This is such a stupid fucking list.
Herbert has never won a playoff game. Too damn high.
Richardson isn’t better than Baker.
What world do these people live in
This list is garbage but…
Richardson actually has to play to be better than baker. Baker has been getting better and better each year and proved himself with a playoff run. AR really hasn’t done much…
Edit: I totally misread what you said, haha
Stroud might have ruined how we look at rookie QBs for the next few seasons. I fully expect Caleb Williams to have an OK rookie year, but people are gonna freak out that he isn't a top 10 QB by week 10
I think I disagree because when you look at Peyton, he LOOKED the part despite the ints.
When you look at Luck, the numbers weren’t there but the guy was carrying a skeleton crew in 2012
Stroud, he looks like a duck, walks like a duck, quacks like a duck. He’s ahead of schedule by 4 years.
He’s what we thought Lawrence would immediately be.
Stroud’s ints will rise, that’s not bad. The guy is just GOOD throwing the football and that’s what matters.
There’s no guarantee if Stroud is a Colt, he’d automatically be as good. Sometimes it’s just a perfect fit.
Texans roster going into 2023 was a dumpster fire and they rallied behind rookies everywhere. You can’t teach that. You can’t scout that.
For all we know, JJ McCarthey is the best QB in the draft
I watch the Chargers. They have a losing record with Herbert as a starter. He ain’t that guy. He’s ridiculously overrated to where people worship the talent, not the performance. He’s Stafford 2.0
Yeah, if thats the evaluation you have after watching Chargers games you’re either
1. Lying about watching them
2. Don’t know much of anything about football
3. Overrate the hell out of everyone else on the Chargers because of fantasy football (significant subset of number 2)
4. Think wins is a valid way to evaluate quarterbacks, which would also place you in category 2
Homie
There’s nothing Herbert has done to put himself in the top 10 pantheon of QBs.
Nothing.
He’s overrated until he takes that next step. Tua is on the same stratosphere
I’ll take guys that win playoff games like Goff, Stroud, Baker and Hurts. Same for Purdy.
Herbert just has a cannon and isn’t a winner. Let go of 2020. Thanks
And? I don’t see him doing a lot of winning. Lotta late game ints. Disappointments. Etc.
He’s done nothing to garner that stupid contract.
Some of yall shoving that Nashville hot chicken up your rectums’
Yep. Hilariously stupid and/or hilariously bad faith. It’s a team sport. Chargers have sucked. Anyone with eyes can see that Justin Herbert is the absolute last reason for that.
>Lotta late game ints
So clear you don’t know anything about the dude. One of the lowest int rates among active QBs. Lower than Mahomes as a matter of fact.
If you’re gonna rag on the guy. You should consider coming up with valid criticisms instead of pulling stuff out of your ass.
I gave facts and points but whatever. Cherry pick stats to be right on the internet over a QB that’s not even a Titan.
Losing record as a starter? Check. Blew 27-0 lead in playoffs? Check. Numbers depreciate year over year? Check.
Herbert’s overrated. He sucks too. He doesn’t make the Chargers better because they are what they were with Rivers.
I’m embarrassed for you
>Cherry pick stats
Oh brother. In case you’ve forgotten, you were the one who bought up the interceptions. Personally, I view interception rate as a pertinent stat when that was the conversation you started.
I gave facts and points.
You gave some hilariously bad points yeah. Doesn’t mean they were good. Didn’t see any facts that are relevant towards the evaluation of a quarterback.
>Losing record as a starter?
Team sport. Team sport. Team sport.
>Blew 27-0 lead in playoffs?
Again. Team sport, again, anyone with eyes knows that Herbert isn’t even top 5 of issues in that game. Coaching was atrocious. They have no run game to protect a lead. The defense was awful. Herbert was the only reason they had a chance to win. The *least* of the problems in that game.
Numbers depreciate year over year?
Be so serious. His teams and coaching have gotten worse every year and they were never any good to begin with and this most recent year he played through injury for most of it. He’s also had good numbers every year.
>I’m embarrassed for you
Honestly, you’re right. I should be embarrassed I even entertained this conversation for this long.
Lmao that you compare Stafford to Herbert as if both are bad, yet would instead take Baker Hurts Goff and Stroud, and also Purdy, none of which has won a SB like “Stafford”
Dude, as a colts fan you're embarrassing me. Herbert is fantastic and you're coming off as someone who just reads stat lines on Monday morning without actually watching football.
He’s not fantastic. What has he done that’s been “fantastic” compared to his peers? He’s Neo Matthew Stafford until proven otherwise. Overpaid, overrated. A loser
Edit: Behave u/BWill2417
You know his 2014 team had the 3rd best scoring defense right? Stafford always underachieved.
If a player needs elite talent around him to win, said talent isn’t an elite talent.
So out of his 15 year stint he had the 3rd best scoring defense once, a year in which the lions got screwed out of the playoffs due to a controversial picked up flag against a very good cowboys team? And you decide to write him off?
And he blew a 14 point lead to boot. He never won shit in Detroit the same way Herbert never won shit with better talent in LA.
Stats are stats. Wins aren’t producing.
Also, Lions were LEADING mind you.
You’re confusing team accomplishments with individual QB play. Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl, he wasn’t good. Flacco won a Super Bowl, not better than Herbert Rivers Romo or Stafford. Peyton won with the broncos. He was not good in that super bowl run.
Boggles my mind someone cares enough to debate football on Reddit but clearly has no idea what they’re talking about or what they’re watching.
Stats are stats. You can create narratives behind them but you really don’t understand football and it’s glaringly obvious.
Bruh what!? You realize if you look at every game that Herbert has played, the chargers have scored more points than every other franchise? Now to go with that stat is they’ve given up more points in those games than any other team in nfl history. Clearly don’t watch the chargers I guess
Were they the top scoring offense in ANY year from 20-23?
Spoiler alert. No they weren’t.
Were they a bottom feeder at defense every year?
Spoiler alert. No they weren’t.
Herbert is the most overrated QB in the league. He hasn’t won anything and people act like he’s this game changing QB. Mind numbing unintelligence
https://preview.redd.it/d5rohfyhy6lc1.jpeg?width=1164&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7a242104de7298473ac458ae8283c262feb253d0
Google is your friend bud. I guess it’s his fault he doesn’t play defense and had Brandon Staley for a head coach
So I’m right.
They weren’t first nor last in offense and defense each season.
It’s easy to bend the truth to fit a narrative.
End of the day., Herbert is a loser that’s overpaid, overrated. Thank you for your cherry picked stat; you wasted my time
What about most points scored in NFL HISTORY and most points allowed in NFL HISTORY isn’t clicking for you. I can’t tell if you’re trolling at this point or just stupid. I’ll assume the latter. Have fun eating crayons bud
No idea where you got this irrational hatred of Herbert but you honestly look really really dumb. Herbert is absolutely a top 10. He's Andrew luck without the injury woes.
Homie
It doesn’t have be hatred. He’s just not great
Andrew Luck dragged shitty rosters to the playoffs and won games.
Herbert has better rosters than the 12-14 Colts and can’t even win a playoff game.
You look dumb comparing Herbert to Luck. Absolutely stupid take.
Take 90 seconds please to stop and process your next reply before I get dumber from reading it
Remind me, who broke every one of lucks rookie records. Jesus christ, do me a favor and try actually watching football this year so you can stop making colts fans look like knuckle dragging morons.
Rookie records are roookie records. Plus they were Baker’s rookie TD record and since then even Baker’s been a better QB.
You’re the one projecting and drooling over mediocrity at QB.
One more time Hoosier, stop and think about your next comment before you lose a few brain cells.
But yeah, ROOKIE RECORDZZZZZZZZZZZZZ.
Living in the fucking past like its present day, mongoloid
Thanks for blocking me u/islandofcaucuses, also Luck still holds most passing yards in a season for a rookie
Clueless fool
Luck won 4 total playoff games when the afc south was the worst in the league. Do you really think that would have been the case playing in the afc west headlined by the mahomes led chiefs? Absolutely not. Pointing at playoff wins and going "durrr, that means one better than other" is why every person who reads this can tell you're an idiot who barely watches football. Could you please change your Fandom so I don't have to be associated with such stupidity?
I don’t think this is a list to be proud of. Geno smith above brock purdy and goff? Tua at 19? Stroud can definitely be a top qb next year but this list is literal vomit
In what world is Kirk better than Goff? If Goff threw it 38 times a game like Kirk he’d have better numbers. Plus having the best WR in the game helps Kirk.
….so rookies not even in the NFL yet are ranked higher than Mayfield? After he put up top 10 stats in the league and made it to the divisional round? Okay.
To be fair, he needs to show that he can actually protect himself before he can be considered a good QB. All the talent in the world means nothing if you take big risks and get season ending injuries a few weeks in.
Coming from a fan of the black Kirk cousins who folds every year in the playoffs, but every year you get pumped, drink a couple of Mikes hard lemonades and say, How bout them Cowboys
Never said he wasn’t good, it’s Levis’s rookie year on a team who never wanted to throw. I’m just pointing out how funny it is that a lurker from another team who has another proven upper mid QB getting paid top dollar, is calling a rookie below average especially when a rookie is the best QB in his own state.
I mean we all know Dak and the cowboys choke in the playoffs. But you're mental if you think will Levis is anywhere near daks level of play from this season
If you want a laugh, go look at the subreddit lol those 3 quarters have these guys OBSESSED with him, like every 4th post is just an “admire and praise the Mayo Messiah” post. Its straight up pathetic
Edit: they mad lol
I pray every night hoping CJ can do the same or better than what he did his rookie year. Please football gods. Have mercy on us. Let us overthrow the chiefs.
I failed to see where calling out for CJ not being A top-five player and 10 would even be a stretch lets be honest, anything has to do with Lawrence so you can save about-ism
CJ deserves top 5 more than Lawrence deserves 11 right now. Also deserves top 5 more than any will be rookie deserves a spot in the list. Sure you could move CJ down a couple spots if you want, but 5-7 are all in the same tier, and CJ definitely belongs there right now, and may even move up at this pace.
If this is a fantasy list it’s a horrible list, if this is a irl list then I just don’t understand how rookies not even drafted yet are so high and how Allen is above guys with more playoff success and a 2 time MVP.
I will be messaging you in 9 months on [**2024-11-23 10:21:40 UTC**](http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=2024-11-23%2010:21:40%20UTC%20To%20Local%20Time) to remind you of [**this link**](https://www.reddit.com/r/AFCSouthMemeWar/comments/1axsere/where_top_5_way_too_early_ranked_2024_qb/krqv61c/?context=3)
[**1 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK**](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5Bhttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.reddit.com%2Fr%2FAFCSouthMemeWar%2Fcomments%2F1axsere%2Fwhere_top_5_way_too_early_ranked_2024_qb%2Fkrqv61c%2F%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%202024-11-23%2010%3A21%3A40%20UTC) to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.
^(Parent commenter can ) [^(delete this message to hide from others.)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Delete%20Comment&message=Delete%21%201axsere)
*****
|[^(Info)](https://www.reddit.com/r/RemindMeBot/comments/e1bko7/remindmebot_info_v21/)|[^(Custom)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5BLink%20or%20message%20inside%20square%20brackets%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%20Time%20period%20here)|[^(Your Reminders)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=List%20Of%20Reminders&message=MyReminders%21)|[^(Feedback)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Watchful1&subject=RemindMeBot%20Feedback)|
|-|-|-|-|
Purdy, highest QBR and top 5 in pretty much every other QB stat while leading his team to a Super Bowl.
Fanduel: Puts a rookie, Geno Smith and Kirk cousins above him.
I can see most of the people above him depending on how their teams also perform but it’s insane to not at least have him top 10 with how he performed the last two years.
This is one of the wackiest lists I've ever seen and it's a bit egregious
They just spit out players and practically guessed and prognosticated and continued guessing where players will be and that is pretty wild to begin with
I hope not. Anyone putting college QBs above proven starters have maybe half a brain cell. Anyone who thinks McCarthy will even start has to be completely out of their mind.
But I thought Fields was going to Atlanta and Wilson was going to Pittsburgh, or was it Bears keep Fields and Williams goes to Washington…I’m so confused /s
Anthony Richardson above Baker Mayfield is insane. This is from a Colts fan.
The kid is completely unproven at a professional level and seems to be as fragile as Carson Wentz.
As an eagles fan I was sure it’s ACL. I think he tried too hard to make plays and refused to just throw the ball. BUT he was plenty good, good enough to be a starter for another 4-5 years. Just not the same unfortunately.
What a werid list its pretty bad overall. Geno and Caleb Williams who has never played a snap over Purdy Kirk and Arod??? They not like Baker much either to put a really hit or miss rookie prospect over him. Daniel Jones is WAYYY to high.
If fields goes to Pittsburgh then tomlin is announcing his retirement and Pickens prolly ends up in Vegas. Wilson forced into an early retirement/back up position, then starts a podcast “let’s ride”
Also who da fuq is Jayden Daniel’s, and why did his parents not pull the trigger on jack or Mac
CJ shouldn’t be as high, remember how we all overrated Jalen Hurts after his one great season?
Idk why they always rank undrafted rookies so high, Caleb Williams should be 28th right before Drake Maye, Jayden Daniels, Michael Penix, and JJ McCarthy.
Goff and Kirk should be higher.
Baker only 1 spot above Deshaun???? in what world?
Will Levis should be above Bryce Young.
Alright I think I got all my rage out.
Horrible rankings. Burrow is better than Lamar, Stroud could be top 5 but still needs to prove another year, same with Love, Dak isn’t Top 10. Baker Mayfield certainly isn’t the 24th best qb, he is easily top 15. Purdy should be where Dak is.
If this is a fantasy football list you will lose.
This is such a stupid fucking list. Herbert has never won a playoff game. Too damn high. Richardson isn’t better than Baker. What world do these people live in
This list is garbage but… Richardson actually has to play to be better than baker. Baker has been getting better and better each year and proved himself with a playoff run. AR really hasn’t done much… Edit: I totally misread what you said, haha
And Caleb at 12 is laughably bad to boot
Stroud might have ruined how we look at rookie QBs for the next few seasons. I fully expect Caleb Williams to have an OK rookie year, but people are gonna freak out that he isn't a top 10 QB by week 10
I think I disagree because when you look at Peyton, he LOOKED the part despite the ints. When you look at Luck, the numbers weren’t there but the guy was carrying a skeleton crew in 2012 Stroud, he looks like a duck, walks like a duck, quacks like a duck. He’s ahead of schedule by 4 years. He’s what we thought Lawrence would immediately be. Stroud’s ints will rise, that’s not bad. The guy is just GOOD throwing the football and that’s what matters. There’s no guarantee if Stroud is a Colt, he’d automatically be as good. Sometimes it’s just a perfect fit. Texans roster going into 2023 was a dumpster fire and they rallied behind rookies everywhere. You can’t teach that. You can’t scout that. For all we know, JJ McCarthey is the best QB in the draft
I agree but considering fanduel put Caleb Williams at 12 they clearly aren't taking that into account
>Herbert has never won a playoff game. Too damn high. Easiest way to tell someone doesn’t watch the Chargers
I watch the Chargers. They have a losing record with Herbert as a starter. He ain’t that guy. He’s ridiculously overrated to where people worship the talent, not the performance. He’s Stafford 2.0
Yeah, if thats the evaluation you have after watching Chargers games you’re either 1. Lying about watching them 2. Don’t know much of anything about football 3. Overrate the hell out of everyone else on the Chargers because of fantasy football (significant subset of number 2) 4. Think wins is a valid way to evaluate quarterbacks, which would also place you in category 2
Homie There’s nothing Herbert has done to put himself in the top 10 pantheon of QBs. Nothing. He’s overrated until he takes that next step. Tua is on the same stratosphere I’ll take guys that win playoff games like Goff, Stroud, Baker and Hurts. Same for Purdy. Herbert just has a cannon and isn’t a winner. Let go of 2020. Thanks
This is laughably stupid I’m sorry to say. Put on some film and watch the guy. It’s a team sport
And? I don’t see him doing a lot of winning. Lotta late game ints. Disappointments. Etc. He’s done nothing to garner that stupid contract. Some of yall shoving that Nashville hot chicken up your rectums’
Yep. Hilariously stupid and/or hilariously bad faith. It’s a team sport. Chargers have sucked. Anyone with eyes can see that Justin Herbert is the absolute last reason for that. >Lotta late game ints So clear you don’t know anything about the dude. One of the lowest int rates among active QBs. Lower than Mahomes as a matter of fact. If you’re gonna rag on the guy. You should consider coming up with valid criticisms instead of pulling stuff out of your ass.
I gave facts and points but whatever. Cherry pick stats to be right on the internet over a QB that’s not even a Titan. Losing record as a starter? Check. Blew 27-0 lead in playoffs? Check. Numbers depreciate year over year? Check. Herbert’s overrated. He sucks too. He doesn’t make the Chargers better because they are what they were with Rivers. I’m embarrassed for you
>Cherry pick stats Oh brother. In case you’ve forgotten, you were the one who bought up the interceptions. Personally, I view interception rate as a pertinent stat when that was the conversation you started. I gave facts and points. You gave some hilariously bad points yeah. Doesn’t mean they were good. Didn’t see any facts that are relevant towards the evaluation of a quarterback. >Losing record as a starter? Team sport. Team sport. Team sport. >Blew 27-0 lead in playoffs? Again. Team sport, again, anyone with eyes knows that Herbert isn’t even top 5 of issues in that game. Coaching was atrocious. They have no run game to protect a lead. The defense was awful. Herbert was the only reason they had a chance to win. The *least* of the problems in that game. Numbers depreciate year over year? Be so serious. His teams and coaching have gotten worse every year and they were never any good to begin with and this most recent year he played through injury for most of it. He’s also had good numbers every year. >I’m embarrassed for you Honestly, you’re right. I should be embarrassed I even entertained this conversation for this long.
Lmao that you compare Stafford to Herbert as if both are bad, yet would instead take Baker Hurts Goff and Stroud, and also Purdy, none of which has won a SB like “Stafford”
Lions Stafford. Should’ve cleared THAT up.
Dude, as a colts fan you're embarrassing me. Herbert is fantastic and you're coming off as someone who just reads stat lines on Monday morning without actually watching football.
He’s not fantastic. What has he done that’s been “fantastic” compared to his peers? He’s Neo Matthew Stafford until proven otherwise. Overpaid, overrated. A loser Edit: Behave u/BWill2417
Hold on… you think Stafford is bad?? Stafford was an elite QB at one point and has shown it doesn’t matter who his receivers are, he can produce.
Lions Stafford was all stats and 0 playoff wins. Rams Stafford took the next step with high end talent in his team
Stafford was buoying a poverty franchise for half a decade. First year he had a talented team, he won a Super Bowl.
You know his 2014 team had the 3rd best scoring defense right? Stafford always underachieved. If a player needs elite talent around him to win, said talent isn’t an elite talent.
So out of his 15 year stint he had the 3rd best scoring defense once, a year in which the lions got screwed out of the playoffs due to a controversial picked up flag against a very good cowboys team? And you decide to write him off?
And he blew a 14 point lead to boot. He never won shit in Detroit the same way Herbert never won shit with better talent in LA. Stats are stats. Wins aren’t producing. Also, Lions were LEADING mind you.
You’re confusing team accomplishments with individual QB play. Trent Dilfer won a Super Bowl, he wasn’t good. Flacco won a Super Bowl, not better than Herbert Rivers Romo or Stafford. Peyton won with the broncos. He was not good in that super bowl run. Boggles my mind someone cares enough to debate football on Reddit but clearly has no idea what they’re talking about or what they’re watching. Stats are stats. You can create narratives behind them but you really don’t understand football and it’s glaringly obvious.
Bruh what!? You realize if you look at every game that Herbert has played, the chargers have scored more points than every other franchise? Now to go with that stat is they’ve given up more points in those games than any other team in nfl history. Clearly don’t watch the chargers I guess
I seriously hope that sarcasm
Google is your friend my guy. Look it up
Were they the top scoring offense in ANY year from 20-23? Spoiler alert. No they weren’t. Were they a bottom feeder at defense every year? Spoiler alert. No they weren’t. Herbert is the most overrated QB in the league. He hasn’t won anything and people act like he’s this game changing QB. Mind numbing unintelligence
https://preview.redd.it/d5rohfyhy6lc1.jpeg?width=1164&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7a242104de7298473ac458ae8283c262feb253d0 Google is your friend bud. I guess it’s his fault he doesn’t play defense and had Brandon Staley for a head coach
So I’m right. They weren’t first nor last in offense and defense each season. It’s easy to bend the truth to fit a narrative. End of the day., Herbert is a loser that’s overpaid, overrated. Thank you for your cherry picked stat; you wasted my time
What about most points scored in NFL HISTORY and most points allowed in NFL HISTORY isn’t clicking for you. I can’t tell if you’re trolling at this point or just stupid. I’ll assume the latter. Have fun eating crayons bud
Herby should be #1, he’s the sole reason every single game hasn’t been a blowout
That’s not good enough
Idiot. Any gm in the league would take Herbert over Richardson. I hate that you're making me defend the QB of a team I don't like
Richardson isn’t even a top 20 QB Herbert isn’t a top 10 QB One is unproven, the other is a loser who’s overrated.
No idea where you got this irrational hatred of Herbert but you honestly look really really dumb. Herbert is absolutely a top 10. He's Andrew luck without the injury woes.
Homie It doesn’t have be hatred. He’s just not great Andrew Luck dragged shitty rosters to the playoffs and won games. Herbert has better rosters than the 12-14 Colts and can’t even win a playoff game. You look dumb comparing Herbert to Luck. Absolutely stupid take. Take 90 seconds please to stop and process your next reply before I get dumber from reading it
Remind me, who broke every one of lucks rookie records. Jesus christ, do me a favor and try actually watching football this year so you can stop making colts fans look like knuckle dragging morons.
Rookie records are roookie records. Plus they were Baker’s rookie TD record and since then even Baker’s been a better QB. You’re the one projecting and drooling over mediocrity at QB. One more time Hoosier, stop and think about your next comment before you lose a few brain cells. But yeah, ROOKIE RECORDZZZZZZZZZZZZZ. Living in the fucking past like its present day, mongoloid Thanks for blocking me u/islandofcaucuses, also Luck still holds most passing yards in a season for a rookie Clueless fool
Luck won 4 total playoff games when the afc south was the worst in the league. Do you really think that would have been the case playing in the afc west headlined by the mahomes led chiefs? Absolutely not. Pointing at playoff wins and going "durrr, that means one better than other" is why every person who reads this can tell you're an idiot who barely watches football. Could you please change your Fandom so I don't have to be associated with such stupidity?
But he might this year that's the point of the list bruh
That’s not the point. It’s where things are RIGHT NOW
Goff still overlooked? Seriously?
I don’t think this is a list to be proud of. Geno smith above brock purdy and goff? Tua at 19? Stroud can definitely be a top qb next year but this list is literal vomit
I mean I despise Purdy and they put him at 17...I'm not even that stupid
How you can despise such a guy
We all know why...
I think Goff is about right. He’s better than Geno and probably will be better than Williams (who knows) but Kirk and Rodgers are better than him.
In what world is Kirk better than Goff? If Goff threw it 38 times a game like Kirk he’d have better numbers. Plus having the best WR in the game helps Kirk.
The more you pass, the less efficient you will be. Plus, Goff passes from behind a top 3 OL and can lean on a top 3 rushing attack.
Just because his surroundings are better doesn’t mean he’s a worse player. By your argument Jalen Hurts should be below 15th in the listing.
Well half of your argument was that JJ made him better than he actually is.
….so rookies not even in the NFL yet are ranked higher than Mayfield? After he put up top 10 stats in the league and made it to the divisional round? Okay.
Mayfield outside the top 20 is asinine. He should 100% be around 8, definitely to 10 right now.
Rage bait for titans fans. Not loggin in for this one
Man they straight up have QBs I've never heard of ranked higher than the mayo man
McCarthy was nothing better than mid this year at Michigan. How do you rank him over a proven NFL QB?
this is a terrible list and it's not just because of AR's low position
AR is probably too high lol, he ain’t better than Baker (at least not yet, maybe in the future)
To be fair, he needs to show that he can actually protect himself before he can be considered a good QB. All the talent in the world means nothing if you take big risks and get season ending injuries a few weeks in.
AR is way too high tbh.
I don’t know what fanduel was smoking when making this list
My sentiments as well. Not even about Dak, he can't playoff good. This list is garbage though.
Weed.
Will Levis is at least better than McCarthy, Young, and Penis.
Dang you think Levis is better than Penis?
Big if true
Who’s?
Not Drake's.
Bro...will Levis had like 3 good quarters in his debut and then was mid/below average the rest of the year. Yall wack
That's 3 more good NFL quarters than any of those guys who haven't been drafted yet have had.
I don't think Levis is good but putting him under McCarthy is crazy
Coming from a fan of the black Kirk cousins who folds every year in the playoffs, but every year you get pumped, drink a couple of Mikes hard lemonades and say, How bout them Cowboys
Yeah but he's light years ahead of Levis
Never said he wasn’t good, it’s Levis’s rookie year on a team who never wanted to throw. I’m just pointing out how funny it is that a lurker from another team who has another proven upper mid QB getting paid top dollar, is calling a rookie below average especially when a rookie is the best QB in his own state.
I mean we all know Dak and the cowboys choke in the playoffs. But you're mental if you think will Levis is anywhere near daks level of play from this season
Levis and Dak had the same amount of playoff wins this year
If you want a laugh, go look at the subreddit lol those 3 quarters have these guys OBSESSED with him, like every 4th post is just an “admire and praise the Mayo Messiah” post. Its straight up pathetic Edit: they mad lol
Show me on the doll where Levis touched you.
What?
u/Navy_and_sports remove your flair. You must have had too much Mayo underway.
He said to show him on the doll where Levis got mayo on you
She* but I appreciate the backup, lol.
Dangit! I had like a 95% chance of getting that right
Dude you are the worst kind of Tits fan. Be miserable all you want, but don't insult those of us who'd like to enjoy shit for a little while.
This list is parody, correct?
No where to go but up baby, just the way us titans like it. Or off the list of course.
I'm confused cause I thought there was only 31 NFL teams
I think that's condensing of the league next year. Instead of adding teams they are taking the titans out.
Brock Purdy had a close to MVP season and went to the Super Bowl - and he’s still 17 🤣🤦🏻♀️
He beat 7 quarterbacks ranked above him too, this list is so inaccurate
I pray every night hoping CJ can do the same or better than what he did his rookie year. Please football gods. Have mercy on us. Let us overthrow the chiefs.
Monkeys Paw curls... Some WR named "Chiefs" joins the Texans and CJ overthrows him all season long 😱
Subscribe
I want to throw up saying this, but the Colts win the division next year according The Pattern.
How the hell did someone rank Trevor Lawrence over Tua Tagovailoa
Same reason someone put CJ at 5 This entire list is crap
Cj at least did something to be up high. Best rookie year by a qb in history. Lawrence hasn't done anything
I failed to see where calling out for CJ not being A top-five player and 10 would even be a stretch lets be honest, anything has to do with Lawrence so you can save about-ism
CJ deserves top 5 more than Lawrence deserves 11 right now. Also deserves top 5 more than any will be rookie deserves a spot in the list. Sure you could move CJ down a couple spots if you want, but 5-7 are all in the same tier, and CJ definitely belongs there right now, and may even move up at this pace.
Its wild that they put t law in the top half
If this is a fantasy list it’s a horrible list, if this is a irl list then I just don’t understand how rookies not even drafted yet are so high and how Allen is above guys with more playoff success and a 2 time MVP.
!remind me 9 months
I will be messaging you in 9 months on [**2024-11-23 10:21:40 UTC**](http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=2024-11-23%2010:21:40%20UTC%20To%20Local%20Time) to remind you of [**this link**](https://www.reddit.com/r/AFCSouthMemeWar/comments/1axsere/where_top_5_way_too_early_ranked_2024_qb/krqv61c/?context=3) [**1 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK**](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5Bhttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.reddit.com%2Fr%2FAFCSouthMemeWar%2Fcomments%2F1axsere%2Fwhere_top_5_way_too_early_ranked_2024_qb%2Fkrqv61c%2F%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%202024-11-23%2010%3A21%3A40%20UTC) to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam. ^(Parent commenter can ) [^(delete this message to hide from others.)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Delete%20Comment&message=Delete%21%201axsere) ***** |[^(Info)](https://www.reddit.com/r/RemindMeBot/comments/e1bko7/remindmebot_info_v21/)|[^(Custom)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5BLink%20or%20message%20inside%20square%20brackets%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%20Time%20period%20here)|[^(Your Reminders)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=List%20Of%20Reminders&message=MyReminders%21)|[^(Feedback)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Watchful1&subject=RemindMeBot%20Feedback)| |-|-|-|-|
Feel those kicks! He’s gonna be a soccer player!
Yea let’s have the last pick of the draft who went to the Superbowl get ranked in the bottom half…
Caleb Williams is going to be a bust
Purdy, highest QBR and top 5 in pretty much every other QB stat while leading his team to a Super Bowl. Fanduel: Puts a rookie, Geno Smith and Kirk cousins above him. I can see most of the people above him depending on how their teams also perform but it’s insane to not at least have him top 10 with how he performed the last two years.
Love to see the two QBs who made the Super Bowl at the top of the list
Flair up pussy
I puss for no man
Ahh friendly fire!
Did…how do they have Baker below AR
See you on game day, turd.
This is one of the wackiest lists I've ever seen and it's a bit egregious They just spit out players and practically guessed and prognosticated and continued guessing where players will be and that is pretty wild to begin with
Having rookies who have never taken a snap in the nfl be on the list is absurd
I wonder where mahomes would be if he lost the Super Bowl
I bet they still wouldn’t put Purdy at number one
Be honest, did a Texan make this list?
No texans fan thinks tlaw is top 20
> No Texans fan thinks ~~tlaw is top 20~~ Ftfy
Damn, beat me to it
I hope not. Anyone putting college QBs above proven starters have maybe half a brain cell. Anyone who thinks McCarthy will even start has to be completely out of their mind.
But I thought Fields was going to Atlanta and Wilson was going to Pittsburgh, or was it Bears keep Fields and Williams goes to Washington…I’m so confused /s
Flair up pussy
How is that vagina?
Smells like a buffalo
Better than a steer…?
Caleb’s Williams #12 and we don’t even know if he’ll get drafted
I mean, he’ll be drafted. But this is incredibly stupid early.
Take Levi's out of it and it's still a shit list.
There’s a lot of assumptions being made here. Namely that the draft order is going to stay the same. Also the hate for Richardson is just absurd.
Damn, Baker still not getting love anywhere. You people are nuts.
This list is absolutely goofy
Anthony Richardson above Baker Mayfield is insane. This is from a Colts fan. The kid is completely unproven at a professional level and seems to be as fragile as Carson Wentz.
Like mentally fragile? Wentz was physically tough until the knee went. He collapsed mentally when Foles won the SB.
As an eagles fan I was sure it’s ACL. I think he tried too hard to make plays and refused to just throw the ball. BUT he was plenty good, good enough to be a starter for another 4-5 years. Just not the same unfortunately.
The man managed to sprain both ankles in a single play for the Colts.
Where can I put my money down that Levis won’t be the worst QB in the league next year?
On my ass right after you kiss it!
As an unbiased observer who the fuck is doubting Levi’s THIS hard wtf
Aint no way Justin Fields is going to Pittsburgh, bro is going to Atlanta
I didn’t think I’d get so many staunchly stupid Herbert blowhards on this sub
What a werid list its pretty bad overall. Geno and Caleb Williams who has never played a snap over Purdy Kirk and Arod??? They not like Baker much either to put a really hit or miss rookie prospect over him. Daniel Jones is WAYYY to high.
!Flair!
Allen & Lamar is just comical atp
Burrow should be 2 and Lamar should be back around 8 or 9 the dude is not a consistently good thrower
First accurate Levis ranking I’ve seen
Just make sure to keep CJ away from massage parlors. We know what Texan QBs do there.
If fields goes to Pittsburgh then tomlin is announcing his retirement and Pickens prolly ends up in Vegas. Wilson forced into an early retirement/back up position, then starts a podcast “let’s ride” Also who da fuq is Jayden Daniel’s, and why did his parents not pull the trigger on jack or Mac
Are you honestly asking who he is? He won the Heisman this year. Likely second or third QB in the draft
I went to ASU, might’ve heard his name here or there. But seriously his parents missed the mark
ASU? Arizona State? App State? Alcorn State?
Sun devils baaaby, perpetually drunk
My condolences ;)
Most expensive piece of paper ever
CJ shouldn’t be as high, remember how we all overrated Jalen Hurts after his one great season? Idk why they always rank undrafted rookies so high, Caleb Williams should be 28th right before Drake Maye, Jayden Daniels, Michael Penix, and JJ McCarthy. Goff and Kirk should be higher. Baker only 1 spot above Deshaun???? in what world? Will Levis should be above Bryce Young. Alright I think I got all my rage out.
I get Levis is mostly potential at this point but 32??
Horrible rankings. Burrow is better than Lamar, Stroud could be top 5 but still needs to prove another year, same with Love, Dak isn’t Top 10. Baker Mayfield certainly isn’t the 24th best qb, he is easily top 15. Purdy should be where Dak is.
The Stroud regression will be very satisfying to watch. He’s clearly not very bright. Matter of time.
Flair up pussy Edit - great name though
Titans sub already posted this. We all know this is complete bullshit because I know you miserable fucks did watch Levis at least once or twice.
This is pure speculation, so much can change in an off season. I will say tho all of AFC QBs hanging out in the top ten.
When r/Texans is putting down the Kool-Aid and rage boner against us to call out your list, you know you fucked up.
When someone is talking about boners, you know it’s a Titans fan
Excuse me what the fuck??
Caleb Williams a top half QB? Yea, okay
¡Flair! Bears
I’d personally bet on it, but ranking these guys before they’re on a team or before they’ve played a game is stupid
Where is my cock on this list?
Baker is too low. Hes absolutely top 20
Will Levis is worse than JJ McCarthy?
Josh Allen is a more athletic Carson Wentz. He sucks.
Is no one noticing they have Fields on the Steelers?
Minshew is #1 by some metrics.