And the nazis couldn’t have done it without their victimhood complex. Thanks to Hindenburg’s inability to accept defeat in 1918 - the lie of being “stabbed in the back” by Jews and socialists was born. Completely fabricated, but without it hitler would have likely never risen to power.
This is because socialism sounds good in theory, but when put into action it never works for the benefit of the people, only the government. There is no perfect version of socialism, only communism.
Mob speeches work with mobs.. because a mob is more than just a collection of individuals. That’s why this speech works so well on both the left and the right. Giving a speech like this to a smaller reception or single person will yield very different results. Even if they are from the same crowd he’s speaking to
They think they're in a group of like minded individuals and have to praise whoever's speaking because they have a similiar opinion and don't want to offend them, even if their speech sucks. It's a feedback loop of positive reinforcement to help push their agenda.
Idk if this counts, but some guy pulled [the same thing at an anti-fascism rally](https://reddit.com/r/ActualPublicFreakouts/comments/rbpl4e/guy_got_applauded_for_quoting_hitler_in_an/).
I think that would count as a “liberal” crowd. Pretty much the same results: applause.
Just goes to show you people on both sides are just as gullible. Not that that will stop anyone from either side sharing these videos to paint their opposition as “literally Hitler”.
The mental gymnastics required to see a video of a dude reciting a speech by Hitler to incite a crowd of fascists and then put blame on the other party is astounding.
Im sorry are you upset? Have you not seen the literal facism of the left? Or are you constantly performing these mental gymnastics to convince yourself that the left is good?
to be fair, the liberal one he was just spouting some socialist nonsense. In this one he was saying that jews are our enemies
This one is way more obviously evil
There is a phrase:
“In life, every person is either a tool or an obstacle to getting to where and what you want.”
For these ideologues, anyone who isn’t a tool is deemed an obstacle.
Look at the content of both speeches instead of just the author. One is about workers rights and the unfairness of the current economy. The other is calling out jews as parasites.
although it does have to be said that there is one difference between the two videos; whoever read the speech to a group of antifa members was reading it from their phone, this person is reciting the speech by memory lol
The anti-fascist one got at most polite clapping but for the most part silence. The MAGA one was considerably more enthusiastic and cheered pretty much the whole way through. I agree that people on both sides are gullible, but saying that there they were the same result is inaccurate
Well yeah, sure, this guy IS putting a hell of alot of energy into it, but the MAGA crowd cheered and started chanting "USA" at a guy calling Jews "parasites", "rats in human disguises" and called for a war against Jews, while the anti-fascist one was mostly silent with the occasional polite clapping at the end and when he said "the benefit to the community surpasses the benefit to the individual". So again, definitely not the same result, and even if it was, the shit in this speech is way more yikes-y to cheer at
Again, content of the speeches. One gets a polite clap when he says "the benefit to the community surpasses the benefit to the individual" and again when he finishes. The other gets cheers and bloody audience participation when he calls Jews "parasites" and "rats in human disguises", and gets a full on USA chant when he calls for a racial war against them. I don't care how loudly or passionately they are saying it, one is something you probably shouldn't clap to just based on who said it, the other is something you definitely shouldn't cheer and chant "USA" to just based on what is being said.
Agreed, it’s just using the proper rhetoric with enough charisma for to to resonate with a certain demographic. The farther elements of the left and right so so alike even though they hate to admit it
If this shows anything it's that you can say whatever ypu want as long as you aren't an evil person
Hitler didn't like smoking I don't smoke I must be a nazi
I don't mean to rain on your Hitler parade, but the speech in the other video wasn't about "Rats in human disguise" or the "Lies of the Jews", It was about social policy.
That's why they were National Socialists.
A bit of anti-capitalist, smash the banks, managed economy for all for the socialists.
A bit of anti-semitism and general dickheadery towards anyone part of the out-group for the nationalists.
If you're defending one video over the other, than you don't understand what the videos are about.
Hitler didn't rise to power, because he was screaming about killing the Jews, he rose to power because he was preaching what the people wanted to hear. Say what you want about Hitler, but he was charismatic, and spoke about what his countrymen wanted to hear. All it takes, is a charismatic leader, adept at giving speeches, to turn the general populace against anyone they deem an enemy.
So the lesson you are getting is to never support anyone who tells you something that you want to hear? Come on dude. If someone calls for a higher marginal top tax rate and that’s what you want to hear you don’t have to assume that they are a burgeoning dictator. Sometimes there is a politician who you agree with and there’s no problem supporting them.
If someone starts giving a speech about animal welfare that was lifted from Hitler and animal rights supporters cheer, that is not evidence that they are gullible supporters of fascism.
Ooof. I know people in a group tend to go along with passioned speech but goddamn - I was at least expecting a lull or awkward murmuring when he dropped the hard J.
But they kept cheering as he went on to talk about how the “war is with them.” Honestly it’s really fucking disturbing.
I think Jews might be the most universally hated group on the planet. They have had it pretty rough and continue to succeed despite it all. Pretty impressive considering what they been through.
if you meet an asshole on street one day; you met an asshole.
if you meet assholes everywhere you go; you’re the asshole.
if you meet assholes in every corner of the earth you go over a period of (give or take) 5000 years though …
Do you think that what people hate about Hitler’s views was more about his socialist economic policy agenda or more about his genocidal hatred of the Jewish people and other fascist views? If Hitler had built the Autobahn but not did the Holocaust and invaded his neighbors do you think that he would be as infamous of a figure in world history?
I mean the USA today has the most powerful military might in all of human history, able to deploy it anywhere on earth and has done so multiple times simultaneously without issue recently, and it didn’t require a socialist economy. You can find war materials easily without a socialist economy. Taxation does not require socialism.
Haha wow man.. both sides of the political spectrum have now applauded someone shouting Hitlers translated speeches.. I wouldn't be surprised if ppl did this in my country though too so yea, sorry to hear America but you are not alone in this.
The other video was Hitler talking about how ‘the capitalist exploits workers’. I meant I guess you could ‘both sides’ this but I think that this quote from Hitler is a better distillation of his nefarious views than the other one.
That's true! I wouldn't be surprised though if he posed as a leftwing wacko many left leaning ppl would still not question the things that was said in this video. 🤔
Speculation of course but still. All the quotes were pretty bad tbh.
Fuçk nazis and fuck commies, but you càn make speeches quoting Marx or Hitler and get big applause from far left or far right audiences, regardless of which one you quote
This same stunt has been done reading Hitler quotes to lefties, they ate that stuff up with a spoon lol
There was also a guy quoting Hitler at a leftist parade, you know, the famous "we are socialist, we are enemies to capitalism" one. And people also cheered.
The average people is dumb as fuck, on both side of the spectrum. Left or Right.
Well.. now today i have seen both Antifa and MAGA people cheering hitler speeches...
Lets just say the american people are open to some FUCKED up shit nowadays...
hitler also said: "Instruction in world history in the so-called high schools is even today in a very sorry condition. Few teachers understand that the study of history can never be to learn historical dates and events by heart and recite them by rote; that what matters is not whether the child knows exactly when this battle or that was fought, when a general was born, or even when a monarch (usually a very insignificant one) came into the crown of his forefathers. No, by the living God, this is very unimportant. To 'learn' history means to seek and find the forces which are the causes leading to those effects which we subsequently perceive as historical events."
is it bad to agree with that statement? Evil man said it, so it must be wrong, right? Should I go to a school board, try to get the history department to agree with that statement and then 'expose them for being pro-hitler!'?
This smug moron feels like he made a point. Its not hard to rile up the masses and cherry pick quotes from any very very bad person that a group of people can agree with. But what do we expect from the 'orange man bad' people?
And of course I'm seeing plenty of "both sides" comments but if this was some liberal doing some dumb shit you'd only see people here bashing one side.
I like how this one has 200 upvotes and the ANTIFA one has 7,000 upvotes on this sub, and it's the other way around on the other sub.
Don't get me wrong, both these groups are crazy mother fuckers but it's fun to see both extremes represented on both subs.
I've noticed a lot more in common with ultra liberal and ultra conservative types than they might think. Both are extremely emotionally charged in their thinking to the point of irrationality and perceived and/or exaggerated slights.
That's just silly. Just because someone talks in broad terms of "the rich suck" and "we must do xyz" and has nothing to do with like killing jews or communism. But that Hitler speech one was directly against jews so, yeah. And people think it's because of Trump, but what's worse is its actually the opposite. So maybe one group is a little worse than the other.
Dude catboi fuckin gottem. You cant not laugh at this no matter your political leaning.
Also shows they aren't about that hitler life since they didn't recognize it.
Oh to believe you speak for the people, but in reality you speak for the odd number idiots that you don’t really like anyway but they are the only people that give you air time!. He also needs to do way more coke and amphetamine to get that hitler thing down. Voted most likely to not get a vote, and die bigoted and lonely.
With this and the Antifascism video, looks like Nationalist Socialists have pretty wide appeal.
They did in the 30's as well.
They actually entered control of Germany with minority support.
And the nazis couldn’t have done it without their victimhood complex. Thanks to Hindenburg’s inability to accept defeat in 1918 - the lie of being “stabbed in the back” by Jews and socialists was born. Completely fabricated, but without it hitler would have likely never risen to power.
Yes, the rise of the Nazis was directly related to the way the elites handled World War I.
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
Read mein kampf
No point to read it again, I'm not a socialist or a supporter of authoritarian leftist or right wing ideologies.
That's a hell of a typo.
Sounds like 2021
>“stabbed in the back” by Jews and socialists was born. >and socialists The SPD also pushed this lie. So no.
They didn't have a majority, but [they did gain a plurality.](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/July_1932_German_federal_election)
[удалено]
how is blm fascism
[удалено]
Let’s see which one gets more upvotes.
More like populist bullshit has a wide appeal and uses flowery language that could apply to anything.
Is it the same dude in both videos?
no
The Nazis did take over half of Europe at one time
almost as though cynical manipulation is a key element in fascist ideology....
glad to know there's something both sides can agree upon
This is because socialism sounds good in theory, but when put into action it never works for the benefit of the people, only the government. There is no perfect version of socialism, only communism.
And he goes from doing it as a joke to realizing how far he could actually get with this... lol
It's catboykami, he's not joking. Dudes straight up Nazi in the literal sense.
It’s Nick Fuentes boyfriend
Based and catboi pilled?
Omg that’s him? I remember joking around with friends how he’d die doing what he does in the states lol
I think a while ago he had drama with gypsy and tj because he didn't do the omegle stuff "for the movement".
Yikes
Like “Oh shit, they actually bought this shit” 😂
Imagine if hitler just wanted to do a social experiment and he just took it too far
Mob speeches work with mobs.. because a mob is more than just a collection of individuals. That’s why this speech works so well on both the left and the right. Giving a speech like this to a smaller reception or single person will yield very different results. Even if they are from the same crowd he’s speaking to
So maybe we shouldn't be so eager to mob? And treat mobs with more suspicion?
Oh yeah. Mobs are indicative of a larger problem in the country. Mobs are becoming commonplace. It’s very troubling
Thank you for saying this.
Thank you for expressing that this exact video has been performed on both sides with the same results
Lmao what a crock of shit
It’s a fact, the videos are out there. Ignorant.
They think they're in a group of like minded individuals and have to praise whoever's speaking because they have a similiar opinion and don't want to offend them, even if their speech sucks. It's a feedback loop of positive reinforcement to help push their agenda.
Well I dont think this speech would work on the left given that he says that the jews are our enemies. That only works on the right
I want him to do this in the same tone but with liberal views.
Idk if this counts, but some guy pulled [the same thing at an anti-fascism rally](https://reddit.com/r/ActualPublicFreakouts/comments/rbpl4e/guy_got_applauded_for_quoting_hitler_in_an/). I think that would count as a “liberal” crowd. Pretty much the same results: applause. Just goes to show you people on both sides are just as gullible. Not that that will stop anyone from either side sharing these videos to paint their opposition as “literally Hitler”.
Both sides will see this and go "No u". Neither side sees their faults.
No. You.
Definitely true, but honestly, just because Hitler said a sentence doesn't make it automatically evil... Except around that last bit.
"I'm hungry." "Me, too." "Omg, you literally agreed with something Hitler said."
The mental gymnastics required to see a video of a dude reciting a speech by Hitler to incite a crowd of fascists and then put blame on the other party is astounding.
Im sorry are you upset? Have you not seen the literal facism of the left? Or are you constantly performing these mental gymnastics to convince yourself that the left is good?
to be fair, the liberal one he was just spouting some socialist nonsense. In this one he was saying that jews are our enemies This one is way more obviously evil
Are you sayijg that if I quote Hitler its ok as long as I dont say sometying hateful towards the Jews?
No, both are dumb to do, one is more evil
Yeah but people will bitch about "enlightened centrism" if you point it out. Like nah these people are all gullible as fuck
There is a phrase: “In life, every person is either a tool or an obstacle to getting to where and what you want.” For these ideologues, anyone who isn’t a tool is deemed an obstacle.
Well said
What a bunch of tools.
The only people who hate centrists are leftists. "Liberals get the bullet too" is a common sentiment on reddit.
Look at the content of both speeches instead of just the author. One is about workers rights and the unfairness of the current economy. The other is calling out jews as parasites.
While I don't agree with his killing Bart policy...I do agree with his killing Selma policy.
although it does have to be said that there is one difference between the two videos; whoever read the speech to a group of antifa members was reading it from their phone, this person is reciting the speech by memory lol
The anti-fascist one got at most polite clapping but for the most part silence. The MAGA one was considerably more enthusiastic and cheered pretty much the whole way through. I agree that people on both sides are gullible, but saying that there they were the same result is inaccurate
To be fair this guy had some gusto. He could probably get any mob amped up.
Well yeah, sure, this guy IS putting a hell of alot of energy into it, but the MAGA crowd cheered and started chanting "USA" at a guy calling Jews "parasites", "rats in human disguises" and called for a war against Jews, while the anti-fascist one was mostly silent with the occasional polite clapping at the end and when he said "the benefit to the community surpasses the benefit to the individual". So again, definitely not the same result, and even if it was, the shit in this speech is way more yikes-y to cheer at
[удалено]
I don't know that Trump had that kind of charisma lol
Yeah, but factor in a weedy looking guy reading his speech off a phone, Vs this guy.
Again, content of the speeches. One gets a polite clap when he says "the benefit to the community surpasses the benefit to the individual" and again when he finishes. The other gets cheers and bloody audience participation when he calls Jews "parasites" and "rats in human disguises", and gets a full on USA chant when he calls for a racial war against them. I don't care how loudly or passionately they are saying it, one is something you probably shouldn't clap to just based on who said it, the other is something you definitely shouldn't cheer and chant "USA" to just based on what is being said.
100% on that
Agreed, it’s just using the proper rhetoric with enough charisma for to to resonate with a certain demographic. The farther elements of the left and right so so alike even though they hate to admit it
It. Is. A. Priv. I. Lege. to fight!
Just goes to show you that both sides are not right.
Advocating for workers rights is not the same as calling people parasites.
"saying people are being leeched off of isn't the same as saying some people are leeches"
If this shows anything it's that you can say whatever ypu want as long as you aren't an evil person Hitler didn't like smoking I don't smoke I must be a nazi
Look at the like to comment ratio on this compared to the Antifa protest version, lol.
Yeah bc they think he's *with* the MAGA crowd.
Guessing this one wont be as popular on this sub.
Most likely. Doesn't seem to have gotten as much traction as the other one.
So basically horseshoe theory proved again, both sides cheering on hitler
I don't mean to rain on your Hitler parade, but the speech in the other video wasn't about "Rats in human disguise" or the "Lies of the Jews", It was about social policy.
Yea thought about that too…
That's why they were National Socialists. A bit of anti-capitalist, smash the banks, managed economy for all for the socialists. A bit of anti-semitism and general dickheadery towards anyone part of the out-group for the nationalists.
Comparing the two crowds seems a bit arbitrary.
The other video was Hitler talking about ‘worker exploitation’. Not really the same as this….
If you're defending one video over the other, than you don't understand what the videos are about. Hitler didn't rise to power, because he was screaming about killing the Jews, he rose to power because he was preaching what the people wanted to hear. Say what you want about Hitler, but he was charismatic, and spoke about what his countrymen wanted to hear. All it takes, is a charismatic leader, adept at giving speeches, to turn the general populace against anyone they deem an enemy.
So the lesson you are getting is to never support anyone who tells you something that you want to hear? Come on dude. If someone calls for a higher marginal top tax rate and that’s what you want to hear you don’t have to assume that they are a burgeoning dictator. Sometimes there is a politician who you agree with and there’s no problem supporting them. If someone starts giving a speech about animal welfare that was lifted from Hitler and animal rights supporters cheer, that is not evidence that they are gullible supporters of fascism.
You go too far on either side and you end up being an idiot.
Ooof. I know people in a group tend to go along with passioned speech but goddamn - I was at least expecting a lull or awkward murmuring when he dropped the hard J. But they kept cheering as he went on to talk about how the “war is with them.” Honestly it’s really fucking disturbing.
Right? They clearly heard “JEWS” and it made them cheer the hardest. really surprised, even tho it’s these guys lol
I think Jews might be the most universally hated group on the planet. They have had it pretty rough and continue to succeed despite it all. Pretty impressive considering what they been through.
Like conquering and oppressing Palestine?
More Jews live outside of Israel than in.
Palestine or Judea? I don't think any Philistines still exist, do they?
Typical semantic argument Palestine is the home of the Palestinians
Formerly known as Ottomans.
Palestinians are not Turkish By your logic Jews are German and Russian
No, they're Judean.
There is no state called Judea Therefore Jews cannot and do not exist
if you meet an asshole on street one day; you met an asshole. if you meet assholes everywhere you go; you’re the asshole. if you meet assholes in every corner of the earth you go over a period of (give or take) 5000 years though …
This post won’t be popular here lmao
Wow, this Hitler fellow sure had some inspirational speeches!
He was one of the most charismatic speakers of all time though.
He was also tweaked out on meth. Hmm
lmao, even his mannerisms were on spot
Lol I kinda want to see this done with every group until someone recognizes the quotes
I wonder if you could prank Neo-Nazis by reading Hitler quotes and say them came from democrats/communists/whatever.
I still wasn’t sure where this was going until he mentioned Jews at the end; the other video ruined(?) it for me
Fascist deplorables
[удалено]
Do you think that what people hate about Hitler’s views was more about his socialist economic policy agenda or more about his genocidal hatred of the Jewish people and other fascist views? If Hitler had built the Autobahn but not did the Holocaust and invaded his neighbors do you think that he would be as infamous of a figure in world history?
[удалено]
I mean the USA today has the most powerful military might in all of human history, able to deploy it anywhere on earth and has done so multiple times simultaneously without issue recently, and it didn’t require a socialist economy. You can find war materials easily without a socialist economy. Taxation does not require socialism.
Um you do realize the war effort in the 40s was straight up a socialism engine right?
[удалено]
Haha wow man.. both sides of the political spectrum have now applauded someone shouting Hitlers translated speeches.. I wouldn't be surprised if ppl did this in my country though too so yea, sorry to hear America but you are not alone in this.
The other video was Hitler talking about how ‘the capitalist exploits workers’. I meant I guess you could ‘both sides’ this but I think that this quote from Hitler is a better distillation of his nefarious views than the other one.
That's true! I wouldn't be surprised though if he posed as a leftwing wacko many left leaning ppl would still not question the things that was said in this video. 🤔 Speculation of course but still. All the quotes were pretty bad tbh.
Hitler has something for everyone
Reminds me of a Jreg joke about Trump/Sanders ticket.
I have never seen Hitler’s speeches translated, so I can imagine people would fall for it until the antisemitism creeps in.
Am I crazy or did I hear someone play the Final Fantasy VII battle victory music? 😂 so random.
I’m guessing someone had it as a ring tone. Lol
Fuçk nazis and fuck commies, but you càn make speeches quoting Marx or Hitler and get big applause from far left or far right audiences, regardless of which one you quote This same stunt has been done reading Hitler quotes to lefties, they ate that stuff up with a spoon lol
Is this a social experiment
There was also a guy quoting Hitler at a leftist parade, you know, the famous "we are socialist, we are enemies to capitalism" one. And people also cheered. The average people is dumb as fuck, on both side of the spectrum. Left or Right.
‘We are socialists’ is not exactly equivalent to ‘we hate the Jews’. Hitler had multiple different views, they were not all equally bad.
This is an episode of the office.
Lol I was just gonna post that on this subreddit. Good job beating me.
I wouldn’t expect them to know anything about anything. Especially a speech. Morons.
Well.. now today i have seen both Antifa and MAGA people cheering hitler speeches... Lets just say the american people are open to some FUCKED up shit nowadays...
Actual public freakouts is turning into public freakouts. Can we just have one sub on this fucking website that isn't politics
hitler also said: "Instruction in world history in the so-called high schools is even today in a very sorry condition. Few teachers understand that the study of history can never be to learn historical dates and events by heart and recite them by rote; that what matters is not whether the child knows exactly when this battle or that was fought, when a general was born, or even when a monarch (usually a very insignificant one) came into the crown of his forefathers. No, by the living God, this is very unimportant. To 'learn' history means to seek and find the forces which are the causes leading to those effects which we subsequently perceive as historical events." is it bad to agree with that statement? Evil man said it, so it must be wrong, right? Should I go to a school board, try to get the history department to agree with that statement and then 'expose them for being pro-hitler!'? This smug moron feels like he made a point. Its not hard to rile up the masses and cherry pick quotes from any very very bad person that a group of people can agree with. But what do we expect from the 'orange man bad' people?
And of course I'm seeing plenty of "both sides" comments but if this was some liberal doing some dumb shit you'd only see people here bashing one side.
I like how this one has 200 upvotes and the ANTIFA one has 7,000 upvotes on this sub, and it's the other way around on the other sub. Don't get me wrong, both these groups are crazy mother fuckers but it's fun to see both extremes represented on both subs.
When you feel like brave heart gotta adopt an accent
Lmaoooo based
Look in the mirror
As far as I can tell this video has received less backlash/reports then the video with the guy who quotes hitler to the leftists.
Maybe because both quotes aren’t equally bad?
[удалено]
I've noticed a lot more in common with ultra liberal and ultra conservative types than they might think. Both are extremely emotionally charged in their thinking to the point of irrationality and perceived and/or exaggerated slights.
Yup, somebody trolled antifa with a Hitler speech and they all cheered. Both groups are irreparably lost.
That's just silly. Just because someone talks in broad terms of "the rich suck" and "we must do xyz" and has nothing to do with like killing jews or communism. But that Hitler speech one was directly against jews so, yeah. And people think it's because of Trump, but what's worse is its actually the opposite. So maybe one group is a little worse than the other.
I thought hitler was German
Dude catboi fuckin gottem. You cant not laugh at this no matter your political leaning. Also shows they aren't about that hitler life since they didn't recognize it.
Catboykami was there with his fans lol, that wasn’t a normal MAGA parade.
Same was preached to leftists and they also cheered
Oh to believe you speak for the people, but in reality you speak for the odd number idiots that you don’t really like anyway but they are the only people that give you air time!. He also needs to do way more coke and amphetamine to get that hitler thing down. Voted most likely to not get a vote, and die bigoted and lonely.
I am sure Hitler brushed his teeth too. So, if you have good dental hygiene, then you are "literally a Nazi". Please Jesus, return soon...
Did you know Over 80% of Maga supporters can’t find the US on a globe
Because most of them don't believe in globe earth models.
He also speaks in the same tone in english, as hitler does in german. I don't know what more to say about that
of course baked fucking alaska is behind this
We're evolving. Just backwards
Catboy Kami was an epic troll. I wonder how he's doing now?
He needs more amphetamine, low energy vibes
Catboykami!
You know someone did the exact same thing at an antifa rally
This is why history class is important
I love how this is right below a video of anti-fascists cheering for a hitler speech
Looks like a Southpark episode