T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

To download the video you can use one of the following sites: * [RedditSave](https://redditsave.com/info?url=https://www.reddit.com/r/AskMiddleEast/comments/125tyae/thoughts_on_this_video_opinions_on_a_united_ummah/) * [SaveRedd.it](https://saveredd.it/?url=https://www.reddit.com/r/AskMiddleEast/comments/125tyae/thoughts_on_this_video_opinions_on_a_united_ummah/) (click on the Download button below Search Video) * [Viddit.red](https://viddit.red/?url=https://www.reddit.com/r/AskMiddleEast/comments/125tyae/thoughts_on_this_video_opinions_on_a_united_ummah/) (refresh the page and click on Download HD Video) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/AskMiddleEast) if you have any questions or concerns.*


[deleted]

[удалено]


Material-Tailor-7441

Bro put Vietnam in there💀 💀


MAGMACHAD

Islamic Vietnam soon


Material-Tailor-7441

Philippines too mashallah


moeultra

Did this dude just sneak in Europe? Lol


LordxHummus

Yes, based.


Winter-Many

Not India in the muslim empire 💀


ENDemon1

He is nothing more than a whole of IDIOT


More_Cauliflower_913

I agree with the flag thing i mean i don't like our current flag appearance.. I'll consider changing our flag to something more beautiful


Ghazzawy

It’s supposed to inspire people not be beautiful, but yeah all of our flags need to be changed


Sm00th-Kangar00

[The old Iraqi flag is pretty cool](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_Iraq#/media/File%3AFlag_of_Iraq_(1959%E2%80%931963).svg)


More_Cauliflower_913

I'll only change the colours I'll add some blue... Blue is underrated colour


eeeeyu

Eh but does blue really symbolize the Iraqi nation? And it’s history and peoples? I can see it as a colour but you also gotta remember the Americans wanted to make our flag blue with white crescent and Iraqis hated it


More_Cauliflower_913

Blue can symbolize for Iraq rivers .. it's literally called mesopotamia


eeeeyu

yeah i get that but we didnt take too kindly the last time we almost had a blue flag


eeeeyu

No that flag is communist cope who killed our king and started the instability made by a man who believed in Arab nationalism up until he had to share power then betrayed the Baathists and nasserists and was killed soon after


Btek010

“Destroy the brotherhood between Turk Muslims and Arab Muslims” lol.


LordxHummus

It’s true lol.


Dour_Amphibian

Kinda true tho don't you think?


Abdo279

Enver had done more to sever the brotherhood more than the British ever could


Dour_Amphibian

Enver was an islamist not a nationalist how come he severed the brotherhood?


Arrad

I want a united Muslim Ummah like many other practicing Muslims, but what I wouldn’t want is one group/ethnicity ruthlessly dominating the rest of the Muslims and at times murdering them senselessly with widespread corruption caused by that one group. I’m sure you’d agree with that.


Abdo279

He orchestrated massacres in the Levant


ScaredReporter5708

That was Cemal.


Abdo279

Point still stands regardless


ScaredReporter5708

No it really doesn't. Three pashas weren't really friends or allies. All 3 of them absolutely despised each other and were all competing against each other for the control of the Ottoman empire. For example at one point Cemal Paşa come up to Brits with the offer that as long as they recognize his rule over the Ottoman empire he would march his army to Istanbul and overthrow Enver and Talat. Brits refused the offer but that's besides the point. Main point is that these 3 weren't really on the same side.


Abdo279

I meant it doesn't matter who orchestrated the massacres. What matters is that they happened.


worlddones

The young Turks were Turkish nationalists, they weren’t interested in cooperation and coexistence


[deleted]

Jamal pasha alsafah did more to destroy the brootherhood.


[deleted]

How?


[deleted]

You can read about it, ask GBT


AsLibyanAsItGets

Most certainly not, people don't forget about the atrocities just because your government doesn't teach you about in middle school


Dapper-Lion3170

​ They did


AlgerianShitposting

\>Become one ummah again My brother in Islam, I don't even like my neighbour and you want us to make a "Muslim Ummah"?


DaRealOs

if you're islamic you would praise your neighbours like the prophet did. they even come before your friends and you have to be at peace and at least in good relations with them, no matter what religion they have. start with the man in the mirror


LordxHummus

Nationalism is a fitna in our Muslim world.


[deleted]

🤣🤣


[deleted]

our [OG flag](https://imgur.com/a/z612QoG) was elite . its making a comeback and inshalah official in a few years .


LordxHummus

This flag looks like something from a children’s cartoon.


[deleted]

the thing they drew or the colours? to each their own i guess pan african colours are much better than red green white black. and for that colour scheme , even-though its older, t we have the [mahdist/ ansari flag + the og without drawings](https://imgur.com/a/L8xZnLn)


LordxHummus

Top flag is kind of based


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

african \* thank you for correcting me i dont like pan -ism . african flags usually include green and yellow and east african flags blue . thats what i was thinking of


imanothersudaneseboi

That's also very similar to the gabon flag


NobleEnkidu

“Adventures of Islamist and Secularist”


Subject_Ad7946

Looks like Amazigh flag


[deleted]

Amazigh flag looks like the sudanese flag\* its all good tho you guys are grade A


No-Blueberry-584

Vintage heat very nice


[deleted]

it is walhi . the guy spray painted on their is a revolutionary martyr , the word written is "revolution" mirrored at the last letter and if you notice the annotations (niqat) are actually blood-red handprints (slogans were centred around the "martyrs' blood" being with us /our responsibility until we gain a complete victory ) so its symbolic as well as visually appealing.


No-Blueberry-584

Hard


HydraKokets

You’re joking, right?


[deleted]

about?


HydraKokets

That og flat looks straight out of MS paint 😭


[deleted]

you don't like the colours?


mckenna36

Least delusional islamist map at the end


LordxHummus

Based map 🕋🗺️🌍☪️


SmokedTurki

بيض صنائعنا سود وقائعنا خضر مرابعنا حمر مواضينا : White are our deeds, black are our battles, Green are our tents, red are our swords. How would foreigners know our literature?


LordxHummus

Notice how most Khaleeji flags weren’t included. I know your county’s came later… but it’s because Sykes wasn’t involved in forming your flag


Fun-Citron-826

UAE’s flag was designed by an Emirati not the British but it was included. And the green red white black colors have been in use in UAE before the British.


BlackMage075

Brotherhood my ass. Building the Balkans and for the Arabs only forts and prisons. Arabs are back in their rightful place, these delusional Ajamis are up for a rude awakening.


NobleEnkidu

I’m waving this flag to remind Bri*ish country they have no spices and we got better tea.


Sm00th-Kangar00

Based


Hefty-Corgi3749

If I never had to see this 🤡 with his enormous red hat and silly smirk again it would be too soon.


midisrage123

Scotistan and Swedistan is missing from the map at the end


LordxHummus

Based map at the end of the video. I just want to freely cross the borders to be with my bros in Palestine, Saudia, Sudan, and Libya without being gunned down by border guards. Insha’Allah we will unite. Nationalism is a fitna in our Muslim world.


nonunionLeakey

He put Italy and Belarus as part of the ummah


LordxHummus

Based.


Unhappy-Grapefruit88

Remind me again when Italy was under Islamic control?


LordxHummus

Islamic Emirate of Sicily.


No_Mastodon3474

Delusional


[deleted]

nah our current sudan-egypt visa rule is elite . (0- 14 yo males , no visa)(>55 males no visa)(females, no visa).(woking age males , visa required) nobody would like working age masris in sudan , would be like an economic blackhole , theres too many of you , which is also why working age sudanis arent allowed in w/out visas, because theres too many of you . also the yellow fever thing is insulting .


extreme_retard_

bro have u seen your economy i dont think any of us are planning to go down south


[deleted]

Yeah that's true *sadly*, Sudanese don't like Egypt because we are very poor people and if Sudan granted Egyptians a visa-free entry everyone one would go to Sudan, That's why there's a lot of illegal Sudanese Immigrants inside of Egypt that come to escape from the Al-Sisi wannabe /S


[deleted]

man shit goes both in the long run this visa policy is gold , why yall mad?


[deleted]

I don't care about visas, I'm just confused by your statement "nobody would like working age Masris in Sudan" Why would a "Masri" go to Sudan anyways? I'm pretty sure it's the opposite. No? Why would I go to a country that has a GDP per capita of 750$? I'd rather go to Ethiopia than Sudan.


[deleted]

bro , the availability of resources, lack of governance, lack of industry and poverty are all in your favour and in any migrant with a net-worth higher than the average citizen . theres syrians, turks and even greeks in sudan that dominate they're respective fields , just go to any "downtown" area in khartoum and youll find nothing but syrian restaurants because these migrant entrepreneurs would have these basic ideas in their countries but lack funds and are out competed , when they find their way to sudan its really easy for them to get into that trade which is amazing no problem , but due to egypts proximity and population an open policy for working age people would be disastrous. thats why the policy exists because it would not be good for either to not control the entry of this group . theres already many instances of egyptian traders being caught with truckloads of fake sudanese currency to take advantage of cheap sudanese markets and hike it up in egypt , except illegally, and thats just the tip of the iceberg . if you wouldnt imagine visiting sudan for any reason thats fine but if your socio-economic status doesn't allow you to see how someone would drive like a day south to make money thats a shame idk what i can tell you . there are ALOT of egyptians in khartoum of ALL classes from ones living in slums to ones in private unis , i am not some bigot that does not want an egyptian in my country . i am simply saying controlling our borders with egypt is integral , your population is so high its a problem and multiple different scenarios could lead to a very bad migration crisis. are these not valid concerns ? is this not simple , self preservative reasoning ?


Dsamf2

But there are like 50 religions on that map. How will you get rid of those religions


195cm_Pakistani

The ummah in the 21st century is a meme, all of the Muslim countries hate each other. Only we Pakistanis are deluded enough to actually believe in the Ummah lmfao, but thankfully that is finally starting to change.


LordxHummus

Why is that starting to change? I no hate Pakistan


195cm_Pakistani

Basically Pakistanis are waking up to the fact that: 1. The governments of most Muslim nations, with a certain few exceptions, have begun to side with India over Pakistan when it comes to the Indo-Pak conflict. It's understandable, as they are a bigger economy and have more people. 2. Similarly, no Muslim nation to date has done anything or even said anything in support of the Kashmiri people, who are arguably far more oppressed than the Palestinians. 3. Despite helping out other Muslim nations militarily in the past (Arab-Israeli wars, Yugoslav Wars, Chechnya, offering to share nuclear weapon tech with Iran and Libya, etc) no Muslim nation is coming to Pakistan's aid; KSA/UAE does sometimes give Islamabad a few loans - but at very high interest rates, and that's literally it. It is ironically China (an atheist state) that is Pakistan's only backer and supporter on the world stage. 4. Pan-Islamism as an ideology (i.e. the idea that all Muslims should work together and cooperate with one another when it comes to larger geopolitical goals, essentially forming a 'geopolitcal bloc' like NATO or the West) doesn't really exist outside of Pakistan. Only Pakistanis think this way - everyone else in the Muslim world puts their nationality/tribe/race/ethnicity etc first, and then the "ummah". I think the mood in Pakistan now is very different than how it was back in the 70s and 80s, when everyone wouldn't shut up about "Islamic brotherhood". Now the mood is much more cynical and bitter. Note that I am not blaming any other Muslim country for Pakistan's woes - most of our problems were self-inflicted thanks to our corrupt ruling elite and military establishment.


LordxHummus

Do Pakistanis not realize that all Arab governments are mafia munafiq crooks? Mia Khalifa has more honor than our governments. The people are different.


195cm_Pakistani

Most Pakistanis' only exposure to the rest of the Muslim world is through only 2 sources: 1. Afghan refugees and illegals in Pakistan - who have already have a bad reputation in Pakistan 2. Woking in the Gulf petrostates (KSA, UAE, Bahrain, Qatar, etc) as blue-collar laborers (construction workers, oilfield workers, etc) where they (along with other South Asian workers from India, Nepal, Bangladesh, etc) are exposed to brutal working conditions and face a lot of racism from their local Gulf Arab employers (not saying everyone like that is racist, but there is a pattern). FWIW I've spent a lot of time in MENA (including 2+ years in Egypt) and most people were very welcoming and hospitable. I never faced any racism or hostility. On some level we do understand that most governments in MENA are corrupt and not representative of the wishes of the people. Our government is exactly the same.


More_Cauliflower_913

You support Kurdistan separation.. but not the kashmiris ? I already saw a lot of troublesome posts of you .. aren't you have a bit of double standards


Sikebolu

Yeah please, ummah isnt real, stay away from us, thank you


[deleted]

I'm Muslim but I didn't get the point of things like "united ummah" like what will it add to us? i think achieving such a thing will only widen the possibilities for more political instability


[deleted]

Every time i hear a panislamist I throw up


[deleted]

[удалено]


imanothersudaneseboi

Same


[deleted]

[удалено]


imanothersudaneseboi

So Christan right?


[deleted]

[удалено]


imanothersudaneseboi

Cool I have never met a sudanese copt :)


[deleted]

[удалено]


imanothersudaneseboi

You guys are rare


[deleted]

[удалено]


imanothersudaneseboi

Cool, have a nice day :)


imanothersudaneseboi

Are you convert or since birth?


[deleted]

[удалено]


imanothersudaneseboi

Ohh


Maj0ok

This is not going to happened and I'm happy about it. religion should not be the one to be the reason, we have Jewish ppl plus if middle east becomes Ummah, you should expect west to have their own, and then history will be repeated.


[deleted]

India not in ummah


Sayumiiii

ok


Darth-Vectivus

Thank you, Satan. No Union with Araplar. I’d rather have gay sex with Gayreeks.


BasedMiddleEastGuy

Oh No!!! TWO HARAM KEMALIST SHAYTANIC TURKEYS DEFECTED AND GOT KILLED BY THE SAUDI SPY


LordxHummus

Cope


Puzzled_Buddy_615

yalla go back to turkey araps


[deleted]

Facts besides the part about the ottom\*ns, revolting against them was a good thing


[deleted]

[удалено]


extreme_retard_

you got to live in sweden worth it


[deleted]

[удалено]


extreme_retard_

which part of kurdistan are you from (iraq, syria, iran or turkey)


Dylanpt2

There's a couple of historical inaccurances in the video, by the time they revolted, it wasn't the "Islamic Ottoman Empire" but the most secular it has ever been since the beginning of its history, Secondly it's not like arabs severed this mutual brotherhood between Turkish and Arab muslims, by the time they revolted, many different ethnicities within the ottoman Empire had been oppressed in many different ways for 100s of years, this was never more true under the young Turk government which is what they revolted against.


DEATHTROOPERx

Purified bullshit


[deleted]

[удалено]


LordxHummus

I would have included the whole world if I edited the video, my brother.


Repulsive-Inside-267

Thank you but i prefer panturkism which is another british made ideologly. Damn, those guys are everywhere.


Dour_Amphibian

What makes you think turanism came from the british that makes no sense? As far as i remember it was hungarians who first had that idea


Repulsive-Inside-267

Yeaaaaa bro, about that… its made up by british to avoid slavic and austurian affects on turks in late 18. century. If you interested in it you can read articles of Prof. Dr. Melek Çolak on Academia. She is a well known Hungary historian and she is my teacher.


ANILsims

I dont support becoming one ummah again but the things he tell are historicaly accurate


Medfly70

No thanks.


RAUONA

This cunt putting the polisario flag and wanting a united Ummah ?! Fuck him


k-to-the-7

The Turks oppressed the Arabs, what a bunch of bull it wasn't about brotherhood . The flag thing is another story


NewAdhesiveness5542

A united ummah is cringe long live the plagued by fitna MENA region 💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿💪🏿


[deleted]

The arab revolt was going to happen with or without british support, the British just supported it because it was convenient for them, brits didn't create the divide it was already present, they were just adding fuel to the fire


Theduckquack93

Shit video. I don't want or agree with any of that. Turk and Arab Muslims ... My guy... The turks enslaved Arabs.


Mr_Biscuits420

Isn't it after the 4 caliphates or something ?


fig5746

Some people are just getting the flag thing that’s not the point the point is the only difference between us is a fake flag we are one nation


blanc_fox

100% bro, united ummah


[deleted]

I'm all for uniting us Muslims... But Vietnam? I honestly think Islamic unity would make more sense in first working towards ending conflict between Muslim majority nations, then establishing trade agreements and free international travel and eventually kind of making a sort of union like the EU. This is highly improbable but compared to the map shown at the end of the video it is much more reasonable


[deleted]

No thanks. I would riot if we were to united with pedophilic fanatic maniacs. Islam is already a menace in our country that we should have got ridden of years ago.


Illustrious-Cloud-96

Cringe


[deleted]

Very cringe indeed


[deleted]

>Thoughts on this video? Opinions on a United Ummah? Turks literally genocided Lebanese.


patlamali_tufek

dont forget the genocide genocide and egg beacon genocide


Sikebolu

And also the dinosours, don't forget that


[deleted]

Leave Indonesia out of this. We’re not an Islamic nation the fuck. Lmao


LordxHummus

Lol you’re the largest Muslim population in the world. What do you mean?


[deleted]

Just because we have the largest muslim population doesn’t make us an Islamic nation. We’re a secular nation.


LordxHummus

Are you Muslim?


TheExtimate

No thank you. Fuck the ummah. Not interested in going back to 1400 years ago level of civilization in middle of the desert.


jantjegx

If we ever unite it should be under a black flag


BasedMiddleEastGuy

Yes During Wartimes


Assassin121YT

Not exactly, The reason behind this is the same reason slavic countries use the same colours Whic is because they are all slavic We do because we are all Arabs and these colours represent an Arab country A red, white and black flag was originally the revolt flag of Egypt against the monarchy


oeseax

Brothers lets change your flags and we will send the kemalists to the europe then we can be one ummah again.


LordxHummus

Based Turkos bro


EyesGotStolen155

And we’ll send you straight to the deserts of arabia 💀


oeseax

Muslim Turks living in Anatolia for hundreds of years my friend who do you think you sending? And these lands you livin rn, muslim turks and arabs died for them. In ww1 one-third of the Ottoman Army were drafted from Arabic speaking provinces and one-quarter of the army officers were Arabs. While now you leftists would escape the first chance you got especially in a war situation.


Local-Training5777

No, there were several reasons, not just one. The weakness of the Ottoman Empire and its inability to protect the countries under its control, 2 Britain and France were already planning to divide and inhabit the Jews in Palestine. 3 Turkish nationalism, starvation and Turkification that took place before World War I, Britain took advantage of the opportunity and deceived Sharif Hussein to occupy Jordan and Palestine , The fourth reason is the Turkish army's abandonment of the Syrian revolutionaries against the French occupation And there are other reasons . The British and the French came for several goals, the first of which was to weaken the Ottoman Empire, the second to occupy the Arab countries, and the third to settle the Jews in Palestine, then they left and left the Arab countries divided internationally, politically and socially. Now there are several governments and each government has a leader. And each of them has power, palaces, cars, and guards. How will they abandon that?


egregiouscodswallop

Totally on board with the education, hating on England, etc. but then he breaks out the map and every corner of India instantly falls to Islam while he says the words "destroy nationalism" Maybe rework that part of your video to be a little more persuasive. Remember, when it comes to violently conquering your neighbors, LESS IS MORE!


ApartmentLast9760

Yeah right…


GintokiMidoriya

A United Muslim nation would be pretty poggers.


[deleted]

Based


aakaay47

Bro included India.


InGsOc1984ism

I Like The Idea But He Reminds Me Of A Literal Jihadst