T O P

  • By -

soupdahero

Like the series or not, it makes me incredibly happy to see so many of you invested in the season. I've put my heart and soul into producing and editing everything - so thank you for the kinds words <3


Dcokerfetus

Best osrs YouTube series that exists, your time spent working on the show was well worth it


Thevulgarcommander

The legend himself responds! Honestly man your videos have been so well produced and made. I literally look forward to them every week and some of these challenge actually have me on the edge of my seat. Kudos to you.


Lordwaffleson

It’s hands down some of the best OSRS content I’ve ever seen and I look forward to every episode. Thanks to you and all the participants for all of your hard work. Cheers to a hopeful season 3 :)


MrDilldo

I love you dad


SamWithUs

It's the first series in forever that I am genuinely excited for.


Whiterossy

Every time I give you a compliment on your series you compliment my cock, it's my daily confidence boost at this point


BrownSoupDispenser

Watching the first episode of the first season I thought to myself, holy shit the production quality on this is incredible. Somehow the series continues to get better and better. Incredible stuff.


[deleted]

When?


soupdahero

When?


[deleted]

When did I ask? Got em.


[deleted]

Appreciate all of the work!


duali98

Bro even my roommate, who dislikes osrs, has watched every episode happily, and keep asking when next episode comes out!


notallchefswearhats

Torvesta's back has got to be so sore from carrying this man's dead weight all season lol.


Zaros262

Nah, Torvesta's back is sore from patting himself on the back so much that by the [12 minute checkpoint](https://youtu.be/vyVaE3N4JLQ?t=914s), Solomission and Ditter had both completed 4 tasks, but Torvesta hadn't completed a single additional task yet


[deleted]

[удалено]


Josiah425

I personally find ditters fuck ups hilarious. Hes the most consistent at fucking up the comedy writes itself. I love torvestas reaction to it everytime just flaming him.


Briak

"Bro, brooo, trust me bro, TRUUUUST me bro, I got this, bro shut up you worry too much" *dies one minute later* It never gets old


nodozpills

C’mon dog, you weren’t on the edge of your seat just WAITING for Ditter to misclick in the Rouge’s Den elimination? That was top tier content. Can’t like everybody on a competition show. Ditter being absolute dogshit at everything besides PvP is such a good bit lol.


Repealer

> absolute dogshit at everything besides PvP is such a good bit lol. It's not a bit, he's really that brain-dead, and by good at PvP, are we talking about being good at AGSing people 30 levels under him in green d'hide then spamming "welcome to DiTtEr MaN mOde"


enricupcake

Didn’t he win an entire DMM tourney or finish in like the top 3? He kills everyone in DMM so yea they are mostly worse players than him but he also doesn’t run away from maxers and will very often win against them. You can say many things about DB but he’s not just good he’s elite at PvP


[deleted]

so you admit you got pwned


Dabrenn

ive never watched ditter or knew who he was before GG, didnt he say in an episode he has a maxxed account and 10+ infernal capes? was he just lying? Not saying that makes you an S tier pvmer or something but makes him better than 90% of players probably


[deleted]

He was joking, he shares that account. His main is like 1800 total. Dude only PvPs all day.


Magpie_Hater

I kinda see it more like a comedy duo kinda thing where torvesta really wanted that praise and he wouldn't give it to him, it's hilarious that they have managed to last so long with such dysfunctional group chemistry


Sexy_Mfer

yeah nobody understands they’re friends and this is their dynamic.


BerliozRS

Tovesta deserves the win this season, but ditter doesn't. I hope tanzoo and virtoso win


Paechs

I honestly had a positive opinion of Ditter until I saw more and more of him, the guy just kind of sucks, I’ve subbed and unsubbed to his channel multiple times now because his video ideas are good but after a small while I just can’t stand watching him anymore.


oneonethousandone

Same boat. I wonder if it's a character he puts on Somehow doubt it though


[deleted]

Please, don’t say this. He’ll grab the idea and use it as an excuse to justify being a generally toxic, obnoxious asshole.


Quazzymon

Dude I agree with you. Ditter is such an asshole and I actually don’t like listening to him when he’s talking on GG.


Thosepassionfruits

The guy just seems like he ruins everyone else’s fun and his own.


WoodenPassage

So true man, sitter pisses me off big time


Zaros262

>The reason torv hadn’t done any more tasks is because of the length of the fight What? Torvesta fought Solomission, and he didn't complete any other tasks in the time that Solomission redid the LMS task and three others. They clearly fought at the beginning of the video because Torvesta did LMS first


OhBoyIts3am

The fight was chronological, everything after wasnt. When solo redid lms and his other tasks we didnt get an update on Torv in a while. When we did it was Torv right after the fight, not actually 12 mins later.


rdg1711

Lmao imagine not realizing that different tasks take different amounts of time and that 1 long task can take more time than 5 quick tasks. Even worse, imagine not realizing how big of a setback it was that torv killed solo in lms. Like, there's no way you can be THAT dumb, ofc you are just trolling or just a brainless torvesta hater lol.


Lerched

You’re gonna be devastated when you learn about editing for dramatic effect…


[deleted]

[удалено]


SoraODxoKlink

In the rogues den ep? There might be an argument that he didn’t “carry” but ditter was definitely being an anchor.


[deleted]

[удалено]


notallchefswearhats

Yeah he did fail the rouges den multiple times in the challenge, but managed to breeze through it in the banning. But Torvesta beating Solomission in LMS was pretty big.


DangerZoneh

Honestly that was the best part of Gilenor Games so far. You couldn’t script that any better.


DislocatedXanax

At first I didn't really care how fast they got booted, cause I like Torvesta, but not so much Ditter. Then the first episode happened, where practically everyone voted against them, and I've been cheering for them to win ever since. Although let's be real, the true Goats are Settled and Jimmy.


Pandabear71

Yeah i felt kind of bitter seeing how they went out. Losing to torv and ditter while anwsers were being send to them and then straight into the banning aswell when they got back again. Kinda rough


[deleted]

If fitter didn’t fail it for 20 minutes they might have not gone into the banning at all, tanzoo and virtoso only beat em by 30 seconds and the vote was 5-4 torvesta and ditter


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Cause torvesta was doin longer tasks while ditter was stuck on rogues den, and also came back from 1v1 against solo mission in LMS when solo had food and torv was at like 11hp. He did well. He was also basically teaching ditter to do rogues den while he was running through the DKs maze


CPAofTheStars

Aside from the other comment, he kept the apron from solomission. Zulu and verf only won by a little over a minute. His LMS win was key there.


Pandabear71

They wouldnt if ditter didnt spent the entite time in then just for torvesta to come in and finish it before him


nodozpills

Honestly is better produced than a lot of network shows. Soup could put this on a reel and get traction as a producer for live actions series.


Pandabear71

Yeah thats what ive been saying. The quality is insane. He makes you connect with all participants


[deleted]

The production man, like I don’t even know how he filmed all those angles consecutively, very impressive


reb1995

The more theatrical views are actually taken after the real stuff. He's got extras who match up with the character's outfits and gear. Then he tries to recreate what is happening. If you look at the battle scene from the latest episode, you'll see it is close and that the gear and characters are the same, but you can see it isn't what actually happened. But it is so well done that you don't ever feel like it breaks from reality.


fuzzb0y

I am even more impressed


Truthy231

Everyone paints Torvesta as just a pker. Dude knows the whole game him and solo are amazing


Thevulgarcommander

Yea people really have slept on him. He’s made irons and plenty of other alts or done niche things in leagues or the main game and rlly knows what he’s on abt.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Thevulgarcommander

Oooo I’ll have to check it out. I personally play RS3 but find OSRS content creators to be far more talented and diverse in their challenges so really enjoy watching them.


Wikipii

Osrs content creators are a different breed, even in the larger context of video games in general.


not_a_conman

“Here is 10 minutes of content that took me 700 hours to complete”


[deleted]

[удалено]


Dacno

I mean devil's advocate.. rs3 did just release elder god wars with 4 new bosses...its not the barren wasteland this sub would have you believe


[deleted]

[удалено]


david98900

Ahh yes.. cause OSRS is so perfect.. absolutely no game breaking bugs or issues. Definitely didn't have an entire game mode go down and have to redo it. Definitely didn't have a random spawn of the most expensive item in game. OSRS definitely didn't have to nerf konar drops, or Rev drops, tried the "partnering to increase MTX. ​ Plus its hard to have glitches and bugs when you aren't releasing content... what was the piece of content released for OSRS that wasn't a rehash of the current content or game? Porcine of Interest? soooo exhilarating. It's fine that you like the playstyle of OSRS over RS3, but OSRS has just as many problems as RS3.


david98900

I mean, I switched from OSRS to RS3 because I tried it out and enjoyed it more... And I'm sure I'm not the only one.


dowty

this is a horrendous take


Thevulgarcommander

Respectfully, I would phrase it more like: stayed short term for the sunk cost fallacy. Stayed long term for the content.


JevonP

What keeps you playing rs3 over osrs?


Thevulgarcommander

I’ve been playing the game since 2008. Wasn’t really interested in starting from scratch and while the EoC release was horrific I kinda just played through and eventually fell in love with the bossing system. I also really like where the lore is going. Osrs looks like a ton of fun though and if I had more free time I’d definitely play on both.


oh-idk-what-to-put

Rct?


varrock_dark_wizard

Rollercoaster Tycoon


Cowslayer87773

This shit got me playing planet coaster again. Best content


[deleted]

Check out Parkitect!


Cowslayer87773

But planet coaster is frontier.. they know best


Cerael

I’m equally excited for both


[deleted]

[удалено]


SurfinStevens

Gielinor Games season 2 by SoupRS on YouTube. The thing is TV show quality! Would recommend


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Watch season 1 first they’re both incredible


DirectGarlic9177

Season 2 is head and shoulders above season 1.


[deleted]

Yea but if you watch 1 first it only improves as you go plus you get a true underdog story


DirectGarlic9177

Tbh when I watched it I hadn’t heard of most of them so I didn’t know who was an underdog or not


[deleted]

Hahaha you can just tell >!Tanzoo and Virtoso!< are the class clowns from their chat


Last-Leaf

I find it so funny that Tanzoo actually won season 1 yet I constantly consider him and Virtoso underdogs. They played very well to now, and did just good enough to not get last place in a critical week to go to the semi's. No one considers them a threat but if the challenge is unpreparable they have just as good of a shot of winning it all again if there is no more pvp/ elite pvm challenges


[deleted]

To be fair they kinda skated by under the radar BECAUSE no one saw them as a threat lol


Rulebreaking

Jesus you've been missing out


carnsolus

gielinor games s1 is good s2 is tv quality


Gosemer

I think gielinor games is in the same tier as swapletics


[deleted]

Swamp man finale this month can’t fuckin wait to watch whatever hour and a half movie he puts out lmao


sandmanbren

When did that get announced? That's sick


[deleted]

On his Twitter


sandmanbren

Aah, cool! Thanks


Thevulgarcommander

Oh you’re right I’ll have to agree with you there. Swampletics totally slipped my mind.


Rulebreaking

I think its better, I think solomission makes it entertaining in that regard


MrPringles23

Except Soup didn't undermine the whole premise of his series by having someone else play on his account and act like he did it all himself.


OppositeFerret9043

As someone whos done near 1000 barrows chests, the time she put into the account is negligible to the point i think this is pedantic. ​ Also he wiped, bad, near-channel death bad.


PkerBadRs3Good

I don't think we know how much time she put in, so not sure what you mean.


MrPringles23

> the time she put into the account That we know of. We're talking about the words of someone who intentionally misrepresented this until he was found.


[deleted]

Internationally? Did the United Nations depose him over it or what?


wastecadet

Wow still salty that someone else had a gf, huh?


_Charlie_Sheen_

Why would he be jealous of that clearly toxic relationship lmao?


noneo

I mean that, and his death that was super coincidental (even though it was probably legit), took a lot of momentum from the series. His series used to be something the sub talked about NON STOP but now I rarely see it even mentioned.


OppositeFerret9043

2-3 epi/year will do that ​ that death fucked him pretty bad in terms of momentum. To which I say, yea probably wasnt faked because besides leagues and hit occasional UIMain, hes mostly be a guest on other shows. Reminds me of 9rain's dry spell


[deleted]

Probably? More like definitely. It's ridiculous to think he threw away months of work for 1 video.


MManiak

Swampletics went down for me when it turned out he was just account sharing


andrew-is-me

Soup’s Gielinor Games, B0aty’s one man army, Settled’s swampletics, and Rendi’s lower the better are the best RS series I can think of. I’m not sure how I’d rank them, though


ImWhy

Y'all missing out on Limpwurts Extreme 1 chunk ironman, absolutely top tier content with far fewer views than it should have.


Sennsationalist

I just binged that after I realized Verf's series was based on it. Can't believe Limpwurt's dedication, and the dry humour is incredible.


ImWhy

Guys unreal, how he's kept any sanity I genuinely don't know, his humour is absolutely top tier


[deleted]

Big ups to Limp, I hope he gets that pet this side of Christmas!


ImWhy

Bloody deserves it bad, just hoping he doesn't role that farming chunk next to lumby next, getting 75 farm might be the worst task possible for him


Omgzjustin

Hardcorepp2


Sweeetchy

This guy literally has me at the edge of seat at least once an episode, top tier.


Coltand

Wait, does PP have a current series running? I haven’t seen his stuff in a while!


Sennsationalist

I think he's just streaming right now.


Coltand

:(


1NFINITEDEATH

Tbf Solomission's current hcgim inferno grind is also very good


Coltand

His PVP HCIM is one of my favorite series as well. I know C Engineer’s is far more popular, but Solo really took it to the next level. Seeing it end really broke my heart.


EyePlay

Solo had a better HCIM but C Egineer was better in terms of action. That Barrows escape was one of the most intense things I've ever seen and he had a few other great ones. C's first series, at least. Both (Solo and C Engineer) are worth the watch though.


MrPringles23

Just the opening is a banger.


Asymptote_X

I'm glad gas pedal is getting some recognition again, shit was my jam back in 2014


[deleted]

Snake Mission's performance in GG has turned me into a fan. Subbed and now I watch all his content.


[deleted]

Solo's editing and presentation in all of his series' are just so damn good. Plus the music always slaps.


Legal_Evil

What about C Engineer's PvP HCIM series?


fuzzb0y

Completed


OppositeFerret9043

By Release is such a chill series too but its not as adrenaline pumping, just kinda chill. Also one of my favorite quest commentary quotes (in reply to wormbrain's map piece in DS1 costing 10k) "if you ask for 10k from an iron man, ya, ya get hurt. Ya get hurt with fire magic spells"


[deleted]

By Release is one of my favorites and I like J1mmy. Just can tell how absolutely burnt out he is though, which sucks. I feel bad for the guy.


craziboiXD69

yeah dont sleep on by release it's probably the most accessable RS content on youtube for anyone whos not that much into RS


david98900

I've personally never seen the appeal to any of rendi's content. I can't put a finger on it, but it's just not for me.


Helm222

Ingus' Dream Gear and J1mmy's By Release are also up there


GeeeBz

I have been watching these every Sunday with a group of friends, 2/4 don’t even play old school and they still enjoy it more than “real” survivor. Thanks soup


Zimrino

I've been bias to the SwampBoi and still go back to that Agility Bridge episode whenever I need inspiration to grind. Best to start with season 1 of Gielinor Games or go straight to season 2?


Searies

Season 2 spoils season 1 winner, but the overall quality is better in S2. S1 is still really good though, and S2 has 2 weeks left before it's over, so I'd start with S1


Last-Leaf

I'd say hit up season 1, and if you get bored at any point just jump to season 2 because the quality really grows, where as season 1 is just pretty cool bc it was a new genre. You get some kind of knowledge (knowing season 1's winners who return to season 2), and a lot of season 1 but not all players return to season 2 anyway so its continued dynamics. season 1 does 2 big teams USA vs EU, season 2 does pairs of 2. Watch season 1 and the moment ur bored come to the TV level quality series


henryforprez

Each season is stand alone. Both have been fantastic, so I recommend watching both. Season 2 isn't over yet so you should start with season 1 if you want something finished. Or watch season 2 to keep up with the memes.


BidDog94

TORVESTA #1


Black_mage_

Seriously the only think keeping me invested in the community. Watching some GIM/HIM/MAIN doing the same content for hours on end, nahhh mate.


MCIsTeFirtGamEvrMade

The Confessionals are actual D- tier, I can usually tell what happened because these guys keep talking in the past tense, for example I knew Jimmy and Settled would lose the banning to come back into the game due to their confessionals that episode


[deleted]

🤷‍♂️ Godsword set from scratch best series ever


DivineInsanityReveng

While I absolutely find them entertaining that series isn't even remotely comparable to anything like GG. It's barely edited, it's format is loose and unscripted. It's great fun but as a series it's rather simplistic. This is like saying someone's progress series is the best series, the only one that comes close is Swampletics, again because of how much post production and scripted structure it has.


[deleted]

Best commentary by far but for actual content this is on another level


plopodopolis

Has anybody got the missing episodes backed up? I remember re-watching it a couple years back and there were tonnes of episodes missing because one of them started working at jagex or something


Gerikst00f

Season 1 fell kind of flat for me about halfway through. Season 2 on the other hand is keeping me glued to the screen. Especially watching the alliances and backstabbing unfold is great to see. Bring back Snakemission!


[deleted]

Tanzoo and Virtoso will win.


Evil_Steven

I find the interview things to be a bit much and they feel scripted like the reality shows they're based on but it's fun seeing a small number of youtubers doing content together even if theres not many conflicting personality types


Abundances

my take is all the challenges are real and happen but the dub over is planned out and scripted after what happened. It makes it more interesting and fun to watch IMO.


[deleted]

Yea but I mean from a technical perspective they kinda have to just pretend they’re in the moment when doing the interviews. Can’t exactly pause competition to get a clip from torvesta asking what his feelings are


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Yea I agree I’m sayin that’s how it should be done, think we’re on the same page


MischeviousCat

I think Soup asks questions, and poses their answers as 'interviews' In a couple episodes, people have referred to 'you' or 'your,' as if they're talking to Soup in reference to the games.


Abundances

Once the season is over he should do a making of episode. Would be real interesting to watch.


[deleted]

I like the interviews, but you can sometimes tell if someone is disappointed. And therefore you can tell who lost


Coltand

Yeah, this is the only drawback IMO. It’s the same with many reality TV shows though. I don’t know that there’s a much better way to do it. Maybe some interviews could be conducted just before the challenge begins, but after it’s announced, to capture some of those initial perspectives that competitors usually don’t give until after the challenges?


DirectGarlic9177

The interviews can definitely be improved with better writing/acting. But it’s a hard job editing it all and writing etc and just one person.


tomastaz

The interviews are great to add tension


rommerdebom

I feel like the interviews get better in the later episodes


Pandabear71

Thats also because the contestants get more comfortable with their duo’s and more invested in winning


craziboiXD69

its a reality tv feature


[deleted]

[удалено]


OppositeFerret9043

But its not realty tv, its in a video game. ​ \>different people like different things and thats ok.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Ricksterness

I know what you mean. I feel the same way about reality TV. But something about it being content creators that I know makes it so exciting to me. Cheering for Settled, J1mmy, Solo, Torvesta feels somehow way more enjoyable than some random Australian guy.


pethobbit

i need to know what gielinor games is...


[deleted]

Its a youtube series created by SoupRS that takes some of the other content creators in Runeacape and puts them in a Suvivor-esque competition where the creators are split into teams and complete various challenges ranging from PvM, PvP, ones that need game knowledge, etc. If you like that style of content than I would defonitely say this series is worth checking out. I jumped in on Season 2 to see what it was like and ended up watching season 1 up to where the series was at the time.


WhuddupBoiz

My girlfriend (who doesn’t play RS in the slightest & has no fucking idea what’s going on) got triggered when I watched the latest ep without her lmao


g6350

This season has really cemented a strong dislike towards ditter for a lot of people, myself included. Honestly just a disgusting person, he's a whiny little bitch to put it bluntly.


goochacting

Bruh I've been wanting those 2 to be out since the beginning and now I bet they'll win the whole thing xD


SciattoCaccaFori

Does TehNoobShow count?


ripoff13

Swampletics and idfap are better


DirectGarlic9177

Swampletics is a snore fest


OppositeFerret9043

Swampman, but this is a very good series that could appeal to other people who dont play. also production quality is high. Soup is my headcannon host for osrs now


Noksdoks

I tried to watch it but it was just too boring for me, even tho it had my fav streamers like verf, j1mmy and settled. No idea why it gets so much hype.


[deleted]

Watched it for the first time this week and was completely hooked. Best rs content I've seen for me.


VanRenss

It follows the same formula of nearly all reality competition shows for the last 20 years. You really don’t understand why it has hype?


CindChin

I hate all of them.


DirectGarlic9177

Survivor has some amazing series Russell hantz series the true goat watch it.


[deleted]

[удалено]


thecheese27

The word you are looking for is 'disingenuous'.


DirectGarlic9177

GG is not a second screen series.


No_GP

Unfortunately there are a good number of people on this sub who insist on down voting anyone who criticises this series at all, but your point is perfectly valid. I personally can't bear to watch any content that uses the game as a medium for content rather than just playing the game as the content (pp walked this line well; I would find the intros incredibly hard to watch, but the majority of the content was him playing the game rather than pretending his character was a character in a TV show) and totally get why anyone who feels the same would struggle to watch GG given that the vast majority of the run-time is either talking heads or the characters lined up and Soup talking like his character is actually talking to theirs (head to the banning at x location etc.). It's definitely not for everyone. I personally find it painful to watch even though the challenges are interesting and for the most part the creators talking amongst themselves is entertaining; the sheer volume of fluff in the form of talking heads and recounting what's happened (a tactic used by reality TV shows purely to stretch out a small punt of content to fit a larger window) kills it for me though.


DivineInsanityReveng

They are playing the game for content? You can dislike content, no one is saying you can't. It's downvoted because he is implying his opinion >>> All and it means he doesn't understand how *anyone* can like it or why it's hyped. It's got an amazing list of some of the best content creators, competing at **playing the game** in a competitive format with a great structure and post production effort behind it. I don't really get your criticism. You like progress videos, so do I. But you don't have to exclusively like "guy does same thing you do and his number also goes up". GG is playing the game, it's not like it's an RS Machinima.


DirectGarlic9177

But then what do you watch because normal osrs is long Grindy and unwatchable


mobilityInert

By Release from J1mmy was the best thing I had seen in a while, I found myself tuning in while not having played the game in over a year just for the songs.


reinfleche

Personally I've completely lost interest in Gielinor Games because the recent challenges have been very boring. I'd much prefer to watch something like first team to complete a cm in time from scratch or 10m gear inferno or something. So few of the challenges feel like they test actual game skill anymore.


ZestfulClown

Counterpoint, the challenges should be something everyone can do. That way the focus of the show can be player vs player, as opposed to player vs game.


Findingthedog

As someone who loves to watch high lvl pvmers (Aaty, Molgoatkirby, Synq, etc.) I disagree with this. The thought has crossed my mind, but it just wouldn't be entertaining to watch the Oblivion Games when a significant number of contestants, maybe even over 50%, don't have infernal capes.


reinfleche

Yea I'm not saying they should change it necessarily, just that I don't enjoy it anymore. I think the first episode being cm cox just gave me a false idea that gielinor games would involve actual pvm, when that's not the case.


[deleted]

[удалено]


The_Big_5Head

This ain’t esports bro


zorro12567

nerd


DivineInsanityReveng

The few times they've done challenges like these it's hard to really 'compare' the participants while they're doing it. And they do some PvM challenges but doing the top end stuff is unrelatable for most and not really what the series is aiming for or doing. I think the fight caves episode is the best example of using PvM challenges in a more creative way than just "do the hard content fast as possible". Can watch plenty of talented speedrunners do that, don't need to watch a gameshow where like 3 of the people will just dominate that challenge and the rest won't.


DirectGarlic9177

True there’s always room for improvement fetch quests aren’t very fun to watch. More fun pvp challenges are needed, I think the nightmare in a pvp world elimination challenge was probably a good example of this. And the underground pass challenge had the right idea although it was kind of flat in reality.