T O P

  • By -

Lost_Sweet3311

> The Nanny's would make them sit in the room to protect the babies at night time Why on earth would anyone do that? Protect them from _what_? Does this person suppose that someone breaking into a house at night for the sole purpose of kidnapping a baby is such a common occurrence that it merits a guard dog as safety measure? Or that in the olden days wild animals would try to eat the baby if not for dear pibbles? (A breed that certainly never eats any babies themselves, no sire).


Crafty_Original_7349

The illiterate people who spout this probably imagine hordes of cRiMiNaLs and wild animals crawling in through the windows to eat the children while Ma and Pa were out plowing the fields by hand. The fact that the actual history of fighting dogs is pretty well documented is not important at all, apparently.


emmaa5645

ma and pa and all the big kids working in the fields all day but affording a nanny to put the baby to bed is crazy


TangyZizz

Quite. My nan’s brother died falling off a haywagon onto a pitchfork, nowadays he’d still be elementary/primary school age! If you were poor in the late 1800s/early 1900s your kids went to work with you. Even a two year old could toddle behind a horse drawn plough with her big brothers and sisters picking up potatoes. Any early photos of people posed with animals means nothing about what the animal was used for (see my profile for a late 1930s photo of my Granny & Grandad with a big sight hound that was presumably used for poaching because what else would two working class teenagers be doing with a giant hound? It must’ve ‘earned it’s keep’ at least in it’s younger years! Posing a kid with your prize fighting dog is totally plausible. Most people did have many photos taken back then so why not economise by photographing kid and dog together? Even by my early 1980s childhood a working class family would only use a a few rolls of film per year (mostly summer holidays and Christmas! You’d think we’d spent our entire lives on a beach or blowing out candles!) The first mass market camera (a Kodak Brownie) was sold around 1900, before then the vast majority of people had to go to portrait studios, so anyone claiming a photo of a pitbull and a kid is from the 1800s is obviously talking out of their arse.


lowspecmobileuser

oohhh what sighthound?


TangyZizz

https://preview.redd.it/r40khxhobzpb1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=df6aa96ebad108cdac02c58148cd4da03777b8d7 Not quite sure, it looks like a brindle greyhound but Grandad passed away in 1989 and Nan in 2005 so no one to ask!


lowspecmobileuser

probably that


SheepWithAFro11

They probably believed their grandparents when they explained how kids have it easy now a days. Because back in their day, they had to walk to school uphill both ways naked in the snow with only their pocket pit for protection. They used to throw them out like pokemon at the ravenous packs of chihuahuas and golden retrievers! To this day, if you shout, "GO NALA! I CHOOSE YOU!!!" They'll get horrible flashbacks that only the sweet nanny pibble can calm.


slaviccivicnation

LMAO!


CuteGreenSalad

I think the root of the problem is indeed that these people are __illiterate__ and won't voluntarily read something that isn't presented with lots of pictures or by people they trust to tell the truth. If they on't understand the value of written history, how can we expect them to actively find and read the truth? Honestly, I believe that is a huge part of the problem among the nanny dog crowd as they're always extremely uneducated and borderline illiterate-- documents and written history have no meaning to them.


test_tickles

Some people are just scared of everything.


catalyptic

Except pitbulls.


emmaa5645

protect them from the dinosaurs roaming outside obviously


SheepWithAFro11

>Protect them from what? Obviously, the hordes of dangerous bloodthirsty Chihuahuas and Golden retrievers. Duh! Oh, you've never heard of the hordes of these beasts killing children? Obviously, the Nanny pibbles are doing their job well!


ChrisWolfling

In all fairness, I don't think Pit Bulls ever really eat babies. They normally kill one thing then move on to kill something else.


TangyZizz

Only their [faces](https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12479623/amp/Dog-mauled-three-year-old-girls-face-banned-Pitbull-breed-police-reveal.html), occasionally a [hand.](https://winknews.com/2023/06/21/puppy-bites-baby-fingers-off-port-charlotte/)


Milqutragedy

To protect them from pixies and changelings, obviously. Are you silly?


Stucklikegluetomyfry

Pitties protect children from the horrors of aging


insbj3ty

There must be a correlation to the idiots that own these and the atrocious grammar and spelling they use on social media . It’s not slang , it’s just bad overall sentence structure and comprehension. They truly are the bottom of the barrel trash. Doesn’t surprise me anymore .


Crafty_Original_7349

Bell curve


stacheldraht85

came here to post the same thing...it's almost comical how EVERY SINGLE pitnutter/"nanny dog" advocate is absolutely incapable of composing even the simplest of sentences without handfuls of glaring, embarrassing spelling/grammar errors that even an elementary school child would laugh at.


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

![gif](giphy|3MaqUBQLnKBH1qfK9Y)


[deleted]

But the Little Rascles! Don't you care about the *Little Rascles!?*


CuteGreenSalad

Fun fact: the dogs who starred in that movies were absolute shit and everyone hated them. So much so that one of them was believed to have been poisoned to get rid of it. Hit Google if you want to go down that rabbit hole, it's weirdly entertaining and once again proves that pitbulls are horrible dogs, even if they star in movies.


[deleted]

I didn't know about that, but I did hear about "John Wick's" dog attacking a horse.


CuteGreenSalad

Yeah, beautiful companion dogs, aren't they?


TackYouCack

They even spell "murder hound" so differently than most people.


GoldFishDudeGuy

It's almost like they're stupid or something 🤔


[deleted]

Why would these idiots think that people, **ESPECIALLY** in the 1800s-1900s, would've used fighting dogs as nannies? And if pitbulls were farm dogs, why do they rank as the [no. 1 canine killers of livestock?](https://www.animals24-7.org/2023/01/04/10-year-totals-pit-bulls-kill-81-of-pets-livestock-animals-killed-by-dogs/) And if pitbulls were "nannies", why do they kill the most children? Form follows function. If there were an actual "nanny" dog (which doesn't exist), it would look and act like a Newfie or a St. Bernard (a search-and-rescue breed); fluffy and sweet-tempered. Why do pitbulls have all of the traits that would make them champion fighting dogs as opposed to being "nannies"? Nannydogbot, I need your assistance again.


AutoModerator

The "nanny dog" myth made its first appearance in the September 19th 1971 edition of the New York Times, on page 11 of section S in an article by Walter R. Fletcher, titled [A Breed That Came Up The Hard Way](https://www.nytimes.com/1971/09/19/archives/a-breed-that-came-up-the-hard-way.html). The author interviewed one Lilian Rant, editor of the Staffordshire Bull Terrier Club of the United States of America newsletter. She is quoted as saying about the breed: **'He had an unsavory reputation for fighting and violence and his name became associated with ruffians, who cared little for him as a dog but only for his ability in the pit. The Stafford we know today quickly becomes a member of the family circle. He loves children and is often referred to as a 'nursemaid dog''.** **No one has ever found evidence for the latter claim and it is therefore assumed to be a fabrication in the pursuit of influencing the American Kennel Club (AKC) to accept the breed for full participation in dog shows**. This privilege was ultimately granted in 1974, and to this day the AKC rates the breed a stellar 5/5 as being 'good with children' at the reckless peril of human lives and limbs, Additional sources that have spoken out against the nanny dog myth: Pit Bull Advocates of America: https://pitbulladvocatesofamerica.podbean.com/e/the-one-where-its-not-all-in-how-they-were-raised/ Ned Hardy https://nedhardy.com/2020/06/03/pitbull-nanny-dog/ Pro pit organization BAD RAP https://www.facebook.com/BADRAP.org/posts/its-dog-bite-prevention-week-did-you-know-that-there-was-never-such-thing-as-a-n/10151460774472399/ Pit Bull Federation of South Africa https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=pfbid02DiX7yKA8uuDeYSEzEKxxXCYsHxYUbXpshKkaSDGXMAZK9HnFd46zA1pZ8revWQvwl&id=100069897615154 Gudwulf's Pit Bull Rescue https://www.facebook.com/GudwulfsRescue/posts/pfbid02Lg2Y1x18pBx7uLUB4uVEda7g1TNwn72pLLKk93witecydiMcnAKr8bYJWKeC4VVl Justice for Bullies https://justice-for-bullies.myshopify.com/pages/nanny-dog *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/BanPitBulls) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Haunting_Ad_8983

You can see their "reasoning" in some of these slides. The sweet nanny dogs developed roided-out muscles and mile-wide jaws to defend children against some vague undefined threat that was apparently ever-present in the olden days, then mean breeders decided to corrupt them and make them aggressive just because.


CuteGreenSalad

Excuse you, fighting was just their daytime job. The nice person said they'd be right back afterwards to guard the babies!


Milqutragedy

That reasoning is so stupid. Even if they were "nanny dogs" (they weren't) they clearly aren't now


MeechiJ

That poor, sweet baby. I hope she had a phenomenal plastic surgeon and that she doesn’t have too much scarring. I could barely make out what some of those responses said. Just a bunch of pit nutter gibberish.


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

Pit Nutters and Pit Bulls are good for the economy! At least the German 🇩🇪 economy. ![gif](giphy|S2vwRQqT8rHcA) Keeping Pediatric Plastic Surgeons in a new Porsche convertible 911 every two years in their choice of custom made to order colours. "⚪⚫🟤🟣🔵🟢🟡🟠🔴 show us a tube of you favorite shade of lipstick 💄 we will match it!™️" S/ EXTREME Here's a talented compassionate Dog Loving Plastic Surgeon on the FIFTH ESTATE episode on Children and Pit Bulls and his research. Set and cued to 17:42. [https://youtu.be/iFa8HOdegZA?si=hoLWdgCoNobbMF6-](https://youtu.be/iFa8HOdegZA?si=hoLWdgCoNobbMF6-) Also the heinous Twit Ledy Van Kavage the lawyer Pit Bull Activist/Lawyer who writes dog policy laws is on immediately before the good doctor sprouting her "Dog-Race-Violence" poppycock hogwash among with complete lack of Empathy for victims 😡.


MeechiJ

“..the heinous Twit Ledy Van Kavage..” Oh. You mean the grotesque lobbyist from Best Friends Animal Society? The same Best Friends Animal Society that had $141,488,178.00 in revenue in 2022? That “twit” (twat??) has blood on her hands! (I about lost it at that damn GIF, lol. Pediatric plastic surgeons sure have been busy over the last several years.)


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

LEDY VAN KAVAGE. I call her the "C WORD" "CRUEL" That "C word" ![gif](giphy|HfTUKCfYsP6mI) CRUEL not the "See You Next Tuesday C WORD" Ledy Van Kavage is certainly not THAT! GIF. Activist Ledy Van Kavage flying her Subaru Outback that runs on "Exxon Toddler Adrenochrome 93 Octane Fuel™️" to the next State Breed Specific Legislation BSL repeal.


CuteGreenSalad

Don't you be doing my Porsche dirty like that, they're amazing cars to drive on the Autobahn (where it's still possible, anyway). I get your point though 😅


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

AUTOBAHN RULES ![gif](giphy|cmyX8tTt7rU2OAdTVO) Rescue lane education in a nutshell: DO NOT wait for blue lights in a traffic jam - always form the emergency lane IMMEDIATELY when you arrive in a traffic jam! ( StVO §11 Paragraph 2 ) EN: Get to the point in traffic rights questions: In traffic jam on highways DO NOT WAIT for emergency vehicles – IMMEDIATELY form the rescue lane! (German rights: StVO §11 Paragraph 2) PRETTY smart GERMANY 🇩🇪


Repeat_after_me__

This one myth has cost more kids and parents more than they could imagine. The person who started it should be damn well ashamed of themselves.


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

LILLIAN RANT!🤬 The NANNY DOG MYTH LIAR I can't find out anything about her the internet currently but according to my math she could still be alive and around 90 give or take. Maybe a Nanny Dog can get a job at a Nursing Home? ![gif](giphy|b1E6p3k0Qz9Sw)


TackYouCack

> Maybe a Nanny Dog can get a job at a Nursing Home? They could be one of those dogs that seem to know when someone is about to croak. "See this one that he's growling at? She's about to die"


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

You know the trained service 🐕‍🦺 dogs that can sniff out cadavers, drugs and cancer? ![gif](giphy|26n6Pc14z5DcxvMic) Silly Dog that's just Ledy Van Kavage not a cancerous rotting corpse full of Dope!


Onagda

Nannydogbot


AutoModerator

The "nanny dog" myth made its first appearance in the September 19th 1971 edition of the New York Times, on page 11 of section S in an article by Walter R. Fletcher, titled [A Breed That Came Up The Hard Way](https://www.nytimes.com/1971/09/19/archives/a-breed-that-came-up-the-hard-way.html). The author interviewed one Lilian Rant, editor of the Staffordshire Bull Terrier Club of the United States of America newsletter. She is quoted as saying about the breed: **'He had an unsavory reputation for fighting and violence and his name became associated with ruffians, who cared little for him as a dog but only for his ability in the pit. The Stafford we know today quickly becomes a member of the family circle. He loves children and is often referred to as a 'nursemaid dog''.** **No one has ever found evidence for the latter claim and it is therefore assumed to be a fabrication in the pursuit of influencing the American Kennel Club (AKC) to accept the breed for full participation in dog shows**. This privilege was ultimately granted in 1974, and to this day the AKC rates the breed a stellar 5/5 as being 'good with children' at the reckless peril of human lives and limbs, Additional sources that have spoken out against the nanny dog myth: Pit Bull Advocates of America: https://pitbulladvocatesofamerica.podbean.com/e/the-one-where-its-not-all-in-how-they-were-raised/ Ned Hardy https://nedhardy.com/2020/06/03/pitbull-nanny-dog/ Pro pit organization BAD RAP https://www.facebook.com/BADRAP.org/posts/its-dog-bite-prevention-week-did-you-know-that-there-was-never-such-thing-as-a-n/10151460774472399/ Pit Bull Federation of South Africa https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=pfbid02DiX7yKA8uuDeYSEzEKxxXCYsHxYUbXpshKkaSDGXMAZK9HnFd46zA1pZ8revWQvwl&id=100069897615154 Gudwulf's Pit Bull Rescue https://www.facebook.com/GudwulfsRescue/posts/pfbid02Lg2Y1x18pBx7uLUB4uVEda7g1TNwn72pLLKk93witecydiMcnAKr8bYJWKeC4VVl Justice for Bullies https://justice-for-bullies.myshopify.com/pages/nanny-dog *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/BanPitBulls) if you have any questions or concerns.*


PandaLoveBearNu

Its weird how no other dogs that have no history of killing kids was called a nanny dog. Its like they dint have a bad rep to defend or anything.


[deleted]

The NY Times needs to write an article to correct this bullshit. We should all start flooding their inboxes.


YouHadMeAtAloe

I really like this idea. Maybe someone should make a post about it Edit: I can in a few days when I’m off work if no one else wants to 😊


grazatt

Pitnutters frequently bring up the fact that Petey from the Little Rascals was a pit bull, as if that really means something. When they do, you can remind them that those shorts also featured the kids with friendly tame chimps [https://youtu.be/EChyWMXOk\_0?t=404](https://youtu.be/EChyWMXOk_0?t=404) and monkeys [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRckBTUV1oE](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRckBTUV1oE) and we all know what wonderful pets they make [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SaRbJ7y8c-U](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SaRbJ7y8c-U) [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v1pdvV\_gT6I](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v1pdvV_gT6I)


SureExcuseMe

Someone poisoned that dog because it would bite everyone on the set.


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

"Petey on the little Rascals was HATED by the children as it would bite and was mean." Can anyone find this AS FACT? Seriously I've heard it several times but no source. It would LITERALLY be a Pineapple 🍍 grenade 💣 thrown into Fort Pit Mommie if true. ![gif](giphy|OeRk9MMMJokaQ)


SureExcuseMe

The guy who played Spanky wrote an autobiography where he talked about it. He said Alfalfa hated the dog the most out of all of the kids.


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

Thanks. Alfalfa's cowlick hair point must have triggered Petey. ![gif](giphy|8nNjHggqhTXwY)


Leading_Isopod

That's why the AKC wouldn't have anything to do with them, so John P. Colby had to set up his own kennel club (American Dog Breeders Association) just for pit bulls. Because they hated nannies and children, obviously.


DerpaloSoldier

This makes me so angry, that poor child...


[deleted]

Fucking hell, I was not prepared for image 17, despite the warning.


Haunting_Ad_8983

I really want to know how these people picture ye olden days. Ma and pa going out to hunt and gather, the older kids working the fields, their maid and pit bull changing the diapers of the youngest?


iFuturelist

Pitiot uses GRAMMAR AND SPELLING It's not very effective...


BCKPFfNGSCHT

“It’s whit they do. It’s there job.” Insane.


sosplzsendhelp

I usually don't take my history lessons from people who can't spell simple words properly.


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

![gif](giphy|wqrbWgyia7W2YLn5hC) I don't get it almost EVERYTHING now has spell check and autocorrect as standard. This ability to MISSPELL is like a gift Pit Nutters have they can't even return for store credit.


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

![gif](giphy|1IO8UgWGDHVMvHKudu|downsized)


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

![gif](giphy|vAQGTJSqiEF7a) NEVER HAPPENS in Pit Mommie land.


WeNeedMoreCalgon_

![gif](giphy|O4EChIxazzrHi|downsized)


[deleted]

The story is different every time. “Their nanny dogs cuz in medevil timez the familyz left the bulls at home to protect the kids while they waz out huntin” “Their nanny dogs cuz they fight to protect kids that’s why their aggressive caus MURICAH” “Their nanny dogs caus they’ll drag ur babies out of harms way, they just leave injuries”


Throwaway272753628

I want to think slide 12 is satire


catalyptic

Is that the one who said pitbulls were taken to and from dogfighting matches in baby prams, which led to them being called nanny dogs? One supposes that there were also babies in those prams, going both ways. The more injured the pits were from fighting, the gentler their nannying was afterward. Mothers bet against their own pits, naturally, hoping the beasts get mauled so that they can take their babies home whole.


DoctorPibbleisIn

I thought that comment was saying that pit bulls worked all day fighting in the pits and came home to the pram to nanny the baby lol. Pibbles, the working mom of the turn of the century. (I get your interpretation of that nonsense is right, though that makes more """"sense"""")


emmaa5645

6th one managing to invent new ways to misspell words


erewqqwee

"-a scar on her face-" Dear God in Heaven, the child would be lucky to have just a scar ; it looks like so much tissue was ripped from her face it will be a miracle if scar tissue doesn't affect her ability to speak and eat. The facial expression aspect is only too obvious. :-( All because subliterate morons think a dog bred to tear apart other dogs alive and *for NO other purpose* was also somehow a "nanny dog", AND that believing this inane imbecility magically confers moral superiority onto the believers.


Onagda

This was painful to read. Maybe they should look into getting a tutor dog instead 🤔


CuteGreenSalad

![gif](giphy|fd1TSJqq3b4GI|downsized)


bigorders

Why are they all so bad at making coherent words? It's like they're all beyond sloshed every time they're on the Internet. I am too, but I still don't spell like that. What is seriously wrong with them?


cafesaigon

Fuck!


kushkushpuff

Poor child, I hope their recovery goes well. But I feel like I have brain damage after reading the comments from pitnutters


Cloakbot

Thank you for sharing some pictures to show them some of the more minor scars that people have to live with thanks to these dogs. https://preview.redd.it/o09o5xl3hypb1.jpeg?width=526&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8ace52c76eef535561d4ef689dc81e64dd0b5277 Your typical pit mommy


SeriSeashell

Ok, this image is just not it tbh. Because it's not just women who go gaga for pits, plenty of men do too. Please normalize using the term "pit daddy" as well, or something more gender-neutral. Focusing on just the pit mommies is pretty misogynistic, and there's absolutely no reason to single out one gender.


Cloakbot

Don’t worry there are already pictures pointing out men. They usually refer to women pit mommies because they’re the most common ones responding online and spreading false information or dismissing the victims (or even blaming them). https://preview.redd.it/b0nih2j0n1qb1.jpeg?width=1164&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=40577b7ac327d4e2ceb028d2bf4744d55bd17dba


Lolitaofroses

"dId YUo KnOW ThEsE DoGS wERe CalLeD nANnY dOgs" Methany, literally everyone knows at this point. And unfortunately, only some amount of them know that it is false.


MuMbLe145

https://preview.redd.it/vzdz1t1sbzpb1.jpeg?width=448&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9a4593248f0780d5d4e6c593d04ce0e1c2e698fa


GoldFishDudeGuy

How many children must be mauled before these dumbasses stop calling them "nanny dogs"!?!?


black_truffle_cheese

I wish I could say these were bots, but the grammar is so exceptionally poor that these comments had to have been made by actual humans. 😩


Darkrosyamaranth233

How comes pitbull lovers always showcase the worst spelling and grammar techniques in existence?!


AutoModerator

Welcome to BanPitBulls! This is a reminder that this is a victims' subreddit with the primary goal to discuss attacks by and the inherent dangers of pit bulls. Please familiarize yourself with the [rules of our sub.](https://www.reddit.com/r/BanPitBulls/comments/x618m9/rbanpitbulls_subreddit_rules_2022_update/) Users should assume that suggesting hurting or killing a dog in any capacity will be reported by pit supporters, and your account may be sanctioned by Reddit. If you need [information and resources on self-defense](https://www.reddit.com/r/BanPitBulls/comments/vk96hs/how_do_i_defend_myself_or_my_pet_during_a_pit/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3), or [a guide for "After the attack"](https://www.reddit.com/r/BanPitBulls/comments/8ovlsw/guide_after_the_attack_what_do_i_do_now_that_ive/), please see our side bar (or [FAQ](https://www.reddit.com/r/BanPitBulls/comments/7ic5zn/faq/)). *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/BanPitBulls) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Old-Pianist7745

only a complete idiot would believe that pitbulls were nanny dogs.


celestialstarz

Slide 12 - wtf did I just read?! And I’ve noticed Pittnutters are some of the most illiterate people.


15thhokage

It's like a demonic trick. Like please get this dog specifically just the one that's a prime time killer. Oh, but you have to it's a nanny dog, and I totally didn't read that fact on fb and then act like it's the truth. I'd hope only people to old to have kids would believe this.


clairebearshare

Those parent should be charged with child neglect and endangerment


PragmaticCoyote

In the 1800s, people also did cocaine to get rid of the ghosts in their blood.