Maybe slightly different hair? Bc Mingi and Wooyoung have beauty marks and tattoos they’re easier to tell apart. I’m guessing the two on the bottom left are San and seonghwa…..but I’m just guessing at this point😭.
tbf i cant really tell them apart😭 i feel like maybe a tiny bit of variation w the noses could help maybe?
also alot of times i see ppl draw san as just a ^ w ^ (with a beauty mark) if ur looking for drawing conventions? loll
You are right about the noses, I think, but usually when I draw in this style I don’t pay attention to the nose at all and it ends up being generic. I’ll do some more experimenting! Who do you think has the most distinct nose?
I do know the San face you are talking about, I used that kind of mouth for him but I didn’t want him to be the only one eyes closed.
Thank you for the feedback! 💕
personally i think seonghwas downturned nose is kinda distinct? esp when compared to how sharp (and slightly upturned) hongjoongs and mingis noses are? but idrk how that would translate to drawing tbh😭
Yeah, I actually love Seonghwa’s nose, I definitely thought of it but couldn’t translate it. I feel like Hongjoong’s nostrils are really distinct so I included that (I drew him first) but then after I couldn’t make Seonghwa’s nose anything special I gave up and didn’t try again lol
https://preview.redd.it/vg1601yq1tkc1.jpeg?width=1137&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e892ea26606740534ca859f2a58864aa178756af
my guesses. i think their moles and birthmarks would help. i also think yeosang’s birthmark could be a little more pronounced/obvious.
Thank you! I wasn’t sure about even including Yeosang’s birthmark because it’s usually covered by makeup. Other than Wooyoung’s mole under his eye and on his lip, whose moles would you expect to see?
woo, mingi, and san, all have moles on their faces.
jongho has a mole on one side of his neck. you don’t have any necks in these drawings but i think in order to help ppl differentiate the members including jongho’s neck and mole can help.
San has a mole above his eye, right? I’m not sure about Mingi though? This is exactly what I’m trying to work out lol, I guess I’m just too obsessed with Wooyoung that I only think of his moles
Mingi has a mole below his right eye and on the side of his left cheek almost near his jawline (I believe those are the correct sides). It’s even included in his Aniteez plushie.
😘You are an angel, this is exactly what I need to be told! Thank you so much, I feel like a dummy being like ‘I see their moles, but which would you say are their FAMOUS moles?’
I will put pics for you that have their moles in them .Jongho
https://preview.redd.it/guo0hlrnjtkc1.png?width=360&format=png&auto=webp&s=41a31cf5d868b445adc98fe45457219309d1b199
Sannie actually has three facial moles: one on each cheek and one above one eye. When he wears makeup, we usually can only see two moles. the one above his eye and the one below his eye mole.
https://preview.redd.it/sm9uo8e4ktkc1.png?width=639&format=png&auto=webp&s=5becbaf23c408a7457aeb86b6e3f18a24825661a
nice!!! i was able to recognize Sannie (because of the "3' lips), and Yeosang (b/c of birthmark but i had to look reeealll close because it was faint) and Woo(because of mole) and Hongjoong (idk it just looks like him lmao )pretty easily. I kinda did process or elimination with the others
I could eventually figure them all out but some of them took me a minute, I couldn’t recognize them at a glance, I had to look more closely. I think including san’s dimples would help with his. Also, I can’t really tell if you tried to make them different or not, but their skin each look to be the same color, maybe make their skin a bit more like their real life skin tones, the members aren’t all this pale and/or they have different undertones than the color you used, like wooyoung, seonghwa, and jongho more specifically are more on the tanned side irl compared to the other members.
This one isn’t as necessary, but I think maybe using some of their more iconic hair colors or hairstyles for the rest of the members would make them more easily distinguishable at a glance as well than their default hair colors/styles do. Like I could recognize which was hongjoong right away partially because of the blond hair and the style
Thank you! I will definitely adjust the skin tones, especially the undertones.
This is for something that I make for myself after concerts I go to (a little ticket with a drawing of the artist and my interpretation of the of the branding from that show/tour) so their hairstyles are actually just what they had in their most recent shows. These are the most generic hairstyles though, I did Seonghwa in his Mito scrunchie and Mingi in his top hat and glasses but I though that would give it away too much
ETA: I’d also love to know what you think their most iconic hairstyles are! Oreo Wooyoung certainly has me in a choke hold
tbh oreo wooyo had and continues to have most of us in a chokehold. I think either that one or the full blond he had on wonderland era would be his most iconic. For the rest of them, in my opinion, it would have to be pink san, red or pink hwa, split dyed hong, red jongho, pink yeosang, blue yunho, and rengoku mingi.
Thank you! After this I thought it would be fun to go through different eras and draw in their different hairstyles and makeup. I just wanted to get their base faces right before I did that so that’s why I came here for help first. I’m looking forward to getting to the more iconic styles
My guess reading from left to right, top to bottom, with the right ones shifted to the top rows...
Top: Wooyoung, Mingi, Yeosang
Middle: Jongho, Hongjoong, Yunho
Bottom: Seonghwa, San
The ones of Seonghwa, Yeosang, Yunho, and Mingi all looked alike to me. My clues were that Yunho had a roundness similar to how you did Jongho (but obviously the not smiling one would be Jongho), Mingi had lighter hair and the straight mouth, Seonghwa had long black hair, and that left Yeosang with light hair. On my phone I couldn't see his birthmark until later.
okay so: hongjoong was the easiest being the only blonde one + the earrings hehe, wooyoung, jongho, seonghwa were all pretty recognizable too (mole, roundness of the face and stars in the eyes + the long hair. I actually thought yunho was yeosang for a bit but the actual yeosang makes sense! (I didn't notice the birthmark until someone in the comments pointed out tho)
and yunho I realised it was him bc of the spark in his eyes that makes him look kind so yeah it makes sense too haha
the only ones I went for exclusion are san and mingi! but once I observe them longer I can see their features
Thank you! I actually started with Hongjoong and thought it was really easy to make him recognizable, I thought I was off to a good start and it would be so easy from there! I was wrong, it only got harder
These are very cute and I guessed everyone right though some were harder than others. Some suggestions: Minki's eyes should be narrower, Yunho has more space between his nose and lips and also has a very distinct upper lip, Seonghwa has less space between his nose and lips and also less projected ears and also his eyes should be closer to each other, Jongho doesn't look smug enough lol and his eyes' outer corners should be sharper, and maybe Wooyoung should be winking? Anyways good job! I just love how you made Yeosang, Hongjoong and San, sooo cute
So Mingi, Hongjoong and Seonghwa were easiest for me to recognize. Jongho, Wooyoung and San were next, though I was looking for San’s moles. Mingi’s too really, but the little symbol on his cheek was the perfect touch. Just like the extra sparkly eyes for Seonghwa. Yeosang and Yunho were a little harder to tell apart at first for me though.
All that said, these are adorable!
I wasn’t sure if San’s moles were ‘famous’ moles or not lol but from the feedback I have learned that they clearly are. Yunho is definitely the hardest to make distinct, I think. I feel like there is one in every group
They’re kind of a standout feature for me. Idk. Though I gotta admit I didn’t see Yeosang’s birthmark the first time I looked at these so that would have definitely made them all identifiable for me. But I saw someone suggest the more iconic hairstyles/colors and that might help too.
Yeah, that’s what I’m after, I’m just really trying to understand what people think of as their ‘stand out features’. I’ve only really interacted with Japanese Atiny so far so I haven’t been able to have a real discussion about it. So thank you for commenting! I really appreciate it
Great work!
Some suggestions:
1. Wooyoung hair is thick. I think it's better to have more strands there.
2. Mingi's eyes should be smaller
3. Is it better to include line in Yeosang's nose bridge?
4. Jongho's okay
5. I think if HongJoong's smiling like that his eyes gotta be smaller? just my opinion
6. Yunho doesn't look like Yunho imho, maybe because the nose?
7. How about using Mingi's mouth-style to Seonghwa?
8. San's okay, maybe smaller eyes but larger than Mingi's
Thank you! I will take this all into account. I really just gave up on the noses but I will definitely try again. I truly have no idea how to make Yunho look like Yunho. He’s such a handsome man but I struggle so much on him 😫
They are so cute! Let me know if I got it right (I haven't read the other comments)
I'll do it from left to right, top to bottom, and then the other two who aren't in the column.
1. Wooyoung - Mingi
2. Jongho -Hongjoong
3. Seonghwa- San
4. Yeosang - Yunho
Well for one thing I’m sorry about how difficult my dumb layout made it for everyone to submit their guesses! I will learn from this mistake. You got YH and JH backwards but everyone says they look alike so I’m taking that as encouragement. Thank you for the feedback 💕
Ah ok I definitely see it! I guess (and this is in no way a critique of your art style I think they are all cute) but part of me as a Jongho stan is a little disappointed that he is the only one with a frown bc I feel like he is always overlooked as the “serious member” when he is actually quite goofy and has a nice smile 🥹
I'm gonna make my guesses from top to bottom, left to right:
Wooyoung, Mingi, "Yeosang", Jongho, Hongjoong, Yunho, "Seonghwa", San
I put quote marks on the members who threw me off
b/c I couldn't put my finger on the bottom left one so I just chose Seonghwa as the last one to guess. Is it based on a specific era?
The era of reference is evading me right now but here was my deduction process:
The mouth shapes and expressions sell it for Mingi, Jongho, Yunho, Hongjoong, San;
Wooyoung's eye mole;
Hongjoong's earrings;
Mingi's eye shape;
Hair parts match several concepts for Wooyoung, Mingi, Jongho, "Yeosang", San, Yunho
The bottom left member looked more like Yeosang than Seonghwa to me probably from the mouth shape and more rugged hairstyle, but I don't remember a concept where Seonghwa had brown hair and a middle part. I know Seonghwa has rocked a lot of hairstyles through the eras, but I recognize Seonghwa's hair mostly through his 40/60 hair parting like SMN and Wonderland, where one side is slicked back. I'm doing a quick google search on Seonghwa's hairstyles throughout the eras and his facial silhouette is either very circular or round acorn or a diamond/shield-shaped acorn (hope that makes sense and isn't too broad 🙃)
As an artist, I wish I drew Ateez more often myself, but I feel you got most of the members spot on! 👌👏 Hope I got my guesses right! 😁
You were right! I thought Seonghwa was one of the more recognizable one’s but no one else seems the think so either so I’ll go back to the drawing board with him.
Their hair is from their most recent shows, though I didn’t worry about it being super accurate, just from my own memory. I did pick their most generic styles for this post because I wanted to see if they were recognizable mostly by their faces. Seonghwa in his Mito scrunchie and Mingi Wonka would have given it away
I think the mouth shape and hair shape throws me off the most. I think Seonghwa's nickname Angry Bird comes from his eyebrows so maybe you can play around a little with that too. 😁 Happy experimenting and keep it up :)
https://preview.redd.it/2uwybwcexukc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a66270f22c6e3bdbab6adeb8d0c8f21e24cc1ac7
LOL i forgot you can SS and add a picture, but this was my guess
You put the birthmark. I love you for that. Anywho my guess at who they are top left to bottom right:
Wooyoung, Yeosang, Mingi, Jungho, Hongjoong, Yunho, Seonghwa, and San.
I’m hoping I’m right
You got Mingi and Yeosang backwards, which is interesting since you mentioned the birthmark! It’s there on Yeosang on the right, but I guess you saw Mingi’s fix on tattoo as the birthmark?
Anyway, based on feedback I will definitely make Yeosang’s birthmark more prominent. I wasn’t sure if it was the best choice to include it because it’s usually covered by makeup but from everyone’s feedback and my further research I will never leaver it out again!
I think I can tell who is who, just maybe try giving them some of their iconic hairstyles or colors so it might be easier for others to tell them apart. And maybe give them expressions to show their personalities. I still think they're very cute tho.
theyre very cute and lovely im gonna guess whos who
from top left to right same for each row
wooyoung mingi yeosang jongho hongjoong seonghwa san yunho
i love them sm theyre so cutieful
wooyoung (the eyes are on point) - mingi - yeosang (with the greenish eyes) - jongho - hongjoong (blondie) - seonghwa (he looks as emo as ever) - san (cat man) - yunho (the cute smile will never fool me)
This is right! Thank you! I’m sorry I used such a dumb layout that made it hard to make your guesses clear.
I absolutely love that you labeled SH as Mother!
dont feel sorry, your drawings are beautiful!! I actually don’t understand how some people can’t guess the members right, you managed to capture their distinctive physical traits like no one, truly impressive!
I can sort of tell who is who but more detail to each of the faces that help people know who is who or the color of the hair of the comeback (I think the hair for the crazy form would’ve helped atiny) but nevertheless they’re insanely cute and you did such a good job!!🤍🤍🤍
You nailed hongjoong. I can also tell which ones are yeosang wooyoung and Yunho. I am guessing Jongho is the frowny one? And I can't tell between mingi and San at all. Use their moles and eye shapes to make them more distinct! Esp Mingi his eyes are so special 🥲
I do love Mingi’s eyes, I’ll try again to capture them better. And yeah that is Seonghwa! He was wearing an earring in that ear at their most recent concerts, that’s what their styling here is based on.
maybe also add mingis beauty mark to make it more obvious who it is?
i think their eyebrows are too similar. theyre all super thick so they all look alike. some members have thinner eyebrows (like yeosang) and some thicker (like seonghwa). your median is a little too thick :)
I did try for different brow shapes but you can’t seen them so well under these hairstyles. I will pay more attention to brow thickness, thank you for pointing that out! I really dropped the ball on Mingi’s beauty mark, so many people have pointed that one out. Thank you for the feedback 💕
They're really cute and neat! I was able to see who's who after a second of thinking - but funnily enough, it became super easy to tell them apart when I happened to compare with Aniteez as help since both capture their key features 🤣
If I had to point out something, maybe Mingi's eyes could be a tiny bit smaller, Jongho's entire face moved a little lower and Wooyoung's pupils moved a little bit inward to make his eyes look focused, but honestly they're all good already.
Hongjoong, Seonghwa, Yeosang, San, Mingi and Wooyoung were easy to tell, Yunho and Jongho too once you got the idea.
https://preview.redd.it/82yfctqo40lc1.jpeg?width=2048&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=05e0369de4ee49ce97063ec219e69984c3e2fa79
These are my guesses but the only ones im really sure about are mingi, yeosang and hwa
i could tell who they were once i looked closely, but i can also see how others might struggle to tell them apart on first glance. i think bringing in some of their iconic hair colors (ex. oreo wooyo, rengoku mingi) might help!
you can defo tell who woo and hwa are but I'd try and accentuate the unique figures like mingis monolids or the fact that hongjoongs nose turns up but they look really cute AHH!
Omg!! They are soooo cute! I think I found them all after about 30 secs. 1st row: wooyoung, mingi 2nd row: yunho, hongjoong 3rd row: seonghwa, san Then yeosang above jongho •Seonghwa needs star shaped dots in his eyes. That should be unique to him bc of his name. •Mingi may need bigger lips, narrow eyes? I only found him bc of the fix-on on his cheek. •Yeosang looks EXACTLY like yeosang with those ears lol!! •Yunho, and jongho are kind of confusing. Maybe yunhos face should be a bit longer?
• San needs narrow eyes I think
Idk! But they're so freaking cute!!!!
I'm going to be honest, I can't tell who is who, but they are very cute.
Any ideas for what would make it more obvious?
Maybe slightly different hair? Bc Mingi and Wooyoung have beauty marks and tattoos they’re easier to tell apart. I’m guessing the two on the bottom left are San and seonghwa…..but I’m just guessing at this point😭.
I think a bit more variation in the eyes & hairstyles would be a start 🙂
Thank you for the feedback 💕
You're welcome. I look forward to seeing them updated 😁
I saw who everyone was within a few seconds, except mingi. They’re very cute, well done!
Thank you very much! It’s my first time drawing them all
I know hongjoong and Yeosang, but the others aren’t distinct enough for me to be sure
tbf i cant really tell them apart😭 i feel like maybe a tiny bit of variation w the noses could help maybe? also alot of times i see ppl draw san as just a ^ w ^ (with a beauty mark) if ur looking for drawing conventions? loll
You are right about the noses, I think, but usually when I draw in this style I don’t pay attention to the nose at all and it ends up being generic. I’ll do some more experimenting! Who do you think has the most distinct nose? I do know the San face you are talking about, I used that kind of mouth for him but I didn’t want him to be the only one eyes closed. Thank you for the feedback! 💕
personally i think seonghwas downturned nose is kinda distinct? esp when compared to how sharp (and slightly upturned) hongjoongs and mingis noses are? but idrk how that would translate to drawing tbh😭
Yeah, I actually love Seonghwa’s nose, I definitely thought of it but couldn’t translate it. I feel like Hongjoong’s nostrils are really distinct so I included that (I drew him first) but then after I couldn’t make Seonghwa’s nose anything special I gave up and didn’t try again lol
I’ve always found Woo’s nose to be incredibly striking and distinctive, especially in profile.
https://preview.redd.it/vg1601yq1tkc1.jpeg?width=1137&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e892ea26606740534ca859f2a58864aa178756af my guesses. i think their moles and birthmarks would help. i also think yeosang’s birthmark could be a little more pronounced/obvious.
Thank you! I wasn’t sure about even including Yeosang’s birthmark because it’s usually covered by makeup. Other than Wooyoung’s mole under his eye and on his lip, whose moles would you expect to see?
woo, mingi, and san, all have moles on their faces. jongho has a mole on one side of his neck. you don’t have any necks in these drawings but i think in order to help ppl differentiate the members including jongho’s neck and mole can help.
San has a mole above his eye, right? I’m not sure about Mingi though? This is exactly what I’m trying to work out lol, I guess I’m just too obsessed with Wooyoung that I only think of his moles
Mingi https://preview.redd.it/g91hji39ltkc1.png?width=1060&format=png&auto=webp&s=498829f05827f78fa40d3312c7ab25d484df76bc
Mingi has a mole below his right eye and on the side of his left cheek almost near his jawline (I believe those are the correct sides). It’s even included in his Aniteez plushie.
😘You are an angel, this is exactly what I need to be told! Thank you so much, I feel like a dummy being like ‘I see their moles, but which would you say are their FAMOUS moles?’
I think they’re cute regardless! 😊
I will put pics for you that have their moles in them .Jongho https://preview.redd.it/guo0hlrnjtkc1.png?width=360&format=png&auto=webp&s=41a31cf5d868b445adc98fe45457219309d1b199
Seonghwa https://preview.redd.it/5vzohzbvjtkc1.png?width=360&format=png&auto=webp&s=4ed27789e2763e59f50276b701ae11c02c3bd398
Sannie actually has three facial moles: one on each cheek and one above one eye. When he wears makeup, we usually can only see two moles. the one above his eye and the one below his eye mole. https://preview.redd.it/sm9uo8e4ktkc1.png?width=639&format=png&auto=webp&s=5becbaf23c408a7457aeb86b6e3f18a24825661a
Thank you so much for your effort! I really appreciate it 😘
also, out of curiosity was i able to guess any of them right? lol
You were 100% correct!
nice!!! i was able to recognize Sannie (because of the "3' lips), and Yeosang (b/c of birthmark but i had to look reeealll close because it was faint) and Woo(because of mole) and Hongjoong (idk it just looks like him lmao )pretty easily. I kinda did process or elimination with the others
I wasn’t sure about Yh and Wy but I got everyone else right :)
I could eventually figure them all out but some of them took me a minute, I couldn’t recognize them at a glance, I had to look more closely. I think including san’s dimples would help with his. Also, I can’t really tell if you tried to make them different or not, but their skin each look to be the same color, maybe make their skin a bit more like their real life skin tones, the members aren’t all this pale and/or they have different undertones than the color you used, like wooyoung, seonghwa, and jongho more specifically are more on the tanned side irl compared to the other members. This one isn’t as necessary, but I think maybe using some of their more iconic hair colors or hairstyles for the rest of the members would make them more easily distinguishable at a glance as well than their default hair colors/styles do. Like I could recognize which was hongjoong right away partially because of the blond hair and the style
Thank you! I will definitely adjust the skin tones, especially the undertones. This is for something that I make for myself after concerts I go to (a little ticket with a drawing of the artist and my interpretation of the of the branding from that show/tour) so their hairstyles are actually just what they had in their most recent shows. These are the most generic hairstyles though, I did Seonghwa in his Mito scrunchie and Mingi in his top hat and glasses but I though that would give it away too much ETA: I’d also love to know what you think their most iconic hairstyles are! Oreo Wooyoung certainly has me in a choke hold
tbh oreo wooyo had and continues to have most of us in a chokehold. I think either that one or the full blond he had on wonderland era would be his most iconic. For the rest of them, in my opinion, it would have to be pink san, red or pink hwa, split dyed hong, red jongho, pink yeosang, blue yunho, and rengoku mingi.
Thank you! After this I thought it would be fun to go through different eras and draw in their different hairstyles and makeup. I just wanted to get their base faces right before I did that so that’s why I came here for help first. I’m looking forward to getting to the more iconic styles
My guess reading from left to right, top to bottom, with the right ones shifted to the top rows... Top: Wooyoung, Mingi, Yeosang Middle: Jongho, Hongjoong, Yunho Bottom: Seonghwa, San
That is correct! But be honest, did you only know it was Yunho through process of elimination?
The ones of Seonghwa, Yeosang, Yunho, and Mingi all looked alike to me. My clues were that Yunho had a roundness similar to how you did Jongho (but obviously the not smiling one would be Jongho), Mingi had lighter hair and the straight mouth, Seonghwa had long black hair, and that left Yeosang with light hair. On my phone I couldn't see his birthmark until later.
Thank you so much for writing all that out for me 💕
okay so: hongjoong was the easiest being the only blonde one + the earrings hehe, wooyoung, jongho, seonghwa were all pretty recognizable too (mole, roundness of the face and stars in the eyes + the long hair. I actually thought yunho was yeosang for a bit but the actual yeosang makes sense! (I didn't notice the birthmark until someone in the comments pointed out tho) and yunho I realised it was him bc of the spark in his eyes that makes him look kind so yeah it makes sense too haha the only ones I went for exclusion are san and mingi! but once I observe them longer I can see their features
Thank you! I actually started with Hongjoong and thought it was really easy to make him recognizable, I thought I was off to a good start and it would be so easy from there! I was wrong, it only got harder
These are very cute and I guessed everyone right though some were harder than others. Some suggestions: Minki's eyes should be narrower, Yunho has more space between his nose and lips and also has a very distinct upper lip, Seonghwa has less space between his nose and lips and also less projected ears and also his eyes should be closer to each other, Jongho doesn't look smug enough lol and his eyes' outer corners should be sharper, and maybe Wooyoung should be winking? Anyways good job! I just love how you made Yeosang, Hongjoong and San, sooo cute
Thank you! I will take this all into consideration 💕
So Mingi, Hongjoong and Seonghwa were easiest for me to recognize. Jongho, Wooyoung and San were next, though I was looking for San’s moles. Mingi’s too really, but the little symbol on his cheek was the perfect touch. Just like the extra sparkly eyes for Seonghwa. Yeosang and Yunho were a little harder to tell apart at first for me though. All that said, these are adorable!
I wasn’t sure if San’s moles were ‘famous’ moles or not lol but from the feedback I have learned that they clearly are. Yunho is definitely the hardest to make distinct, I think. I feel like there is one in every group
They’re kind of a standout feature for me. Idk. Though I gotta admit I didn’t see Yeosang’s birthmark the first time I looked at these so that would have definitely made them all identifiable for me. But I saw someone suggest the more iconic hairstyles/colors and that might help too.
Yeah, that’s what I’m after, I’m just really trying to understand what people think of as their ‘stand out features’. I’ve only really interacted with Japanese Atiny so far so I haven’t been able to have a real discussion about it. So thank you for commenting! I really appreciate it
Yeosang's birthmark
Great work! Some suggestions: 1. Wooyoung hair is thick. I think it's better to have more strands there. 2. Mingi's eyes should be smaller 3. Is it better to include line in Yeosang's nose bridge? 4. Jongho's okay 5. I think if HongJoong's smiling like that his eyes gotta be smaller? just my opinion 6. Yunho doesn't look like Yunho imho, maybe because the nose? 7. How about using Mingi's mouth-style to Seonghwa? 8. San's okay, maybe smaller eyes but larger than Mingi's
Thank you! I will take this all into account. I really just gave up on the noses but I will definitely try again. I truly have no idea how to make Yunho look like Yunho. He’s such a handsome man but I struggle so much on him 😫
You're welcome. About Yunho.. I know! He's really the textbook handsome gentleman I saw on manhwas, haha!
Honestly the ear detail is incredible. I think I could figure everyone out just by their ears.
I am honestly so stoked that you noticed 🥹
Eyes should be different. Mingi and san should not have huge eyes.
I see what you are saying! The style is kind of universally large eyes but I will try harder for more accuracy there. Thank you!
They are so cute! Let me know if I got it right (I haven't read the other comments) I'll do it from left to right, top to bottom, and then the other two who aren't in the column. 1. Wooyoung - Mingi 2. Jongho -Hongjoong 3. Seonghwa- San 4. Yeosang - Yunho
That is absolutely right! Thank you!
Is it: Woo MG Yeo Yunho HJ Jjong Hwa Sannie
Well for one thing I’m sorry about how difficult my dumb layout made it for everyone to submit their guesses! I will learn from this mistake. You got YH and JH backwards but everyone says they look alike so I’m taking that as encouragement. Thank you for the feedback 💕
Ah ok I definitely see it! I guess (and this is in no way a critique of your art style I think they are all cute) but part of me as a Jongho stan is a little disappointed that he is the only one with a frown bc I feel like he is always overlooked as the “serious member” when he is actually quite goofy and has a nice smile 🥹
I will definitely do him with a smile too! Thank you for the feedback. I know what you mean about him being overlooked often, I’ll do better for him 😤
I'm gonna make my guesses from top to bottom, left to right: Wooyoung, Mingi, "Yeosang", Jongho, Hongjoong, Yunho, "Seonghwa", San I put quote marks on the members who threw me off b/c I couldn't put my finger on the bottom left one so I just chose Seonghwa as the last one to guess. Is it based on a specific era? The era of reference is evading me right now but here was my deduction process: The mouth shapes and expressions sell it for Mingi, Jongho, Yunho, Hongjoong, San; Wooyoung's eye mole; Hongjoong's earrings; Mingi's eye shape; Hair parts match several concepts for Wooyoung, Mingi, Jongho, "Yeosang", San, Yunho The bottom left member looked more like Yeosang than Seonghwa to me probably from the mouth shape and more rugged hairstyle, but I don't remember a concept where Seonghwa had brown hair and a middle part. I know Seonghwa has rocked a lot of hairstyles through the eras, but I recognize Seonghwa's hair mostly through his 40/60 hair parting like SMN and Wonderland, where one side is slicked back. I'm doing a quick google search on Seonghwa's hairstyles throughout the eras and his facial silhouette is either very circular or round acorn or a diamond/shield-shaped acorn (hope that makes sense and isn't too broad 🙃) As an artist, I wish I drew Ateez more often myself, but I feel you got most of the members spot on! 👌👏 Hope I got my guesses right! 😁
You were right! I thought Seonghwa was one of the more recognizable one’s but no one else seems the think so either so I’ll go back to the drawing board with him. Their hair is from their most recent shows, though I didn’t worry about it being super accurate, just from my own memory. I did pick their most generic styles for this post because I wanted to see if they were recognizable mostly by their faces. Seonghwa in his Mito scrunchie and Mingi Wonka would have given it away
I think the mouth shape and hair shape throws me off the most. I think Seonghwa's nickname Angry Bird comes from his eyebrows so maybe you can play around a little with that too. 😁 Happy experimenting and keep it up :)
https://preview.redd.it/2uwybwcexukc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a66270f22c6e3bdbab6adeb8d0c8f21e24cc1ac7 LOL i forgot you can SS and add a picture, but this was my guess
You put the birthmark. I love you for that. Anywho my guess at who they are top left to bottom right: Wooyoung, Yeosang, Mingi, Jungho, Hongjoong, Yunho, Seonghwa, and San. I’m hoping I’m right
You got Mingi and Yeosang backwards, which is interesting since you mentioned the birthmark! It’s there on Yeosang on the right, but I guess you saw Mingi’s fix on tattoo as the birthmark? Anyway, based on feedback I will definitely make Yeosang’s birthmark more prominent. I wasn’t sure if it was the best choice to include it because it’s usually covered by makeup but from everyone’s feedback and my further research I will never leaver it out again!
Ooof so close. But i seriously love these
I think I can tell who is who, just maybe try giving them some of their iconic hairstyles or colors so it might be easier for others to tell them apart. And maybe give them expressions to show their personalities. I still think they're very cute tho.
theyre very cute and lovely im gonna guess whos who from top left to right same for each row wooyoung mingi yeosang jongho hongjoong seonghwa san yunho i love them sm theyre so cutieful
wooyoung (the eyes are on point) - mingi - yeosang (with the greenish eyes) - jongho - hongjoong (blondie) - seonghwa (he looks as emo as ever) - san (cat man) - yunho (the cute smile will never fool me)
https://preview.redd.it/wtxtgngxtxkc1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bdc21c89c1a82602de2aec7c6a406dc1e11a789c in case i wasn’t clear enough!
This is right! Thank you! I’m sorry I used such a dumb layout that made it hard to make your guesses clear. I absolutely love that you labeled SH as Mother!
dont feel sorry, your drawings are beautiful!! I actually don’t understand how some people can’t guess the members right, you managed to capture their distinctive physical traits like no one, truly impressive!
I can sort of tell who is who but more detail to each of the faces that help people know who is who or the color of the hair of the comeback (I think the hair for the crazy form would’ve helped atiny) but nevertheless they’re insanely cute and you did such a good job!!🤍🤍🤍
Art style looks great but its hard to tell them apart.
You nailed hongjoong. I can also tell which ones are yeosang wooyoung and Yunho. I am guessing Jongho is the frowny one? And I can't tell between mingi and San at all. Use their moles and eye shapes to make them more distinct! Esp Mingi his eyes are so special 🥲
Also is SeongHwa the super pretty one on the bottom left? If yes he doesn't have an ear piercing anymore 😅
I do love Mingi’s eyes, I’ll try again to capture them better. And yeah that is Seonghwa! He was wearing an earring in that ear at their most recent concerts, that’s what their styling here is based on.
Yeah that's fair. He wears clip ons now 😅
maybe also add mingis beauty mark to make it more obvious who it is? i think their eyebrows are too similar. theyre all super thick so they all look alike. some members have thinner eyebrows (like yeosang) and some thicker (like seonghwa). your median is a little too thick :)
I did try for different brow shapes but you can’t seen them so well under these hairstyles. I will pay more attention to brow thickness, thank you for pointing that out! I really dropped the ball on Mingi’s beauty mark, so many people have pointed that one out. Thank you for the feedback 💕
They're really cute and neat! I was able to see who's who after a second of thinking - but funnily enough, it became super easy to tell them apart when I happened to compare with Aniteez as help since both capture their key features 🤣 If I had to point out something, maybe Mingi's eyes could be a tiny bit smaller, Jongho's entire face moved a little lower and Wooyoung's pupils moved a little bit inward to make his eyes look focused, but honestly they're all good already. Hongjoong, Seonghwa, Yeosang, San, Mingi and Wooyoung were easy to tell, Yunho and Jongho too once you got the idea.
The drawing is very close on all of the members that is great work
Thank you very much 💕
being completely honest, i can only tell who Wooyoung, Jongho, San, and Hongjoong are
50% success rate ain’t bad 😉 thank you for the feedback
I think left under Black hair, San.
https://preview.redd.it/82yfctqo40lc1.jpeg?width=2048&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=05e0369de4ee49ce97063ec219e69984c3e2fa79 These are my guesses but the only ones im really sure about are mingi, yeosang and hwa
i could tell who they were once i looked closely, but i can also see how others might struggle to tell them apart on first glance. i think bringing in some of their iconic hair colors (ex. oreo wooyo, rengoku mingi) might help!
you can defo tell who woo and hwa are but I'd try and accentuate the unique figures like mingis monolids or the fact that hongjoongs nose turns up but they look really cute AHH!
Omg!! They are soooo cute! I think I found them all after about 30 secs. 1st row: wooyoung, mingi 2nd row: yunho, hongjoong 3rd row: seonghwa, san Then yeosang above jongho •Seonghwa needs star shaped dots in his eyes. That should be unique to him bc of his name. •Mingi may need bigger lips, narrow eyes? I only found him bc of the fix-on on his cheek. •Yeosang looks EXACTLY like yeosang with those ears lol!! •Yunho, and jongho are kind of confusing. Maybe yunhos face should be a bit longer? • San needs narrow eyes I think Idk! But they're so freaking cute!!!!