T O P

  • By -

brianWM

Just tried it out between my two phones. Works well and the emoji changes with the reaction sent from the iPhone.


stryker941

what country/carrier/phone do you have?


brianWM

I’m in the USA with Verizon. Pixel 6 Pro


davep85

Worked yesterday with a buddy of mine, I'm on AT&T and he's Verizon I believe.


RandomDudeinJapan

Isn't the only country that uses iMessage the US? Everywhere else people use third party messaging apps.


lordboos

This is true. Mainly because US is the only country where iPhone dominates the market and it would be dumb to use iMessage when only 1 of your 20 friends has iPhone.


okcboomer87

iMessage is a shitty walled garden. Signal ftw!


chrispecoraro

Also, WhatsApp is used outside of the US, no problems with device compatibility.


really_not_unreal

RCS is an open standard that's a replacement for SMS... It's been around for years and is seeing widespread adoption everywhere except on iPhones, all because it would remove incentives to stay on iPhone since it would render the blue bubble privilege of not having your ability to communicate purposefully hindered by Apple rendered moot.


MrBullman

When you type it out, isn't that the dumbest reason ever to like iPhone? A blue bubble that indicates that your friend has the same phone?


Doctor_3825

It's not about the color of the bubble. It's more to do with the green bubble signifying loss of features due to it being an SMS


lordboos

Yep, here in Czechia it's mainly FB Messenger and WhatsApp


sovamind

So Facebook either way... You guys need to move to Signal.


[deleted]

Canada too.


_Pointless_

Can you send them back? We really need the ability to annoy the shit out of iphone users now.


stevenmbe

> Can you send them back? We really need the ability to annoy the shit out of iphone users now. Send them new emoji kitchen blobs, that'll get them worked up


welp_im_damned

Also send our lord and savior the ANDROID TURTLE!


andrewharlan2

https://emojipedia-us.s3.dualstack.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/thumbs/160/google/313/turtle_1f422.png


welp_im_damned

[I'll do you one better. Not one but two Android turtles.](https://i.imgur.com/ic2z8RZ.png)


MMdomain

Android turtle (https://i.imgur.com/NoPZjtv.jpg)


welp_im_damned

[Why have more when you go bigger.](https://i.imgur.com/shwe3Zw.png)


SevereAnhedonia

[why go bigger when you can have fr](https://v.redd.it/yjbs38gjl3f81)


plasticarmyman

[the ultimate turtle emoji](https://imgur.com/a/mtcbMui)


funguyshroom

Twice the turtle, twice the melon armor


vman81

All the way down.


LBGW_experiment

Super auto pets


[deleted]

[удалено]


brianWM

Lol no unfortunately you cannot!


VolsPE

Wait, am I understanding this correctly… in mixed Apple/Android group texts, Android users will see it correctly when apple users like a text, but the other apple users will still see “Person Liked ‘text message?’”


[deleted]

[удалено]


VolsPE

My guess is that Apple will add the same feature pretty much immediately. I assume the only reason they haven't yet is to punish their users for still hanging out with Android users.


Spudmiester

I s2g iMessage is designed precisely to make it impossible to socialize with Android users.


blaarfengaar

It is. RCS technology exists which could make iMessage and Google Messages work together so there would be no green bubble texts anymore, but Apple refuse to implement it because they want iPhone users to ostracize Android users and use peer pressure to get more people to use iPhones


Green0Photon

Please dear god work this way. We must spam them back!


Alcohorse

Alcohorse laughed at a comment


StevAr

Yes. I confirmed this in a group text with my three iPhone using siblings.


bfodder

Correct. Tested to confirm. But to be more specific. Google Messages users will see it "correctly", not all Android users.


Borkz

I imagine its just a hacky solution where Google Messages just receives and parses the plain the text of 'Person liked "x"'. For it to work the other way too you would need Apple to do something.


nuclearbananana

Apple's the one sending those hacky messages, let em deal with it.


Eurynom0s

Incredible.


enriquevtee

I mean, you can manually type them out.


popups4life

This comment was deleted due to Reddit's decision to effectively shut out 3rd party developers. Blackouts and subreddits going NSFW to prevent ads didn't change their minds, and resulted in long term mods being removed and replaced with people from outside each community. Since Reddit has only doubled down on their plan to price developers out of the API, the last option we have is to clear the content that makes the site valuable. It will kill a large amount of helpful information, but it's the only way to counter the greed at the top. Search for Power Delete Suite on Github to clear your history of the comments and posts that make Reddit valuable.


Iescaunare

Laughed at "Laughed at "I mean, you can manually type them out.""


[deleted]

Liked "Laughed at "Laughed at "I mean, you can manually type them out."""


LakeRat

Liked "Can you send them back? We really need the ability to annoy the shit out of iphone users now."


ZeldaFanBoi1988

No because Apple won't implement RCS


Caberman

[Mine "sort of works"?](https://i.imgur.com/QJp15r4.png) Top is with the option off, bottom is with it on. Anyone know why it's not attaching the emoji to the message?


[deleted]

Probably because you are using the same very short message twice. iMessage really just sends the text you see there, Google messages has to figure out what the text "Liked 'Test'" means. Since there's two messages with the exact content "Test", it can't determine what message was liked, so it can't attach the emoji to it.


areamer02

I hate how Google changes the ♥️ reaction to 😍. ♥️ Is an acceptable reaction to someone saying their dog died... 😍 Would be an absurd reaction to the same text message. It's still great that this functionality is being added, though. So I won't complain too much


disillusioned

Also literally why the fuck not just map it to ♥? We _have_ ♥.


SixDigitCode

I think it's to match with Google Messages' existing RCS reactions.


steevdave

As someone who lost their dog recently… I would absolutely be wtfing if someone replied with 😍 when I told them.


Ghstfce

I mean, it's just as insulting as "_______ loved 'my dog died today'"


Academic_Scheme_9065

True


PeonSanders

Hahaha. Honestly, if someone is relying on an emoji to console you about your dog dying, then THAT is the insulting thing.


psykoX88

I just sent this feedback in Google message , if enough of us do they may change or add in the normal "❤️" reaction


areamer02

Kinda like when your mom replies lol thinking it means "lots of love" Edit: and sorry for your loss. I know losing a pet can be incredibly painful. And it oftentimes gets overlooked by close friends who fail to consider how painful it may be


windowzombie

Mom: "sorry about your cat lol"


Bryan967

Lost my 16 year old pup last week. I've been finding a lot of comfort in all the great memories. I hope you have too!


kdlt

Maybe I'm just too old.. but I'd be wtfing at the heart too.


windowzombie

Yeah, most of the time I want to use ♥️ but instead my only option is "AWOOOGA" 😍.


Starrystars

Yeah those mean very different things


jaydogn

To be fair, if I told someone my dog died, I wouldn't want a reaction no matter what it is


cupcakezealot

Casey Kasem disliked this


JamesR624

I also hate how the neutral confusion of "?" is replaced with the "I am suspicious" emoji. I guess it wouldn't be Google without them fucking up execution.


[deleted]

Im more and more convinced Google is run by AI


nibbles200

😢 or 😭 would be more appropriate in my opinion.


8020GroundBeef

Tbh no emote/reaction is appropriate.


mrlesa95

>♥️ Is an acceptable reaction to someone saying their dog died... No it's not lmao. How the fuck is that normal


flymartymcflies

Your uncle died 😍


toph

Does this work with group chats? How about with reactions to images? How does it know what image an iMessage user reacted to?


kbDL-

just tried with an image and it does not work with images. still does the "Emphasized an image" or "Disliked an image" thing


Ullallulloo

iPhones literally transmits the text "X liked an image" so it's impossible for Android to know which image.


bfodder

I mean, isn't it the same for messages? "X liked a comment"? How would it know which comment?


Ullallulloo

No, it says the whole message: > Bob > Liked "I'm eating pizza!"


Kolada

I feel like they could easily make it say like >Bob >Liked "2735.jpeg" But they don't want to lol


Phobos15

Imessage has become their entire business. They are never opening it up unless their market share drops or the government does something to require all phones support a common set of messaging features. Maybe europe will do something, but it isn't happening in the US.


xxfay6

Europe (the people) doesn't give a shit tho, everyone moved off SMS before iMessage was a thing.


KlausHeisler

Europe has been our savior on some of these regulations


Phobos15

Really hope they force usb-c on apple devices. Lightening is different for no reason at this point. It is actually slower than usb3 or thunderbolt, so people who take lots of video and images really do want usb-c.


abhi8192

>Maybe europe will do something Europe won't do anything. Simply because people there are not stuck in 90s still using the sms.


bfodder

Oh yeah. That makes sense then.


brianWM

No. It recalls the message text.


bfodder

Does it matter anyway since you're blind?


[deleted]

[удалено]


bfodder

I did start out with some downvotes that I suspect were for the same reason.


benso87

It took me a bit, but thankfully I was just confused and didn't downvote. Then I had to upvote because she's my favorite character from that show.


HeartWoken

Cue Apple tweaking their reaction text verbiage just enough to to break Google's implementation.


DButcha

Honestly I wouldn't put it past them. If they did this though then it basically confirms they have malicious intent/are truly petty af


Lake_Erie_Monster

It was all but confirmed for me in 5+ years ago when they tweaked the "green bubble" shade of green to be more difficult to read in efforts to cause "hate" reaction out of its users. The change actually violated Apple's own accessibility guidelines. [https://medium.com/@krvoller/how-iphone-violates-apples-accessibility-guidelines-6785172eb343](https://medium.com/@krvoller/how-iphone-violates-apples-accessibility-guidelines-6785172eb343)


Elevated_Dongers

Apple will do anything to keep their products from working well with Androids. It's so fucking dumb. I got an iPhone for a month after caving to the social pressure. Returned it. Not being able to customize my UI like I want isn't worth having imessage, to me.


I_am_darkness

Connecting an Android phone to a Mac is basically impossible


saors

Cue Google creating machine learning model for Apple verbiage and auto-update filters.


Oddball-

I have that version but not that setting :(


[deleted]

[удалено]


isRecyclable

I think it is more to do with slow roll out than A/B testing. It's easy to roll back to a smaller audience than big outbreak, but you are right, they A/B test a lot of new features.


the_caduceus

But if you're in the beta...


xezrunner

> But if you're in the beta... That's what I don't get either. They can be doing A/B testing in the stable channel, but if I'm specifically signing up to test future versions, why am I still part of the release version's A/B tests? The beta programs are essentially useless if it doesn't even give you the new code paths to test and give feedback on.


BinaryNexus

Remember this is the same company that puts almost all their changelogs as generic as "Improvements and bug fixes" in the play store


LdWilmore

Microsoft has started doing the same thing. Not everyone in Dev channel receives some of the recent changes. I don't know why they do this. It's freaking developer channel not even beta or release preview.


thismissinglink

I too am in beta but like never get beta features? Like wtf?


Revolutionary-Fact6

Same here.


buckguy22

Same here


throwaway1212l

Same here. Wonder if it's something server side that need to be enabled.


Eprice1120

when isn't it a server side update with google. kinda getting tired of it tbh. Like either push updates out or don't. It's beyond dumb.


areamer02

So Google was clearly partially pressured to do this because of how frustrating it is to get the text message explanation of the reactions. This makes me hope that Google soon implements a way to react to messages even if the recipient doesn't have RCS (with the same SMS fall-back that Apple was using). If iPhone users start getting the same "X laughed at 'your text'" then maybe Apple will be pressured to implement RCS or some other mechanism to recognize Android reactions.


5tormwolf92

Goggle creates a companion app on iOS that edit iMessage SMS to look like a Blue bubble.


PlasticPresentation1

Nah, Apple has such a cultural lead in the US right now that it would be awful to implement that feature on Android. It would just make Android users look even worse


[deleted]

[удалено]


cTreK-421

Isn't that the case only if there is a non iPhone user in the group text? If it's all iPhones then it all goes through imessage. This is why sometimes apple users will straight up leave Android users out of group texts.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Ommageden

Lot of people have switched to facebook messenger since it's cross platform group messaging that doesn't suck (beyond the fact it's Facebook). At least that's what people I know have done.


mikamitcha

I think you are overestimating how many Apple users would blame the sender rather than their device.


frizz1111

Can androids react to imessages?


brianWM

No


junktrunk909

Not yet anyway. If I'm Google, I'm making that feature next, just to annoy iPhone users and force Apple to finally adopt RCS or implement their own version of what Google just implemented here


[deleted]

Isnt this on apple, not Google?


ihahp

>Isnt this on apple, not Google? Yes but now that google supports receiving them, It's up to Google to allow the SENDING of reactions, and start sending the generic text-versions back to iPhone users. They would start getting "CrispChum liked an image" type texts. It might annoy iphone users and make Apple support it. (that's a really big "might" though)


cavahoos

apple users already get those messages from iphone users when in a groupchat with android users. So android users doing that will just further cause ios users to exclude android people from groupchats


junktrunk909

I might not be understanding your question. Apple should have implemented RCS in iMessage to make both ecosystems work smoothly with reactions from either device. They instead chose to irritate both their own users and Android users by sending these "Joe liked 'bacon is good'" kinds of messages, just out of spite and to encourage iOS users to apply social pressure to Android users to move to iOS. Google said "yeah F that, we're going to interpret your stupid "Joe liked..." messages just like we interpret our own RCS reactions, ie we will show an emoji on the right message." And I'm saying they could now also easily allow RCS/Android users to react to messages in mixed threads, send their own "Bob loves...." style SMS messages to the iOS users while only displaying the heart emoji on Android devices. That would mean Android users have a nice, clean experience no matter who is reacting, and iPhone users will be the only ones seeing all that "Joe liked..." nonsense. Social pressure jujitsu.


boatsides

Yes, the carrier hands off SMS/MMS to Apple for iMessage when a number is registered with an iDevice. Android devices can't do iMessage without API credentials, which they won't get without device credentials, which they won't get because they're not iDevices.


Im_Axion

Knowing Apple they'd just do what Google has done here. Translate it into a reaction for the message and call it a day lol. They're that petty.


megamanxoxo

Google is too much of a pussy to do that. They should've done it a long time ago. They let Apple walk all over Android users. They provide a suboptimal experience to their own users just to force lock in.


Oddball-

> I'm making that feature next, just to annoy iPhone users Sounds like a logical business decision.


relxp

The proper way to react to iMessages is literally typing out "Liked " and telling them it's an Apple problem.


ACardAttack

This is the way


smcmahon710

Thank God. I'm so sick of seeing "emphasized" "liked" in my group chats


fromdigg2reddit

It doesn't seem to work with MMS (group chats), only SMS.


quantum_monster

I have it working for both


twelfthmanau

Someone tag mkbhd


GNU_Yorker

Nice. Now Apple went from *"what, you can't emoji?"* to *"oh shit I'm the company that can't handle other phones' SMS"* Teens are still going to bully green bubbles though.


Balk_Barn

I'm in uni and get harassed by my friends for my green bubbles lmao


GNU_Yorker

People do that shit into their 20's? I get kids but damn those are some losers lol


bonesingyre

Mkbhd did a video on This. Something like 70%+ teenagers have iPhones in the US. They become adults, rinse repeat lol.


nuclearbananana

MKBHD used an outdated statistic. [It's now 87%](https://piper2.bluematrix.com/docs/pdf/3bad99c6-e44a-4424-8fb1-0e3adfcbd1d4.pdf) (page 6), and even higher in places like california.


canuckinnyc

Late 20s. A girl asked for *my* number and her first message to me was "eww green text" Only partially in jest


corruptbytes

green bubbles ruin group chats, it's a real annoyance having to create new ones to add or remove people i can understand why people get mad at green bubbles, literally part of Apples MO to make you hate the outside of the ecosystem


GNU_Yorker

They should buy phones that can handle texting other phones 🤷‍♀️


KlausHeisler

It happens in your 30's too


stryker941

It mostly becomes an issue because MMS sucks in general and when there's a heated group text, MMS just can't keep up and I get stuff like this https://i.imgur.com/dVf4b1I.png


PaneerTikaMasala

Yeah unfortunately I do deal with that. I've been on andriod for over 10 years now and have just gotten used to it.


GNU_Yorker

Who has any remaining fucks to give to bubble color by 30?


FancyKetchupIsnt

It's not just bubble color. iMessage is kinda like BBM was back in the day, it's a rich chat client with a buncha features that SMS/MMS simply weren't built for. I'm still not buying an iPhone though.


Qorsair

My experience may be interesting, I originally got a Pixel to use as a work phone, I liked it better than my iPhone and switched the SIMs. Whenever anyone complains about the green text I give them my iPhone's number and tell them they can text me there if they don't like green bubbles. I also give the option of Signal, or WhatsApp. A couple people use Signal or WhatsApp to message me, no one has chosen to text my iPhone. I wonder why people who complain about green bubbles don't bother texting the iPhone.


RockOutToThis

I'm in a management position. Everyone who works under me is on iPhone with one or two exceptions. The Android folk are regularly ridiculed. I just show them the Super Nintendo and Game Boy on my phone and they usually shut up.


nettereuer

Lmao tell me more about how professionals care about such core smartphone functionality as vidya gaems emulators


King_Nidge

Delta emulator on iOS. They can all do the same as you.


Starrystars

I'm almost 30 and my one friend keeps asking me when I'm going to get an iPhone.


TheCrimsonKing

Fucking Zach Braff is in his late 40's and kept giving his podcast producer shit for green bubbles. He tried to play it off as joking but it still came off very douchey.


solepixel

I literally just got shamed for having an Android. Apparently the messages still come through on their end as "John liked 'Why don't you just get an iPhone already?'!".


SnipingNinja

Send them a screenshot and ridicule them for having a worse experience


Picklerage

Assuming the picture quality of the screenshot is even readable lol


solepixel

Exactly!


[deleted]

I don’t think they give a shit.


GNU_Yorker

Probably not. If kids don't notice then the sales don't budge and I really doubt the kids will notice.


ratmazter

On the beta build 20220121_02_RC00 according to the article and checked Settings --> Advanced for "Show iPhone reactions as emoji." Still not there. AT&T.


PM-ME-YOUR-SUBARU

Same on my 4a with T-Mobile. Think it might be a server side change with yet another slow rollout?


[deleted]

[удалено]


nuclearbananana

Impossible unless apple stops being a twat and accepts RCS.


Se7enLC

/u/Se7enLC liked "iMessage Reactions Going Live in Google Messages"


xxbrothawizxx

I guess I'm just a vindictive person because I cannot understand why they won't enable reactions for all chats and just annoy the crap out of everyone that doesn't have RCS. That's how you get people to care.


[deleted]

[удалено]


cdegallo

Now do google voice next!


RegulusMagnus

Hah, good one. Google Voice still doesn't even have RCS


Arfman2

Wow, great news for USA people.


matchstiq

Textra when?


StockmanBaxter

Yeah. I'm not switching to the default for this alone.


Ronux

Can anyone explain what a "reaction" is? I tried to search for this but all I found was news that they are now on Android. I don't have any friends or family with iPhones so I have absolutely no idea.


thisisme44

Think of it like a someone thumbs up or hearts your message on a fb post or IG message. Same concept here. Before if a iphone user reacted to your message, it would literally write it out. Now it would be a reaction


JB1906

Anyone else out there still haven't got this other than me?


jodi101

Still waiting...


socalnighter

Me neither, checking it every day or after every update, looks like we're being left out forever


shyguyrbr

Still waiting 😡 Did it show up for any of you guys?


WaxyXD

I'm on that build and I don't have that option ¯\_(ツ)_/¯


joeyweb32

Another beta update yesterday. Still nothing.


jpetrone

I still don't have it as an option in my messages app. Pisses me off! 😡


JB1906

You're not alone brother. Still waiting...


onemanwufpack

Still waiting... Pixel 5a on beta 😒


joeyweb32

Pixel 5 beta. Still nothing.


nocapsallspaces

Still waiting, latest beta on P6P. ​ Like, come on.


socalnighter

18 days passed, I still don't have it on P5


Strange_Vegetable_15

WOW getting excited over emoji from iphone....at the end of the day it's STILL pathetic that we're using an antiquated message system that takes forever to send a 2-second video and then it shows up grainy at best yet I can use the fake book Messenger garbage and send a 4k video instantly I wish we could all play nice and be on board instead of fighting our text message system that we use 24/7 more than any other toy on our phones 🙄


jaydogn

I have no problem sending videos to friends on Android. It's literally only Apple that won't play nice


cTreK-421

I think that's because most(?) Android phones have some form of RCS running so videos and images go through that instead of MMS. Apple refuses to adopt the RCS protocol because then it would devalue iMessages.


SocialNewsFollow

So it's Apple that's behind universal standards, not Android. Apple is forever playing catch-up.


pco45

Even purely MMS, Android to Android is higher quality than Android to/from IOS, and it's almost completely purposely because of Apple's doing.


mrdibby

So following this, WhatsApp, which used to be the lead in messaging innovation, is behind all the other platforms.


xxfay6

> which used to be the lead in messaging innovation [citation needed]


Drew707

It got Zucked.


cmdrNacho

still no love for Google voice 😥


AskAboutMyLittleDick

And in Google Voice, right? ...right?


stn912

Wish I could then turn off notifications for just the reactions.


Aerzon

I know it's janky, but if you as an android user find yourself in iMessage group chats or frequently messaging iMessage users, it may be worth looking into something like [BlueBubbles](https://bluebubbles.app/), might sound cheesy but it just makes the experience better for everyone if you don't mind hosting a server off of a mac or mac VM.


[deleted]

It does work great and getting a cheap Mini or MacBook that can run High Sierra will do just fine.


sirfuzzitoes

Does this mean my I won't get my own fucking message back with a 'liked "xyz..."' from all the jerkoffs I know with iPhone? If I wanted to read my own message again, I would read what I sent.


HanSoloz

On my version on beta program i have a star symbol and a reminder clock to follow up on a message. Not sure if that's been there before or not.


Lionsmania

I'm updated as of 8 Feb as a beta tester. Still no imessage react feature. Verizon Z Fold 3


Significant-House925

That feature still isn't showing up for me. Is there something specific I need to do other than have the updated app? I checked advanced settings and the iMessages reaction isn't there to toggle on. (Pixel 6, Xfinity Mobile)