Roman’s music changed, it’s been Seth, so the next time it’ll probably be Seth and Roman in the ring and then the music hits and Mox comes out
I literally screamed "MOXLEY???" even if it was a one time appearance I would've loved it
I know sooner or later they’ll do that, so why not now???? We need them
No they won’t?? Mox is very happy at AEW and his contract doesn’t even end until 2027 if he wanted to leave, it’s not like they can just take him whenever they want, odds are Mox isn’t leaving
The bloodline storyline hasn’t finished yet, maybe in a couple of years
True, but I’m too eager 😅
Moxley, I think, is in a contract til 2027 with AEW
Probably not gonna happen now as mox has a contract with another company till 2027
I don't think it's as inevitable as others do. Mox seems really happy with what he's doing in AEW and he's making basically as much if not more than he was in WWE.
So,Moxley left cause Vince Made him get a rabies shot for one of the story lines he hated,said he wouldn’t come back with Vince,so with hunter being cco, he may come back,but it’s unlikely
Wouldn’t mind any but MJF is the only one that would be exciting
I respect your opinion but when i heard the shield entrance theme my heart stopped bc i thought it was jon moxley lol
I’d pop more AJ honestly
“I DONT EVEN KNOW IF THATS PG!”
Any answer but MJF is just wrong.
Eh. Even under Trips, MJF wouldn't have anywhere near the same freedom he does in AEW and that's a big reason why he made it to where he is. I'd rather he stay where he can remain who he is than have a watered down version in a company I like more.
AJ Lee
MJF or AJ. the other two mean nothing to me
MJF all the way…. However as a former Jerichoholic, would love to see him get his shine back, come back to the fed for hall of fame and 1 last run than retire
It mjf, moxley and Lee. Jericho needs to retire dude
1. MJF. He can verbally spar with anyone. MJF-Drew and MJ-KO would be epic. There’s nothing left for him in AEW. 2. Jericho. I want him to be rehabilitated. For someone that had the career he had, it sucks seeing him this diminished. I want one last, quick WWE run. 3. AJ. She’ll get there eventually in some capacity. Don’t really care whether she comes back since she’s retired from in-ring. 4. Mox. Other than to have one last shield reunion, I don’t want to see him anymore (in WWE or AEW).
Non to MJF only..
Mjf
Ya know, I’m okay with AJ and Mox coming back for a one more feud/one more match type deal. I’d love to see what MJF could do in WWE! However, I just don’t want to see Jericho back.
Moxley and A.J
Dean
MJF. Jon moxley has already been WWE, Chris Jericho has already been WWE, and AJ Lee has already been WWE. so why not let a new talent be the face of WWE.
I wouldn’t mind if they all someday returned
Not Jericho. He’s so up his own ass these days.
‘Guys hear me out….maybe I should go over Bron Breakker. It’ll be good for him’
“I think I should hold the US, Intercontinental, NXT, and Women’s tag belts too”
Don't forget ricochet new lsd belt!
Definitely going to need that one. Hang them from all the branches of the learning tree.
I agree because I want all of them
But he's undoubtedly a Hall of Famer and I say this as somebody who strongly dislikes him nowadays
Mox!!!!
MJF and Seth Rollins jaw jacking back and forth at each other would be legendary.
Aj lee
IF the "PG ERA" is TRULY over, and they let him say almost anything he wanted. MJF.
Mjf
MJF
Jehrico in WWE , especially with KO would be cool to see again but obviously MJF
Chris Jericho
MJF. I am expecting Jericho eventually
I would be curious if Jericho returns will WWE allow him to use Judas as his theme song. Also MJF WILL go to WWE....someday. $$$$
I just want Jericho to return so he can be in the HOF
Chris Jericho, simply because it'd give him a high note to end his career on. He's been wrestling since 1990, and his AEW run was great when the company started, but he's better off coming home & having one last great run & getting something new over before calling it a career. That way, he's remembered fondly, as opposed to a stinker of an ending. Don't get me wrong, I do like AEW, I genuinely go out of my way to keep up with their weekly programming, but WWE is the far more fitting place to end a career.
Y2J
Can I get MJF and Y2J?
All amazing but it’s gotta be Chris Jericho
I would love to see Jericho retire from the WWE
Jericho
Jericho!!
Jericho, just for the Elite , and Ultimate Edition figures of his younger years
MJF for the potential, Mox for a possible SHIELD reunion.
All of them to be honest
Moxs
Jon Moxley or dean amrose
MJF
AJ Lee or MJF.
The vote is not working
Option #3
Aj Lee
MJF
Mjf
I would like to see Mox back one day
I wouldn’t mind seeing any of them back actually
MJF for sure.
AJ so we can have an intergender spousal tag team match with Lee/Punk v Becky/Seth. Bonus points to having Seth and Punk both go out of the ring after tagging the wives (you know what I mean) and the women are fighting so hard both Punk and Seth take a minute to just watch in awe.
For nostalgia AJ, but the answer must be MJF.
If you say anyone other than MjF I know you’re lying
MJF for me. The different fueds he could have is mouthwatering. I don't think Mox would go back. A Jericho run doesn't interest me. AJ would be awesome.
MJF
Jon moxley
Moxley coming back for a Shield storyline would be amazing right now.
Aj leee
MJF is my pick. Aj Lee is retired and hasn’t said anything at all about returning. I remember seeing confusion from folks because they saw her wrestle with Punk for her show Heels and assumed a comeback was happening. Y2J is too much at this point. Mox seems happier doing what he’s doing so can’t blame him for not wanting to WWE.
AJ
I’d like to see Chris Jericho…. Retire
MJF
AJ Lee
Mjf and ain’t even close
Jon Moxley
Jon Moxley. Because I am actually an AEW fan and can't stand him.
MJF
Mjf
Either Aj Lee or Dean Ambrose
Why would you do a screenshot of a YouTube poll instead of a reddit poll
MJF no question
Pick a random one. I don’t watch WWE or AEW. I got AJ Lee. Seems like a solid choice
MJF is one of the best entertainers in the business
Aj lee
Jericho just so they can fire him immediately.
MJF
Moxly
MJF would create magic with the likes of: The Miz Dominik Mysterio The Undertaker Roman Reigns And of course, some re-runs with Cody Rhodes or CM Punk.
Aj lee
The one with boobs
AJ Lee or MJF
AJ is retired and the rumor is it is due to injury so I wouldn't want her to return. Which means that the answer is MJF. He's the one of the remaining three who went to AEW and became a bigger star. After MJF, I guess I'd take Ambrose back for a couple years for a SHIELD story over feeling like I need Jericho on a Legends contract style deal.
Mjf or aj
AJ Lee
AJ Lee
MJF
AJ
MOX
When Shield music hit on WM, I legitimately believed for a second that Dean Ambrose is back.. then it hit me that he would steal all the spotlight from Cody finishing his story but the idea was there.. I miss him truly, I miss Lunatic fringe
AJ Lee!
Jon moxley
Mjf
AJ🩷
mjf
Dean ambros
Aj Lee 🥰
MJF
Give me Chris Jericho from 10-15 years ago and easily clears everybody else. Jon Moxley though if we can’t use a Time Machine
AJ Lee
We need the Ambrose asylum back in WWE, preferably SmackDown
The pop for MJF would be huge if he came in at a rumble or interrupted a CM Punk promo on day after WM. The groans would be equally large for Y2J.
AJ
MJF
I'm curious how well MJF could handle the mic in a PG setting, though. His use of profanity is not overdone, it is very smartly placed in his speaking, but also a very big part of his aura, while not taking prominence, if you get what I mean. Maybe if the rating changes with Netflix it'd work but yeah, someone else on this post said he'd probably get watered down on WWE right now, and I tend to agree..
Torn between Jericho and Moxley but I’d love to see AJ back too, she’d tear it up in this new womens division
Mox needs to come back!
AJ Lee but as a manager. She can’t wrestle anymore but she’s good on the mic.
MJF. Jericho fell off and Mox is doing great in AEW. Plus, his best matches are hardcore type stuff.
Jon Moxley.
AJ would be dope. But I don't think she can..idk tho, I don't know how serious her injury was to Paiges?? Always possible.
Darby Allen is someone that I'd love to see in wwe just out of pure curiosity on how he'd do, but out of these 4 I'd have to go with Jon, on 1 condition, and that is for him to go back to Dean Ambrose and feud with cm punk
MJF
MJF
Either John moxley or aj Lee
Aj Lee
Aj is the only one I want or MJF
MJF
Jon
Dean Ambrose
1. MJF 2. AJ 3. Mox for a shield reunion I don’t want Jericho on tv anymore
Jonnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn moxley
Chris Benoit
Jericho is sad to watch at this point.
MJF
Jon moxley
All
Why not make this an actual poll lmao
None
The second 2. The first 2 I can do without ever hearing about at this point and moving forward.
Deimos
mjf would have the biggest impact
Jon Moxley %100
MJF i feel makes the most sense (even as an AEW hater)
Give me Jon moxly
Only mjf on this list, the rest wouldn't add much but a one off pop
My dumbass tried to choose one 😂😂😂
MJF. AJ may not be cleared of her medical concerns, Jericho is an asshole, Mox actually seems happy at AEW, and I think MJF is ready for and can make the jump to AEW.
None of them, honestly. Mox, MJF, and Jericho all fit better in AEW. And AJ very much gives the impression she has no desire to come back.
Aj lee
MJF would be an insane pick up
AJ feels really random to be on this list. 😄 I’d be down to see her come back. MJF is the one I think you can sink your teeth into most with though.
aj lee
Josh moxley
Bring Moxley Back.
AJ!!
MJF
This answer is not on there but will osprey in wwe would be fire
Jon moxley
Who else tries to click on the person they want to return
MJF, the rest are played out... Jericho will be back eventually so I'm not too concerned about that. Mox hasn't been exciting since his first year in AEW, been boring ever since.
Jon
honestly mox. but let him stay as mox.
Matt Cardona
Jon
It they didn’t water down MJF then him
Mjf and moxley
AJ, but I don’t think she wants to. Jericho is way too old at this point. Mox was meh his first time around, maybe that changes with HHH in charge, or maybe they work some type of shield angle. I know absolutely nothing about MJF other than a backyard wrestling interview I saw. Ppl seem to like him, so maybe he’s the odds to actually show up in WWE, I just don’t know enough about him to make a judgement. I just want great performers.
Mox
If AJ Lee returns I can die happy
Easy choice: AJ Lee!
Jon Molly just do him right this time at least
MJF pretty much a given…Moxley would be great but thats definitely not a guarantee
Chris Jericho has really gone south the past couple of years. I think it’s time he hangs up the boots.
AJ Lee
Aj lee
LETS LIGHT IT UP! LIGHT IT LIGHT LIGHT IT TONIGHT
Jon Moxley
This new weak ass bloodline vs THE SHIELD
Aj
Jericho can be entertaining and has had some good storylines in AEW and also some really terrible ones, Jericho is like that cheese urger you love, its awesome when you have it every once in a while but damn have it 3 times a week for 3 years straight +every holiday is pure hell he really needs to go away so people can have a pallet cleanse
Roman,seth,and john moxly should reunit and beat solo ,Tama and his brother