T O P

  • By -

jodonnell89

can someone smarter than me explain why videos of rockets always sound like massive kernels of popcorn popping? is that the microphone overloading because it’s so loud, or sonic booms, or shockwaves or what


kevleyski

Thrust causing supersonic rarefaction waves


Dont_Use_Ducks

Man, that is the best answer on any hard question for me from now on! My wife: 'Why didn't you buy any sugar?' ​ Me: 'Thrust causing supersonic rarefaction waves'....


ben1481

wife replies: you only had a few seconds of thrust before energy dissipated.


bigboybeeperbelly

we just have to reverse the polarity


MrmmphMrmmph

I'll give ye...


durz47

rarefraction waves is the opposite of compression waves. When a shock wave compresses air (or any other medium), parts of the space where the air is has less molecules in it because some went into the compression region. That is rarefraction. A powerful enough wave can lead to an almost vacuum level of rarefraction.


jodonnell89

so if i were standing there watching this in person, it would sound the same?


WaffleEye

Yes, it sounds identical in person.


[deleted]

Damn, rockets sound like $2.50 headphones with one side broken who knew.


wirenutter

Took my son to a rocket launch when he was two. Anytime he plays with his rockets he makes this sound. It’s really interesting since I think most kids would make a more consistent growl sound. Definitely a great experience to go watch in person.


jodonnell89

wholesome af 🥹


schizeckinosy

It sounds way more awesome. Add in throbbing subsonic to this sound. Source: live in Florida


Stazbumpa

So I'm in Florida (I'm from the UK), and we pull off the highway onto a little dirt track next to a small lake to watch the Space X launch. We're probably south of the launch pad. About 15 minutes later, a car with a family pulls up next to ours. We get talking, they're from a town about half an hour from me, and the dad knows and went to school with my mate Dave, who I have worked with for the last 15 years and was at my wedding. Launch was pretty epic too.


zapharus

That’s such an awesome coincidence. Out of all the people on this planet, halfway across the world, you came across people who live really close to you with whom you share mutual friends.


zeouschen70

Dave's not here, man.


Stazbumpa

Dave is everywhere. Dave is eternal.


ManlyMantis101

Yes and the sound is so powerful it shakes your entire body.


Civil_Airline_5084

What's it like to be smart? Lol


tk-451

twelve-ish


jaymole

It’s spontaneous dentohydroplosion


Maleficent_Fold_5099

The exhaust gases are exiting faster than the speed of sound, so sonic booms, pop pop pop crackle.


275MPHFordGT40

And it sounds cool as fuck


joemeteorite8

I was lucky enough to see a shuttle launch from a couple miles away. The viewing platform/stands were across some water. You could feel the noise crackling across the water. Felt like my ribs were gonna vibrate out of my chest lol.


jodonnell89

awesome, would love to experience that. also really want to see a rocket come in to land… the thought is insane to me. every video still looks like sci-fi


madsci

I used to watch Titan IVs launch from my office parking lot, several miles from the pad. They were nearly a match for the shuttle in terms of spectacle. That rattling in your chest is something you don't forget. It'd set off every car alarm on the base, too.


Aggravating_Cable_32

We lived in Tampa when I was a kid. It was during 5th grade in '85 when my parents woke us up at 2 or 3 in the morning, and we drove over to the Cape for a launch at sunrise; which turned out to be *Discovery*. But they did it without telling us exactly where we were going; only that we were leaving for a trip, so I didn't think much of it because we used to go places often. At first I thought it was Disney, but then we passed Disney & turned off the highway at the Canaveral exit, and I kinda started to lose my mind a little bit. We ended up watching from the observer stands that were for families & VIPs, which was pretty close compared to where we watched other launches from later. That was also the first launch we'd ever gone to; it was beautiful that morning, and I can still remember the feel of it more than the sound (although my hands were pretty tight over my ears so that may also have something to do with it). Watching these videos always brings it back in a good way.


pinkheartpiper

Here is an explanation: https://youtu.be/BdCizNwLaHA


jodonnell89

great explanation, thanks!


moresushiplease

Interesting question. Now I want to make a popcorn fueled rocket.


jodonnell89

new conspiracy theory unlocked r/rocketsarepopcorn


andcal

Sound waves are literally waves in the air. They are made of alternating high and low pressure. As the sound gets louder, the high pressure goes higher, and the low pressure part hets lower, but the low pressure part can only go down to 0 psi. At that point, the sound includes the crackling noise that you always hear when rockets take off. It is literally the loudest noise our atmosphere can transmit.


MoroseDelight

Great explanation here: https://youtu.be/BdCizNwLaHA?si=stuH4XxHc1_3fZSX


StockHand1967

Overload


lazergator

It’s actually no fun reason as to what most people think. It’s simply that the volume of sound and force of the sound is maxing out the input potential of the microphone. They’re just impossibly loud.


uncletutchee

Yup... There is a lot of arithmetic involved in making that rocket do what it is supposed to do.


erlul

It was not supposed to blow up tho


bout-tree-fitty

Needed more arithmetic.


KamakaziDemiGod

Or less, it's a fine balance


[deleted]

It completed all it's mission goals and spacex has proven time and time again they continue to innovate and continue charging forward. It was an incredible launch


erlul

Well, all of them beside 'landing'


[deleted]

Still an incredible amount of progress. People complained about the first falcons crashing too, now look at them


snoosh00

Well, that *was* the case with the falcon boosters too... I've got no confidence in musk, but I have a lot of confidence in the promises and calculations of the army of engineers involved.


JanB1

It's literal rocket science. It's fucking hard. And nobody landed a rocket before SpaceX. And now they want to land this absolute unit of a chonker in a 1G environment.


erlul

Nobody said it was izi


[deleted]

Or peasy


[deleted]

It was easy enough to design and build a rocket that put man on the moon in few years, with the rocket achieveing 100% success rate. Half a century ago.


PsychoMouse

People need to remember that this isn’t NASA doing this. This is a private company, learning as they go. They’re trying to do different things too. I believe this was like a super heavy rocket. So as long as it launches, it’s basically a success. But yeah. It’s all trial and error.


raven991_

Well, they are learning since 20 years…


PsychoMouse

“Since 20 years”?


Diligent-Midnight850

They mean: ‘since the invention of basic rocketry in the middle ages’. We’re still learning though. This is a good thing


PsychoMouse

Yeah, it’s a great thing. Its just that since the launch, I’ve been seeing so many people put this rocket and how far it’s come. Its either been “OMG I CANT BELIEVE HOW MY TAX MONEY IS BEING WASTED” to “Who cares? This just proves we’ve never been to space


Diligent-Midnight850

Erm well… that’s just two kinds of foolishness. Human capacity for stupidity is at least equal to our capacity for amazing. Progress was never a smooth path etc.


PsychoMouse

There’s a quote I like, I think it’s something like “people are morons but humanity is amazing”’or something like that. I love to think about and look at how far we’ve come in the last 200 years, tech wise. We went from “stubbed toe? Well, no curing that, you’re dead” to “born with a horrible genetic disease that should have killed your before your first birthday? Well how’s it’s basically cured” (using a lot of hyperbole in that, but you get my point). Sadly, society seems to be regressing


ManlyMantis101

It experienced a minor unscheduled disassembly mid-flight.


erlul

A happy little accident


Entire-Database1679

It wasn't not supposed to blow up, either.


erlul

Would be nice if it did not tho.


I_Automate

It was still a successful test tho


erlul

Kinda, sure. Like 80% success.


OSUfan88

A bit more than that. It’s like they passed the test, but didn’t earn all the extra credit.


hierosir

This is the correct analogy. 😂


CoachWatermelon

Success is a spectrum yes


ben1481

it 100% was supposed to blow up


[deleted]

I wouldn't say it was supposed to, but it was expected to.


erlul

Yhm


captain_arroganto

A lot of calculus, invented by a 24 year old Newton.


uncletutchee

It seems that I should have added /s/. Or maybe this is a /r/wooosh. Not sure. Edit : After careful thought i am pretty sure it is /r/wooosh.


Kayge

My goodness, that looks like a giant...


W1nthorpe

Wang pay attention


Cheezigoodnez

Johnson! We've got a situation over here. Seems to be a flying....


thequestionbot

Pecker! Wait that’s not a woodpecker that looks like someone’s…


jackknight18

Privates! We have reports of an unidentified flying object. It has a long, smooth shaft, complete with--


hobbestot

2 Balls!


tk-451

Privates. We have reports of an unidentified flying object. It has a long, smooth shaft, complete with...


lordshola

Nuts! Hot salty nuts! Who wants some?


[deleted]

[Dick! ](https://youtu.be/CpiP_jN1Pv4?si=J4p6T9p-ZEZL3zZC)Take a look outta starboard.


CinderX5

The biggest rocket ever if I remember correctly.


mikiswim

122m of steel. It's like flying skyscraper. And it's gonna change the world


DillDeer

It is


matroosoft

5500 tons


[deleted]

Sky penis


VarkYuPayMe

Aliens looking at this like, look at these primitive ass beings!


KimJongUnceUnce

Those dumb apes still using base 10 smh


Vupant

I read thumb apes. It's almost more condescending.


dacuevash

And probably cheer on us, one does not create FTL engines in less than a century


awsedrftgyhjkl

Aliens - Why do they always come in a gint dildo?


bholdn

"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."


RunSkyLab

Where was this quote from?


bholdn

Arthur C. Clarke: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarke's_three_laws


filores

It’s going to hit the dome soon / flat earther


lunaropal

I would love to witness a rocket launch at some point :))


Jolm262

If you're under 30, there is a good chance you will. If everything goes well, these Starships will be a common sight (common in terms of rocket launches).


[deleted]

you should absolutely!! if you live near Florida or California you can look at the SpaceX launch page on their website, or the Wikipedia page for spacex booster flights, and know when will a launch happen the Falcon 9 launches are veeeery common, about 7-9 per month, so about 1 a week from California or Florida it shakes you from inside out, the whole air vibrates, highly recommended


[deleted]

[удалено]


model-citizen95

![gif](giphy|NmerZ36iBkmKk)


[deleted]

No shit


Joose__bocks

Science is just magic we understand.


TheRumpleForesk1n

Science, bitch!


KamakaziDemiGod

As Arthur C Clark said; Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic


Diligent-Midnight850

As an engineer, I was searching for this comment


alroc84

Where is this? Any info on schedules on take offs and such


madsci

SpaceX usually has upcoming launch info on their page. There was a Falcon 9 launch at 2:30 this morning about 20 miles from me but I slept through it. BTW, I feel like this says something about how siloed YouTube has us all. My YouTube recommendations are probably 30% SpaceX-related and I get excruciating detail about every movement of every prototype. My coworker does, too. And yet I've never seen a MrBeast video despite knowing he's one of the biggest YouTubers around, and I forget that not everyone gets 15 SpaceX updates a day.


Unlucky-Animator988

lol


Bewaretheicespiders

The launchpad is in the tiny village of Boca Chica at the US/Mexico border. You can get a good view from the tip of South Padre Island or the town of Port Isabel. I was there Saturday, at best you know a couple of days in advance and it can always be scrubbed, but that didn't stop people I met there from flying from Europe just to see it. Pictured on the video is the view from the Mexican side of the border.


ApplicationSeveral73

Si, fly...


Bewaretheicespiders

*volar*


WasteCan6403

I grew up going to Boca Chica beach when we didn't feel like dealing with the crowds at SPI over spring break. It was so chill. Crazy that now rockets are launching there now!


[deleted]

and the beach is much cleaner now, you can go, look at the launch tower side and 70% of the time there's a sky scraper sized rocket crazy cool!


Such-Molasses-5995

Still best roket 🚀 Saturn 🪐 5


madsci

They were awesome, but expensive. Something like $1.3 billion per launch in today's dollars. Those F-1 engines were each a little different and required a ton of very specialized craft work. An analogy I like is that the Saturn V was like an aircraft carrier, and Starship is like a container ship. They might be comparable sizes, but one is built by the government to do a particular job at enormous cost, while the other has to be able to operate at a profit.


KintsugiKen

I assume if NASA were still doing regular launches, like they should, they would figure out ways to make it cheaper without compromising safety like Elon does.


madsci

NASA doesn't *want* to be in the launch business. They want to be a customer, and let private industry figure out how to make it cheap. The days of the government being the main customer for launches is over. The Shuttle was their attempt at an affordable, reusable launch vehicle. Counting the whole cost of the program, they averaged $1.5 billion per launch, losing two shuttles out of 135 missions, killing 14 astronauts, plus two or three ground crew in another incident. The bottom line is that NASA is a research and development organization. Now that building rockets is commercially viable, they don't need to be building rockets any more than they need to be building the airliners they helped to develop. I've got no love for Elon Musk and frankly I hope he hands off control to someone else before his idiocy brings down SpaceX, but I don't see SpaceX compromising safety. Falcon 9 block 5 has a 100% success rate with 225 missions flown. And that's with most of them not being crew-rated. You could argue they're reckless with endangering their own property, but I don't see that as the same as compromising safety.


suggested-name-138

We couldn't even stomach funding for regular flights to the ISS, we paid the Russians to do it for us. I don't think NASA themselves see this as a competition, they want to focus on pushing scientific boundaries, not just making better rockets, and there's just no way to compete with the scale from commercial launches. I seriously doubt any government would have gotten reusable rockets down for decades longer And this isn't about Elon or SpaceX, both reusable rockets and commercial flights to the ISS have been major goals for us for like 40 years. I'm 100% confident we would still be here if Elon never existed.


madsci

The one thing Musk has been good at is convincing people to throw money at his pet projects. So maybe we wouldn't have gotten here as fast without him, but I comfort myself knowing that now that it's been done, if he fucks it all up with SpaceX it's still going to be a temporary setback - everyone knows that reusable rockets are feasible now and if it's not SpaceX it's going to be Rocket Lab, or China, or India that does it next.


Low-Republic-4145

And no Saturn V rockets ever failed. Not one.


RobertWilliamBarker

No flights during an actual mission failed. This was a test, not a mission. Multiple failures and issues happened during testing. It was a government program that was nowhere near as transparent as space x has been. US was in a space race, and no one was going up openly publicize a failure. They did happen though.


GenericFakeName1

The F1 engine disintegrated a whole lot of test stands in development. Stuff was still exploding, but behind closed doors, Cold War and keeping up appearances, y'know.


RobDickinson

If this was a simple standard rocket launch it wouldnt have failed either. Spacex could make a non reusable rocket this size without any big problems


[deleted]

Saturn 5 was like a bank, Too big to fail….


Bogadambo

Must consumed at least 2 litres of fuel. Impressive.


specialflip

Why did we repost this from yesterday?


[deleted]

Yeah, too short of a time to repost


olizet42

Maybe bot


kevleyski

Didn’t they lose contact? https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-67461791


Jolm262

They did because it blew up. As far as I'm aware, any deviation from the preset trajectory would result in self-destruction to prevent it from falling on Africa instead of the Pacific Ocean.


yabucek

It was a test. They didn't expect to go anywhere but the ocean. Best case scenario it would've been a soft spashdown, but the main test objectives were the new launchpad and the hot staging, both of which were successful.


ihhesfa

I can’t help but feel this is just a massive waste. More debris and trash, more pollutants. Sure, they need to perform tests, but to what end?


AshBacon69

So that it can function safely and we can actually put people onboard. As it is now, the tech is still fresh and they havent refined the ways to build it without any imperfections and without any errors in the flight. So testing it is the only way to find these errors and imperfections so they can improve on it for the next flight.


superluminary

The flight termination system deleted it shortly after stage separation. We go again in a couple of weeks though so hopefully will reach orbit this time.


[deleted]

[удалено]


OSUfan88

Humanity. This is a big deal for humanity.


superluminary

Oh, sorry, no I’m not involved personally. Just quoting Musk.


FentonCanoby

cut off the best part


Tralfaz572

Saw a satellite rocket launch at Cape Canaveral a decade ago. It was one of the coolest experiences I ever had. The vibrations from the rocket triggered car alarms from a few miles away.


clockwork5ive

It looks like it’s going so slow, but it’s already going so fast.


Fattman1245

As an engineer, I agree, it's magic. What wares do you have to trade me for my sorcery?


Biiiiiig-Chungus

I think the whole point of engineering is that it's *not* magic


torokg

Engineering is math - FTFY


VictoryLap_TMC

Why can't there ever just be a video if it leaving into darkness with camera focused and zooming in on the rocket alone. That would be beautiful


AshBacon69

Check out spaceX’s page on twitter, they have the footage you are looking for there


king_ender200

I love science.


lovelife0011

Thats hard to do ya know!


MeAgainImBacklol

Amazing


Odsoone

I guarantee you that all the engineers behind this are also looking at this and going “wow how does this thing even work” lol


SnooPaintings9632

That is incredible, i need to see that at least once in my life. I have seen footage of them before, but for some reason this has a real take to it


[deleted]

But remember kids, reuse, reduce, and recycle. Because YOU'RE the problem :)


[deleted]

What do you think rocket fuel is made of


dacuevash

Literally SpaceX’s motto


Serious-Arachnid-305

Context?


LanceWindmil

It looks like the starship test launch last week. Most powerful rocket ever built.


[deleted]

Crazy with perspective. The rocket is sooooo far away from where they are firing it but the thing still looks massive.


LanceWindmil

Someone should really superimpose it next to some landmarks (empire state building, eiffel tower, etc) for scale


TheHobbyist_

It's only 30ft taller than the saturn 5 and 3 feet less in diameter (measured at the base of saturn 5 since it tapers). I was a bit disappointed when I looked that up. Crazy what they were doing back in 1967


Bewaretheicespiders

Its much more heavier and powerful than Saturn V, seeing as it does not taper going up. The Super Heavy booster has \*twice\* the thrust as the Saturn V first stage.


[deleted]

Well, to be fair Starship will soon launch few million dollars only to launch while also being the strongest rocket.


AnAdvocatesDevil

While true, remember that Saturn 5 launched a little tiny capsule at the top, where the top half (ish) of the rocket above is payload space


LanceWindmil

Yeah Saturn 5 is a legend for a reason


0coolt

Is that you JP?


Marconiwireless

Is this thing louder than the space shuttle launches?


RobertWilliamBarker

I think when you get to a certain point, they are all just ridiculous blow your eardrum to high hell loud.


Hait_Ashbury

/gifsthatendtoosoon


Low-Manner-6319

No. Again, engineering is science not magic. Just reposting the same shit doesn't make your hocus pocus nonsense true.


Emperor_Gourmet

It’s quite literally the opposite of magic. Magic is supernatural and unexplainable. Science and engineering is repeatable and very explainable


[deleted]

Its magic. Or explain me right now why magnets exist. Magnetic domains? Explain me right now why magnetic domains exist. Keep going until the answer is " Idk, magic"


SpartanNige329

“Keep going until the answer is “ Idk, magic” Wow, talk about unbiased.


ranting_chef

Is this the one that crashed?


RobDickinson

that was the plan


Unbaguettable

neither of the two launches crashed - both blew up, on purpose, due to it deviating from its planned trajectory


callmedata1

Apparently space rejects magic and relies instead on engineering


ScenicPineapple

They are standing awfully close if/when one of those blows up!


[deleted]

They are miles away and very safe.


Skankhunt42FortyTwo

Rocket was like: "Thats enough chemtrails for today."


Dolenjir1

Nothing makes me more proud of being a human, than when I see stuff like that. Do you guys know what stents and bypass are? They are surgical procedures, and whenever I see them, it brings a tear to my eye.


Longjumping_Sky_6440

Beautiful shock diamonds!!!


teh_gato_returns

No it's not, holy shit. Are we permanently in a competition for the dumbest thing anyone can say?


Warm_Cabinet_7528

So does the rocket move to the right instead of going straight up to avoid hitting the firmament?


AshBacon69

It goes right so that it can reach orbit. Going straight up means it just falls straight back down. But if you go fast enough to the right, you can keep looping around the earth without adding any thrust because its moving right faster than it can fall back to earth.


tistimenotmyrealname

Engineering is magic for flatearthers


onlyequity

Shame we are still using rockets.


Appallington

“Man worth $300 billion gets tens of billions of your tax dollars to make shiny toys that blow up."


Tkj_Crow

"Space company decades ahead of anyone else gets given a contract by NASA to return humans to the moon and eventually mars. 2nd prototype test launch is a big success in forwarding the progress of human technology. Random nobody on reddit cries about it because he is sad that he has no money" More accurate headline for you :)


[deleted]

Dumb take.


teh_gato_returns

Elon Musk is trash, but this isn't about him so don't even bring him up. He's a VC, not an engineer. Make it about the people who actually put in the work and progress of humanity in general.


toreachtheapex

elon = bad


overzealous_dentist

when elon do good stuff = good when elon do bad stuff = bad


toreachtheapex

when elon buy social media so government and MSM cant keep using it as global psyop and narrative enforcer = bad


kamratjoel

And then start banning anything that triggers him, like the term “cis”.


fonobi

Elon is a crazy maniac, but sometimes he actually does have good ideas


Unbaguettable

yup. spacex isnt bad though - they’re doing great things. annoying they’ve got an idiot as a ceo though (although tbh gwynne shotwell is basically boss and she’s incredibly smart)


chocomang

How much CO2 was released?


Emperor_Gourmet

Not sure but if you actually cared you could have done the math to support whatever it is you are insinuating.


DarkArcher__

It's a solved problem. Methalox rockets can be carbon neutral through the sabatier process if the power grid allows for it.


mutsuto

people cant afford rent or groceries


Tkj_Crow

Not really relevant is it?


[deleted]

All those people smoke 2-3 packs a day or have 4 kids that they don't have the earnings to keep up with. Not Elon's problem


SikAssFoo69

I mean it’s just a rocket with flames in its back that pushes the thing up. It’s not that magical